‹ Reports
The Dispatch

The Dispatch Demo - openmeterio/openmeter

Executive Summary

OpenMeter is a cloud-based metering solution designed for AI, billing, and FinOps applications, managed by the organization openmeterio. It enables real-time collection and aggregation of millions of usage events, making it suitable for infrastructure and IoT use cases. The project is actively maintained with 1552 commits and 45 open issues since its inception on June 6, 2023. The overall trajectory of the project is positive, with continuous updates and enhancements.

Recent Activity

Team Members

Recent Commits

Collaboration Patterns

The team demonstrates a collaborative effort with Márk Sági-Kazár leading dependency management, Peter Turi focusing on client SDKs, and Krisztian Gacsal refining core components. Dependabot automates routine updates, ensuring the project stays current.

Issues and PRs

Risks

  1. Flaky Tests (#707):

    • End-to-end tests occasionally fail, undermining CI/CD pipeline reliability.
    • Requires immediate attention to ensure stable releases.

  2. Critical Bugs (#688):

    • Issues with Benthos schedule input affecting data ingestion reliability.
    • Needs resolution to maintain data integrity.

  3. Dependency Updates (#932, #926):

    • Updates to critical dependencies like gRPC could introduce breaking changes if not thoroughly tested.
    • Ensure comprehensive testing before merging.

  4. Technical Debt (#914):

    • Ongoing efforts to refactor codebase indicate technical debt that needs addressing.
    • Prioritize refactoring tasks to improve maintainability.

Of Note

  1. Performance Optimization (#728):

    • Ongoing performance testing efforts are crucial for scaling the project efficiently.

  2. License Compliance (#696):

    • Adding Licensei tool ensures compliance with licensing requirements, important for legal reasons.

  3. API Enhancements (#682):

    • Adding filter capabilities using expression language enhances API functionality.

Conclusion

OpenMeter is a well-maintained project with active development focusing on dependency management, client SDK improvements, and CI enhancements. However, attention is needed on flaky tests and critical bugs to ensure reliability. The project's trajectory is positive with continuous improvements across various aspects of the codebase and infrastructure.

Quantified Commit Activity Over 14 Days

Developer Avatar Branches PRs Commits Files Changes
Peter Turi 3 9/8/2 54 125 22736
Márk Sági-Kazár 3 18/19/0 28 29 5573
dependabot[bot] 5 28/25/0 29 15 2376
Krisztian Gacsal 1 7/7/0 16 7 496
Peter Marton 1 3/4/0 3 6 141
András Tóth 0 0/0/0 0 0 0
OpenMeter Bot (openmeterbot) 0 13/12/1 0 0 0
None (openmeter-bot[bot]) 0 2/0/2 0 0 0

PRs: created by that dev and opened/merged/closed-unmerged during the period

Detailed Reports

Report On: Fetch commits



Project Overview

OpenMeter is a cloud-based metering solution designed for AI, billing, and FinOps applications. It enables the collection and aggregation of millions of usage events in real-time, making it suitable for infrastructure and IoT use cases. The project is managed by the organization openmeterio and is written primarily in Go. Since its creation on June 6, 2023, the project has garnered significant attention with 914 stars and 46 forks on GitHub. The repository is active with 1552 commits and 45 open issues, indicating ongoing development and maintenance. The overall trajectory of the project appears positive, with continuous updates and enhancements being made.

Team Members and Recent Activities

Márk Sági-Kazár (sagikazarmark)

dependabot[bot]

Peter Turi (turip)

Krisztian Gacsal (chrisgacsal)

Peter Marton (hekike)

Patterns and Conclusions

The recent activities indicate a strong focus on dependency management and client SDK updates across multiple languages (Node.js, Python, Web). Márk Sági-Kazár has been particularly active in merging dependency updates and improving CI configurations.

Dependabot has played a crucial role in automating dependency updates, ensuring that the project remains up-to-date with the latest versions of its dependencies.

Peter Turi has been heavily involved in generating client SDKs and making significant improvements to the API and internal logic.

Krisztian Gacsal has focused on refining the sink-worker component by reverting changes that might have introduced issues or were not aligned with the project's direction.

Overall, the team demonstrates a collaborative effort towards maintaining code quality, updating dependencies promptly, and enhancing various aspects of the project through well-coordinated commits and pull requests.

Report On: Fetch issues



Analysis of Open Issues for openmeterio/openmeter

Overview

The repository currently has 45 open issues, with a mix of dependency updates, feature requests, refactoring tasks, and bug reports. Several issues have been created recently, indicating ongoing active development. Below is a detailed analysis of the notable problems, uncertainties, disputes, TODOs, and anomalies among the open issues.

Notable Problems and Uncertainties

Dependency Updates

  • #932: update-grpc
    • Created very recently (0 days ago). This issue might be related to the ongoing dependency update efforts.
  • #926: chore(deps): bump google.golang.org/grpc from 1.63.2 to 1.64.0
    • Also created 0 days ago by Dependabot. This update includes deprecations and behavior changes that could affect existing functionality.
  • #922: chore(deps): bump the k8s group with 2 updates
    • Created 0 days ago by Dependabot. This involves updating Kubernetes dependencies which might require thorough testing to ensure compatibility.

Feature Requests and Enhancements

  • #898: Bulk query
    • Created 7 days ago. This feature requires an API design session, indicating it is still in the planning phase.
  • #897: Add tracing support to Benthos collector
    • Created 7 days ago. This enhancement aims to implement OTEL tracing support for better observability.
  • #428: OpenMeter .NET 8 SDK
    • Created 186 days ago but recently edited. There is interest from contributors to start implementing this SDK.

Refactoring and Technical Debt

  • #920: chore: remove PR checklist for now
    • Created 3 days ago. The removal of the PR checklist suggests a possible re-evaluation of the project's development process.
  • #737: refactor: use new framework for list events endpoint
    • Created 53 days ago. This refactor aims to improve the codebase by adopting a new framework.
  • #914: refactor: get rid of ULID type usage
    • Recently closed but indicates ongoing efforts to simplify or standardize ID handling within the project.

Bug Reports and Anomalies

  • #707: The e2e test fails occasionally
    • Created 63 days ago. This issue highlights flaky end-to-end tests that could undermine confidence in CI/CD pipelines.
  • #688: Benthos schedule input does not exhaust non-batch inputs
    • Created 69 days ago. This bug affects data ingestion reliability when using Benthos with scheduled inputs.

Performance and Optimization

  • #728: Feat/perf testing
    • Created 56 days ago. This issue focuses on comparative performance tests, which are crucial for ensuring efficient resource utilization.
  • #700: Benchmark ClickHouse queries
    • Created 64 days ago. This benchmarking task aims to compare different query execution strategies in ClickHouse.

Disputes and Discussions

  • #696: feat: add Licensei
    • Created 66 days ago with ongoing discussions about license management and compliance.
  • #680: Support GPT Assistant API ?
    • Created 72 days ago with discussions about extending support for GPT Assistant API, which could attract more users but requires careful consideration of implementation details.

Recently Closed Issues (Context)

Several issues have been closed recently, indicating active progress:

  • #931, #930, #929, #928, #927, etc., all closed within the last day or so, mostly related to dependency updates and minor fixes.

Summary

The project is actively maintained with a focus on dependency management, feature enhancements, refactoring, and addressing technical debt. There are ongoing discussions around significant new features like bulk queries and tracing support. Some critical bugs related to test flakiness and data ingestion need attention to ensure reliability. Performance optimization tasks are also underway, which are crucial for scaling the project efficiently.

Overall, the project appears to be in a healthy state with continuous improvements being made across various aspects of the codebase and infrastructure.

Report On: Fetch pull requests



Analysis of Pull Requests for openmeterio/openmeter

Open Pull Requests

  1. #932: update-grpc

    • State: Open
    • Created: 0 days ago
    • Details: Updates gRPC and removes deprecated API usage.
    • Notable: This PR is very recent and involves critical updates to gRPC, which might impact the overall functionality if not handled properly.

  2. #926: chore(deps): bump google.golang.org/grpc from 1.63.2 to 1.64.0

    • State: Open
    • Created: 0 days ago
    • Details: Dependency update for gRPC.
    • Notable: Similar to #932, this PR also deals with gRPC updates, indicating a significant focus on updating gRPC dependencies.

  3. #922: chore(deps): bump the k8s group with 2 updates

    • State: Open
    • Created: 0 days ago
    • Details: Updates Kubernetes dependencies.
    • Notable: Important for maintaining compatibility with Kubernetes.

  4. #920: chore: remove PR checklist for now

    • State: Open
    • Created: 3 days ago
    • Details: Removes the PR checklist as it is deemed not useful at this stage.
    • Notable: This change might affect the review process and quality control.

  5. #879: chore(deps): bump next from 14.0.3 to 14.1.1 in /examples/customer-dashboard-nextjs

    • State: Open
    • Created: 10 days ago
    • Details: Updates Next.js dependency in an example project.
    • Notable: Dependency update for a specific example project, less critical but still important for consistency.

  6. #833: chore(deps-dev): bump black from 24.3.0 to 24.4.2 in /api/client/python in the development-dependencies group

    • State: Open
    • Created: 21 days ago
    • Details: Development dependency update for Python client.
    • Notable: Ensures code formatting and style consistency.

  7. #843: docs(config): extend configuration example OM-521

    • State: Open
    • Created: 17 days ago
    • Details: Extends configuration example documentation.
    • Notable: Improves documentation, which is beneficial for new users and contributors.

  8. #809: chore(deps-dev): bump the development-dependencies group across 1 directory with 15 updates

    • State: Open
    • Created: 28 days ago
    • Details: Multiple development dependency updates.
    • Notable: Significant updates that could impact development workflows.

  9. #765: chore(deps): bump openapi-typescript-fetch from 1.1.3 to 2.0.0 in /api/client/web in the production-dependencies group

    • State: Open
    • Created: 45 days ago
    • Details: Major version update for a production dependency.
    • Notable: Major version updates can introduce breaking changes; requires careful review.

  10. #737: refactor: use new framework for list events endpoint

    • State: Open
    • Created: 53 days ago
    • Details: Refactors list events endpoint using a new framework.
    • Notable: Refactoring core functionalities can have widespread impacts; needs thorough testing.

  11. #728: Feat/perf testing

    • State: Open (Draft)
    • Created: 56 days ago
    • Details: Adds performance tests comparing projections with materialized views.
    • Notable: Performance testing is crucial but this PR is still in draft, indicating ongoing work.

  12. #696: feat: add Licensei

    • State: Open
    • Created:: 66 days ago – Details: Adds Licensei tool and license headers to all files. – Notable: Ensures compliance with licensing requirements; important for legal reasons.

13. 682: feat(api): filter with expression language     – State: Open     – Created: 70 days ago     – Details: Adds filter capabilities using expression language.     – Notable: Enhances API functionality; still in draft indicating ongoing work.

14. 634:* test: add failing test for empty group by     – State: Open     – Created: 88 days ago     – Details: Adds a test case for empty group by scenarios.     – Notable: Identifies potential issues early; still in draft.*

15. 631: fix(api): make windowSize optional     – State: Open     – Created: 89 days ago     – Details: Makes windowSize parameter optional.     – Notable: Minor fix but improves API usability.

16. 563: ci: image status test*     – State: Open (Draft)     – Created: 117 days ago     – Details: Tests custom image status reporting.     – Notable: CI-related changes are critical but this PR is still in draft.

Closed Pull Requests

  1. 931: test(e2e): increase eventual timeout     – Closed without merging     – Details: Increases timeout to avoid flaky e2e tests.     – Significance: Addresses stability issues in tests.

  2. 930: chore(deps): bump cachix/install-nix-action from 26 to 27     – Merged     – Details: Dependency update.     – Significance: Routine maintenance.

  3. 929: chore(deps): bump dagger/dagger-for-github from 5.5.0 to 5.6.0*     – Merged     – Details: Dependency update.     – *Significance: Routine maintenance.

4. 928: chore(deps): bump github/codeql-action from 2.3.3 to 3.25.5     – Merged     – Details: Dependency update.*     – Significance: Routine maintenance.

5. 927: chore(deps): bump actions/checkout from 4.1.5 to 4.1.6     – Merged     – Details: Dependency update.*     – Significance: Routine maintenance.

6. 925: chore(deps): bump github.com/huandu/go-sqlbuilder from 1.27.1 to 1.27.2     – Merged     – Details: Dependency update.*     – Significance: Routine maintenance.

7. 924: chore(deps): bump github.com/getkin/kin-openapi from 0.123.0 to 0.124.0     – Merged     – Details: Dependency update.*     – Significance: Routine maintenance.

8. 923: chore(deps): bump github.com/avast/retry-go/v4 from 4.5.1 to 4.6.0     – Merged     – Details: Dependency update.*     – Significance: Routine maintenance.

9. 921: chore(deps): bump golang from 2a88224 to f1fe698     – Merged     – Details: Dependency update.*     – Significance: Routine maintenance.

10.* [bot] Re-generate Python client (#919) 11.[bot] Re-generate Node.js client (#918) 12.[bot] Re-generate Web client (#917) 13.revert:sink worker changes (#916) 14.fix improve entitlements API (#915) 15.refactor:get rid of ULID type usage (#914) 16.ci fix snapshot job (#913) 17.chore(api)update openapi formatting (#912) 18.ci integrate stainless (#911) 19.feat(sink-worker)make some Kafka parameters configurable (#910) 20.[bot] Re-generate Node.js client (#909) 21.[bot] Re-generate Web client (#908) 22.[bot] Re-generate Python client (#907) 23.refactor(sink-worker)use main context on flush (#906) 24.feat(otel)use conventional environment tag (#905) 25.feat:on ledger creation return the existing ledger if exists (#904) 26.feat mk broker.address.family configurable (#903) 27.feat(openmeter)export new kafka collector (#902) 28.feat(backend)add ingest event counter metric (#901) 29.refactor use http framework for features (#900) 30.feat:add support for upserting ledgers by subject (#899) (Closed without merging)

Noteworthy Observations

  • The project has several open PRs related to dependency updates, especially around gRPC and Kubernetes, which are critical components.
  • There are multiple drafts and open PRs related to performance testing and refactoring core functionalities, indicating ongoing significant changes.
  • Some PRs were closed without merging, such as #899, which aimed to add support for upserting ledgers by subject, suggesting either a change in priority or unresolved issues.
  • Recently closed PRs mainly involve routine dependency updates and minor fixes, reflecting active maintenance.

Recommendations

  • Prioritize reviewing and merging critical dependency updates like #932 and #926 to ensure compatibility and security.
  • Address ongoing drafts like #728 (performance testing) and #682 (API filtering) as they can significantly impact performance and functionality.
  • Monitor the impact of removing the PR checklist as per #920 on the quality of future contributions.
  • Ensure thorough testing of refactoring changes like #737 to avoid introducing bugs into core functionalities.

This detailed analysis should help prioritize efforts and maintain the project's stability while incorporating necessary updates and improvements.

Report On: Fetch PR 932 For Assessment



PR #932: update-grpc

Overview

This pull request (PR) aims to update the gRPC library and refactor the code to remove the use of a deprecated API. The changes are minimal but significant, as they involve updating a core dependency and refactoring parts of the codebase that interact with it.

Changes

  1. Update gRPC Library:

    • Updated google.golang.org/grpc from version 1.63.2 to 1.64.0.
    • Updated golang.org/x/oauth2 from version 0.17.0 to 0.18.0.

  2. Refactor Deprecated API Usage:

    • Modified the collector/benthos/output/otel_log.go file to replace the deprecated grpc.DialContext method with the new grpc.NewClient method.

Files Changed

  • collector/benthos/output/otel_log.go:

    • Replaced: go conn, err := grpc.DialContext(ctx, out.address, grpc.WithBlock(), grpc.WithTransportCredentials(insecure.NewCredentials())) with: go conn, err := grpc.NewClient(out.address, grpc.WithTransportCredentials(insecure.NewCredentials()))

  • go.mod:

    • Updated dependencies: ```diff
    • google.golang.org/grpc v1.63.2
    • google.golang.org/grpc v1.64.0
    • golang.org/x/oauth2 v0.17.0
    • golang.org/x/oauth2 v0.18.0 ```

  • go.sum:

    • Updated checksums for the new versions of google.golang.org/grpc and golang.org/x/oauth2.

Code Quality Assessment

  1. Dependency Management:

    • The PR correctly updates the dependencies in both go.mod and go.sum files.
    • The updates are minor version bumps, which generally indicate backward-compatible improvements or additions.

  2. Code Refactoring:

    • The refactor in otel_log.go is straightforward and replaces a deprecated method with its recommended alternative.
    • The change ensures that the codebase remains up-to-date with the latest gRPC API, reducing potential technical debt and future-proofing the application.

  3. Impact Analysis:

    • Given that gRPC is a core dependency, this update could have wide-reaching effects on how services communicate within the application.
    • It's crucial to run comprehensive integration tests to ensure that all services interacting via gRPC continue to function correctly after this update.

  4. Commit Messages:

    • The commit messages are clear and follow a consistent format, making it easy to understand the purpose of each change.
    • Example: "chore: update grpc" and "refactor(benthos-collector): remove use of deprecated API".

Recommendations

  • Testing: Ensure that all unit tests and integration tests pass successfully after this update. Pay special attention to any tests related to gRPC communication.
  • Documentation: If there are any internal documents or onboarding guides that reference specific versions of dependencies, consider updating them to reflect these changes.
  • Monitoring: After deploying these changes, monitor the application closely for any unexpected behavior or performance issues related to gRPC communication.

Conclusion

This PR is well-executed and addresses both dependency management and code refactoring effectively. With thorough testing and monitoring post-deployment, this update should enhance the robustness and maintainability of the codebase.

If you have any further questions or need additional assistance, feel free to ask!

Report On: Fetch Files For Assessment



Source Code Assessment

Repo: openmeterio/openmeter

.github/workflows/ci.yaml

Structure and Quality Analysis

  1. Job Definitions:

    • The CI configuration is well-structured with multiple jobs (build, test, lint, commit-hooks, dev, artifacts, dependency-review, fossa-scan, quickstart, e2e, and dagger).
    • Each job has a clear purpose and is logically separated.

  2. Use of Actions:

    • Uses various GitHub actions like actions/checkout, cachix/install-nix-action, and custom actions for specific tasks.
    • The use of pinned versions for actions ensures stability and reproducibility.

  3. Environment Variables:

    • Environment variables are defined at the top level, making it easy to manage configurations like DAGGER_VERSION.

  4. Steps:

    • Each job contains well-defined steps with clear names, making the workflow easy to follow.
    • The use of Nix for environment setup is consistent across jobs, ensuring a standardized development environment.

  5. Error Handling:

    • There is no explicit error handling in the steps, but the structure ensures that any failure in a step will halt the subsequent steps.

  6. Security:

    • Secrets like GITHUB_TOKEN and DAGGER_CLOUD_TOKEN are used securely via GitHub secrets.
    • Permissions are minimized where possible (e.g., read-only permissions for certain jobs).

Recommendations

  • Consider adding caching mechanisms where applicable to speed up the CI process.
  • Ensure that all secrets are rotated regularly and monitored for unauthorized access.

api/api.gen.go

Structure and Quality Analysis

  1. Generated Code:

    • This file appears to be auto-generated, likely from an OpenAPI specification or similar schema.
    • Generated files often contain boilerplate code that follows a consistent pattern, which seems to be the case here.

  2. Readability:

    • Generated code can be verbose and harder to read due to its boilerplate nature.
    • However, it is generally not meant to be manually edited, so readability is less of a concern compared to hand-written code.

  3. Functionality:

    • The file likely contains API endpoint definitions, request/response models, and possibly client functions.
    • Ensure that the generation process is well-documented so that developers know how to regenerate this file when needed.

Recommendations

  • Regularly regenerate this file as part of the CI process to ensure it stays up-to-date with the API specification.
  • Avoid manual edits to this file; instead, make changes in the source schema or specification.

api/openapi.yaml

Structure and Quality Analysis

  1. OpenAPI Specification:

    • This file defines the API endpoints, request/response models, authentication methods, etc.
    • It follows the OpenAPI 3.0 specification, which is standard for RESTful APIs.

  2. Documentation:

    • The OpenAPI spec provides a single source of truth for the API, useful for both developers and automated tools.
    • Ensure that all endpoints, parameters, and models are well-documented within this file.

  3. Validation:

    • Use tools like Swagger Editor or OpenAPI validators to ensure the spec is correctly formatted and valid.

Recommendations

  • Regularly review and update this file as the API evolves.
  • Use this specification to generate client SDKs and server stubs where possible.

cmd/server/main.go

Structure and Quality Analysis

  1. Initialization:

    • The main server entry point initializes various components like configuration, logging, telemetry (metrics/tracing), health checks, Kafka ingestion, ClickHouse client, etc.
    • Uses libraries like chi for routing, slog for logging, OpenTelemetry for metrics/tracing.

  2. Configuration Management:

    • Configuration is managed using Viper and pflag, which are standard libraries for configuration management in Go.
    • The configuration is validated before use, ensuring that required fields are present.

  3. Error Handling:

    • Errors during initialization (e.g., configuration loading, database connection) cause the application to panic, which is appropriate during startup.
    • Runtime errors are logged appropriately using structured logging.

  4. Graceful Shutdown:

    • Uses a run group to manage goroutines and handle graceful shutdown on receiving termination signals (SIGINT/SIGTERM).

  5. Modularity:

    • Initialization functions (initKafkaIngest, initClickHouseClient, etc.) are modularized, improving readability and maintainability.

Recommendations

  • Consider breaking down this large file into smaller modules if it grows further.
  • Ensure comprehensive unit tests cover each initialization function.

config/config.go

Structure and Quality Analysis

  1. Configuration Structs:

    • Defines a hierarchical configuration structure using nested structs (e.g., TelemetryConfig, AggregationConfiguration).

  2. Validation:

    • Implements validation logic within each configuration struct's Validate method.

  3. Defaults:

    • Sets default values using Viper's SetDefault method for various configuration options.

  4. Environment Variables:

    • Supports environment variable overrides using Viper's automatic environment variable binding.

  5. Flag Binding:

    • Binds command-line flags to configuration fields using pflag.

Recommendations

  • Ensure all critical configuration fields have validation logic.
  • Document all configuration options in a central place (e.g., README or separate documentation file).

internal/credit/credit.go

Structure and Quality Analysis

  1. Data Models:

    • Defines data models related to credit management (Grant, Reset, etc.).

  2. Constants and Enums:

    • Uses constants and enums for fixed values (e.g., ExpirationPeriodDuration, EntryType).

  3. Error Handling:

    • Defines custom error types for specific error conditions (GrantNotFoundError, LedgerAlreadyExistsError).

  4. Methods:

    • Implements methods on data models for business logic (e.g., calculating expiration dates).

  5. JSON Serialization:

    • Uses struct tags for JSON serialization/deserialization (json:"fieldName").

Recommendations

  • Ensure comprehensive unit tests cover all business logic methods.
  • Consider adding more comments/docstrings for complex methods or data structures.

internal/sink/sink.go

Structure and Quality Analysis

  1. Sink Logic:

    • Implements logic for consuming messages from Kafka topics and processing them (deduplication, validation, storage).

  2. Buffering and Flushing:

    • Buffers messages in memory before flushing them based on time or count thresholds.

  3. Metrics and Tracing:

    • Integrates with OpenTelemetry for metrics (messageCounter, flushEventCounter) and tracing (Tracer).

  4. Namespace Management:

    • Manages namespaces dynamically by subscribing/unsubscribing from Kafka topics based on namespace changes.

  5. Error Handling:

    • Handles errors at various stages (parsing messages, deduplication check) with appropriate logging and retry mechanisms.

  6. Graceful Shutdown:

    • Listens for termination signals to gracefully shut down the sink process.

Recommendations

  • Ensure comprehensive unit tests cover all critical paths (message parsing, deduplication check, storage).
  • Consider adding more comments/docstrings for complex methods or data structures.

internal/server/router/router.go

Structure and Quality Analysis

  1. Router Initialization:

    • Initializes HTTP routes using chi router.
    • Registers custom body decoders for CloudEvents content types with openapi3filter.

  2. Handler Interfaces & Configurations

    • Defines interfaces (IngestHandler) and configurations (Config) required by the router.
    • Config struct includes dependencies like credit connectors, namespace managers, streaming connectors etc., ensuring modularity.

  3. Router Implementation

    • Implements router struct conforming to ServerInterface from generated API code (api.ServerInterface).
    • Initializes credit handlers if credit connector is provided in config.

  4. Error Handling

    • Uses custom error handlers from errorsx package ensuring consistent error responses across routes.

Recommendations

  • Ensure comprehensive unit tests cover all routes & handlers initialized by router.
  • Consider adding more comments/docstrings explaining purpose of each route & handler.

Overall assessment indicates well structured codebase following best practices around modularity , error handling , configuration management & observability . Some areas can benefit from additional documentation & unit test coverage .