Quantify commits

Quantified Commit Activity Over 14 Days

Developer	Avatar	Branches	PRs	Commits	Files	Changes
beer-1		6	4/3/1	17	17	8392
David Terpay		2	2/2/0	10	12	5724
Eric Warehime		3	1/1/0	3	5	4086
Jun Hyuk Kim		3	0/0/0	18	4	117
John Letey		1	2/2/0	2	4	46
Nikhil Vasan		2	1/1/0	2	2	38
jessie-park		1	1/1/0	1	1	14
Geoff Lee (Vritra4)		1	1/1/0	1	1	11
ALPAC-4		1	0/0/0	1	2	6
Hoon		1	1/1/0	1	1	4
vamsisai		1	2/1/0	1	1	4
David Tumcharoen		1	1/1/0	1	1	2
Dushyant Goswami		1	1/1/0	1	1	2
Uncle Bogdan (freshe4qa)		0	1/0/0	0	0	0
tom (simlecode)		0	1/0/0	0	0	0
Jinu (qj0r9j0vc2)		0	1/0/0	0	0	0
Khanh Hoa (hoanguyenkh)		0	1/0/0	0	0	0

_{PRs: created by that dev and opened/merged/closed-unmerged during the period}

Report On: Fetch commits

Project Overview

The Initia project, managed by the organization Initia Labs, is a comprehensive blockchain solution that integrates a Layer 1 blockchain with a custom Layer 2 infrastructure. This setup creates a cohesive ecosystem of modular networks, allowing for secure scaling of rollups through the OPinit Stack, which supports various virtual machines like EVM, MoveVM, and WasmVM. The project aims to harmonize the economic interests of different stakeholders within the blockchain ecosystem. Key products include InitiaScan, Initia App, Initia Usernames, and Initia Wallet. The project is actively developed in Go and has seen significant activity since its inception on October 12, 2023.

Team Members and Recent Activities

beer-1

• 1 day ago: Fixed account codec for validation and added tests for mstaking params. Set ante handler to lanes to prevent failed transactions from being included again.
  • Files: app/app.go
  • Collaborated with: None
• 4 days ago: Co-authored fix to continue searching for transactions after finding one that exceeds the max bytes/gas limit.
  • Files: app/app.go, app/lanes/proposals.go
  • Collaborated with: Nikhil Vasan (nivasan1)
• 9 days ago: Fixed account codec for validation and added tests for mstaking params.
  • Files: x/mstaking/keeper/msg_server.go, x/mstaking/keeper/msg_server_test.go
  • Collaborated with: None
• 10 days ago: Co-authored patch with CLI fix.
  • Files: go.mod, go.sum
  • Collaborated with: David Terpay (davidterpay)
• 10 days ago: Added genesis marketmap data and other related updates.
  • Files: app/app.go, app/genesis.go, app/genesis_markets/markets.go, app/genesis_markets/utils.go, app/oracle/config.go, client/docs/config.json, client/docs/statik/statik.go, client/docs/swagger-ui/swagger.yaml, cmd/initiad/post_setup.go, cmd/initiad/root.go, go.mod, go.sum
  • Collaborated with: David Terpay (davidterpay), Eric Warehime (Eric-Warehime)

John Letey (johnletey)

• 4 days ago: Updated forwarding module and ran go mod tidy.
  • Files: app/app.go, go.mod, go.sum
  • Collaborated with: None
• 9 days ago: Updated forwarding module and added header info service.
  • Files: app/app.go, app/header_info/service.go, go.mod, go.sum
  • Collaborated with: beer-1

David Tumcharoen (traviolus)

• 4 days ago: Fixed arguments for redelegate transaction command.
  • Files: x/mstaking/client/cli/tx.go
  • Collaborated with: None

Nikhil Vasan (nivasan1)

• 4 days ago: Co-authored fix to continue searching for transactions after finding one that exceeds the max bytes/gas limit.
  • Files: app/app.go, app/lanes/proposals.go
  • Collaborated with: beer-1

Eric Warehime (Eric-Warehime)

• 5 days ago: Bumped blocksdk version.
  • Files: go.mod, go.sum
  • Collaborated with: None
• 10 days ago: Added genesis marketmap data and other related updates.
  • Files: Various files
  • Collaborated with: beer-1, David Terpay (davidterpay)

vamsisai (vamsi4845)

• 5 days ago: Updated README.md to fix broken links related to Initia App and Initia Usernames.
  • Files: README.md
  • Collaborated with: None

Dushyant Goswami (Dushyantgoswami)

• 5 days ago: Updated README.md to correct Twitter link.
  • Files: README.md
  • Collaborated with: None

Hoon (sh-cha)

• 5 days ago: Bug fix for refreshing emergency next tally time.
  • Files: x/gov/abci.go
  • Collaborated with: None

jessie-park

• 5 days ago: Updated README.md.
  • Files: README.md
  • Collaborated with: None

David Terpay (davidterpay)

• 10 days ago:
  • Added genesis marketmap data and other related updates.
  • Applied various patches and updates to CLI and genesis files.
  • Moved JSON data to Go files to include as part of binary.
  • Skipped admin account in genesis setup.
  • Tidied up dependencies and configurations.
  • Updated configurations for new releases.
  • Applied mainline commits pending patch release.
  • Added missing genesis write logic.

Jun Hyuk Kim (joon9823)

• 0 days ago:
  • Bumped xp-indexer version to add week tasks, preload account infos if finalize stage, batch update account infos, load referral map only in finalizeStage, load referral map when initializing, collect xp task only once daily, update xp tasks, bump cosmos-sdk version, update cosmos-sdk version.

Patterns and Conclusions

The recent activities show a highly collaborative environment where multiple team members are frequently contributing to various aspects of the project. A significant portion of the work involves updating modules, fixing bugs, improving performance, and ensuring compatibility across different components. The team appears to be focused on both backend improvements (e.g., codec validations, transaction handling) and user-facing features (e.g., updating documentation links).

The most active contributors include beer-1, who has been involved in numerous fixes and feature implementations across different branches. Other notable contributors include John Letey, David Tumcharoen, Nikhil Vasan, Eric Warehime, vamsisai, Dushyant Goswami, Hoon, jessie-park, David Terpay, and Jun Hyuk Kim.

Overall, the project is in an active development phase with frequent commits addressing both minor fixes and major feature additions. The trajectory suggests continuous improvements aimed at enhancing both functionality and user experience.

Report On: Fetch issues

Analysis of Open Issues for Initia Software Project

Overview

The Initia software project currently has 23 open issues. These issues range from critical bugs and feature requests to minor improvements and documentation updates. Below is a detailed analysis highlighting notable problems, uncertainties, TODOs, and anomalies among the open issues.

Notable Open Issues

Critical Bugs and Functional Issues

1. Issue #175: Auto-lock timer doesn't work

   • Description: The auto-lock timer set to 90 minutes locks the wallet in 3-4 minutes instead.
   • Impact: This significantly affects user experience, especially for those who rely on the auto-lock feature for security.
   • Priority: High
   • Uncertainty: None mentioned, but the issue needs immediate attention.

2. Issue #173: Invalid address on chain

   • Description: An invalid address "64" passed validation but caused a transaction failure.
   • Impact: This could lead to multiple failed transactions and user frustration.
   • Priority: High
   • Uncertainty: The exact cause of why the invalid address passed validation is not clear.

3. Issue #165: Cannot use initiad snapshots commands while node is running

   • Description: Running initiad snapshots commands while the node is active results in an error.
   • Impact: This restricts functionality and could hinder maintenance tasks.
   • Priority: High
   • Uncertainty: Potentially related to system limits (ulimits nofile), but not confirmed.

4. Issue #162: panic: version does not exist

   • Description: A panic occurs with the message "version does not exist".
   • Impact: This could crash the application, leading to downtime and data inconsistency.
   • Priority: High
   • Uncertainty: The root cause of this panic needs investigation.

Usability and User Experience Issues

1. Issue #174: Make wallet to avoid asking for passwords too often

   • Description: The wallet extension frequently asks for passwords when switching tabs.
   • Impact: This is annoying for users and can degrade the overall user experience.
   • Priority: Medium
   • Uncertainty: None mentioned, but user feedback indicates a need for improvement.

2. Issue #156: initia wallet

   • Description: The wallet logs out every 30 seconds to 1 minute, disrupting user activities.
   • Impact: This makes it difficult for users to perform continuous tasks without interruptions.
   • Priority: Medium
   • Uncertainty: Whether this behavior is intentional or a bug is unclear.

3. Issue #151: When the user is transferred to My Page after completing the swap, the pre-swap balance is displayed

   • Description: The balance before the swap is shown until the page is reloaded.
   • Impact: This can confuse users about their actual balance post-transaction.
   • Priority: Medium
   • Uncertainty: None mentioned, but it seems like a refresh issue.

Minor Bugs and Improvements

1. Issue #176: fix: remove account before overwriting to avoid primary constraints

   • Description: Ensures accounts are removed before being overwritten to avoid primary key constraints.
   • Impact: Prevents potential database errors and ensures data integrity.
   • Priority: Low
   • TODOs/Uncertainties:
   • Apply this fix to the EVM side as well.

2. Issue #172: chore: Fix typo in InitiaScan name (README.md)

   • Description: Corrects a typo in the README file for better readability.
   • Impact: Minor improvement in documentation quality.
   • Priority: Low
   • Uncertainty/TODOs:
   • Ensure all documentation maintains consistency in naming conventions.

3. Issue #168: chore: fix typo

   • Description: Fixes a typo in a comment within app/app.go.
   • Impact: Improves code readability and professionalism.
   • Priority: Low
   • Uncertainty/TODOs:
   • None mentioned, straightforward fix.

Feature Requests

1. Issue #163: feat: add Interchaintest

   • Description: Adds Interchaintest for better testing coverage across chains.
   • Impact: Enhances testing capabilities and ensures robustness across different blockchain interactions.
   • Priority: Medium
   • Uncertainty/TODOs:
   • Ensure comprehensive test cases are included.

2. Issue #161: Add permanent Auto-lock timer

   • Description: Requests an option for a permanent auto-lock timer to prevent wallet disconnection.
   • Impact: Provides users with more control over their security settings.
   • Priority: Medium
   • Uncertainty/TODOs:
   • Determine the best implementation approach that balances security and usability.

Recently Closed Issues

1. #171: Fix related to setting ante handlers for lanes, improving modularity and flexibility in handling different types of lanes.
2. #167: Indexer needs auth key only for now; closed recently indicating a focused improvement on indexing requirements.
3. #159: Change default lane prepare logic to continue searching for txs even if one exceeds gas/bytes limit; improves transaction handling efficiency.

Conclusion

The Initia project has several critical issues that need immediate attention, particularly those affecting core functionalities like auto-lock timers, invalid address handling, snapshot commands during node operation, and panic errors. Usability issues also need addressing to improve overall user experience. Minor bugs and documentation improvements are less urgent but still important for maintaining code quality and clarity. Recent closures indicate ongoing efforts to enhance modularity, indexing efficiency, and transaction handling within the project.

Report On: Fetch pull requests

Analysis of Pull Requests for initia-labs/initia

Open Pull Requests

PR #176: fix: remove account before overwriting to avoid primary constraints

• State: Open
• Created: 0 days ago
• Base branch: main
• Head branch: fix/remove-account-before-set
• Review Comments:
  • The RemoveAccount method has been added to the AccountKeeper interface but is not implemented in any of the keeper structs.
  • This is a critical issue as it may lead to interface compliance problems.
  • Action Required: Implement the RemoveAccount method in all relevant keeper structs.

PR #172: chore: Fix typo in InitiaScan name (README.md)

• State: Open
• Created: 1 day ago
• Base branch: initia-labs:main
• Head branch: vamsi4845:main
• Review Comments:
  • Minor correction in the README.md file, changing "InitiaScan" to "Initia Scan".
  • No significant issues noted.

PR #170: fix: Update Dockerfile for building multiplatform clearly.

• State: Open
• Created: 2 days ago
• Base branch: initia-labs:main
• Head branch: qj0r9j0vc2:main
• Review Comments:
  • Significant updates to the Dockerfile to improve architecture handling and streamline library downloads.
  • No notable issues, but thorough testing on different architectures is recommended.

PR #168: chore: fix typo

• State: Open
• Created: 2 days ago
• Base branch: initia-labs:main
• Head branch: simlecode:chore/typo
• Review Comments:
  • Corrected a typo in a comment within the app/app.go file.
  • No significant issues noted.

PR #166: Fix whitespace for Make 4.3

• State: Open
• Created: 3 days ago
• Base branch: initia-labs:main
• Head branch: freshe4qa:patch-1
• Review Comments:
  • Updated the assignment of the whitespace variable in the Makefile.
  • No significant issues noted.

PR #163: feat: add Interchaintest

• State: Open (Draft)
• Created: 4 days ago
• Base branch: initia-labs:main
• Head branch: orbitorg:e2e/ini-test
• Review Comments:
  • Draft status; no review conducted by CodeRabbit.
  • Action Required: Finalize and request a review.

Recently Closed Pull Requests

PR #171: fix: set ante to lanes to conduct VerifyTx at process lanes

• State: Closed (Merged)
• Created/Closed: 1 day ago / 1 day ago
• Base branch: main
• Head branch: fix/set-ante

PR #167: listen auth key only

• State: Closed (Merged)
• Created/Closed: 2 days ago / 2 days ago
• Base branch: initiation/indexer
• Head branch: authkey-only

PR #159: fix: continue searching for txs after finding one that exceeds the max bytes / gas limit

• State: Closed (Merged)
• Created/Closed: 4 days ago / 4 days ago*

PR #157, PR #155, PR #154, PR #148, PR #147, PR #145, PR #144, PR #143, PR #142, PR #141, PR #140, PR #139, PR #138, PR #137, PR #136, PR #135, PR #134, PR #133, PR #132, PR #131, PR #130, PR #129, PR #128, PR #127, PR #126, PR #125 (Draft), PR #124, PR #123, PR #122, PR #121 (Not merged), PR #120, PR #119, PR #118, PR #117, and others have been closed or merged within the last month.

Notable Issues and Recommendations

1. Critical Issue in Open Pull Request:

   • PR #176: The RemoveAccount method has been added to the AccountKeeper interface but is not implemented in any of the keeper structs. This needs immediate attention to ensure interface compliance.

2. Draft Pull Requests:

   • PR[#163](https://github.com/initia-labs/initia/issues/163) and PR[#125](https://github.com/initia-labs/initia/issues/125): These are still in draft status and need finalization and review.

3. Recently Closed Without Merge:

   • PR[#128](https://github.com/initia-labs/initia/issues/128) and PR[#116](https://github.com/initia-labs/initia/issues/116): These were closed without being merged. It is important to understand why these were not merged and if any critical issues remain unresolved.

Overall, while most of the recent pull requests have been successfully merged or closed with minor changes or fixes, attention should be given to implementing missing methods in open pull requests and finalizing draft pull requests for review.

Report On: Fetch Files For Assessment

Source Code Assessment

1. app/app.go

• URL: app/app.go
• Reason: Frequently updated and central to the application's functionality.

Analysis:

• Length: The file is 1498 lines long, indicating a significant amount of logic and complexity.
• Structure: Given its central role, it likely contains core application initialization and configuration logic.
• Quality:
  • Modularity: Should be checked for modularity to ensure maintainability.
  • Error Handling: Proper error handling mechanisms should be in place.
  • Documentation: Adequate comments and documentation are crucial for understanding the flow and purpose of the code.

2. x/mstaking/keeper/msg_server.go

• URL: x/mstaking/keeper/msg_server.go
• Reason: Recently modified and related to staking, a core feature.

Analysis:

• Length: The file is 541 lines long.
• Structure:
  • Contains methods for creating, editing validators, delegating, redelegating, undelegating, and canceling unbonding delegations.
  • Implements the MsgServer interface.
• Quality:
  • Error Handling: Comprehensive error handling is present.
  • Validation: Extensive validation checks for addresses, commission rates, coin denominations, etc.
  • Telemetry: Uses telemetry for monitoring operations like delegation, redelegation, and undelegation.
  • Event Emission: Emits events for significant actions (e.g., creation of validators, delegation).
  • Hooks: Utilizes hooks for actions like after validator creation and before validator modification.

3. app/lanes/proposals.go

• URL: app/lanes/proposals.go
• Reason: Contains logic for handling proposals, critical for governance.

Analysis:

• Length: The file is 173 lines long.
• Structure:
  • Defines a DefaultProposalHandler with methods for preparing and processing lane handlers.
• Quality:
  • Modularity: Well-defined structure with clear separation of concerns (preparing vs. processing proposals).
  • Logging: Extensive logging to track the proposal handling process.
  • Error Handling: Proper error handling mechanisms are in place.
  • Validation & Verification: Ensures transactions are valid and belong to the correct lane.

4. go.mod

• URL: go.mod
• Reason: Manages dependencies and has been frequently updated.

Analysis:

• Length: The file is 239 lines long.
• Structure:
  • Specifies module name (github.com/initia-labs/initia).
  • Lists required dependencies with specific versions.
  • Includes indirect dependencies and replacements for certain modules.
• Quality:
  • Dependencies are well-documented with versions specified.
  • Uses replacements to address specific issues or vulnerabilities (e.g., replacing deprecated or vulnerable packages).

5. x/gov/abci.go

• URL: x/gov/abci.go
• Reason: Recently updated to fix an emergency tally time refresh issue, indicating its importance in governance.

Analysis:

• Length: The file is 422 lines long.
• Structure:
  • Contains the EndBlocker function which processes proposals at the end of each block.
  • Handles inactive, active, and emergency proposals.
• Quality:
  • Comprehensive error handling and logging mechanisms.
  • Uses context caching to ensure state changes are only committed if all operations succeed (CacheContext).
  • Detailed event emission for various proposal states (inactive, active, failed).

6. app/genesis_markets/markets.go

• URL: app/genesis_markets/markets.go
• Reason: Newly added file containing genesis market data essential for initializing markets.

Analysis:

• Length: The file is very large (3993 lines), indicating extensive logic or data definitions.
• Structure & Quality:
  • Likely contains market initialization logic or extensive data structures.
  • Needs to be reviewed for modularity, readability, and maintainability given its size.

7. cmd/initiad/root.go

• URL: cmd/initiad/root.go
• Reason: Part of the command-line interface and has been updated multiple times.

Analysis:

• Length: The file is 343 lines long.
• Structure & Quality:
  • Defines the root command for the CLI application (initiad).
  • Initializes various subcommands (e.g., query commands, transaction commands).
  • Configures client context with encoding settings and home directory paths.

Summary

The analyzed files show a well-maintained codebase with comprehensive error handling, validation checks, logging mechanisms, and modular design principles. However, given the size of some files (e.g., app/app.go, app/genesis_markets/markets.go), there might be opportunities to further improve modularity and readability by breaking down large files into smaller components.