Quantify commits

Quantified Commit Activity Over 14 Days

Developer	Avatar	Branches	PRs	Commits	Files	Changes
goat		4	0/0/0	51	107	3435
Blair (Critical-Impact)		2	4/5/1	4	62	2498
None (Haselnussbomber)		3	4/4/0	3	6	679
KazWolfe		3	3/2/1	31	38	545
Infi (Infiziert90)		1	2/1/0	1	11	334
Anna		1	1/1/0	1	3	123
None (Aireil)		2	2/2/0	2	2	22
Mira (Koenari)		1	1/1/0	1	1	2
GitHub Web Flow		1	0/0/0	1	1	2
None (bleatbot)		0	4/3/1	0	0	0
None (MidoriKami)		0	2/1/1	0	0	0
kal (kalilistic)		0	0/1/0	0	0	0

_{PRs: created by that dev and opened/merged/closed-unmerged during the period}

Report On: Fetch commits

Development Team and Recent Activity

Team Members and Their Recent Activities

goaaats

• Recent Commits: 51 commits with significant changes across multiple files and branches.
• Areas of Work: Enabled binary formatter in nuke project, targeted build project to .NET 8.0, allowed Windows targeting for Dalamud, updated auto-update features, and worked on plugin installer enhancements.
• Collaborations: Involved in various branches including apiX, apiX-rollup, revert-1860-fix-onsetup-hook, and csupdate-master.

anna-is-cute

• Recent Commits: Added /xlcopylog command to copy the dalamud.log file to the clipboard.
• Areas of Work: Focused on enhancing user interaction with log files.

KazWolfe

• Recent Commits: 31 commits focusing on updates and bug fixes.
• Areas of Work: Updated ClientStructs, fixed issues related to game lifecycle hooks, and contributed to API updates.
• Collaborations: Active in branches like apiX and apiX-rollup.

Infiziert90

• Recent Commits: Updated MarketBoard related packet structs.
• Areas of Work: Focused on network structures and their accurate representation in the codebase.

Haselnussbomber

• Recent Commits: Contributed to enhancing configuration options and fixing lifecycle hooks.
• Areas of Work: Worked on improving the addon lifecycle management and configuration settings.

Aireil

• Recent Commits: Fixed anti-debugging features and corrected party member visibility.
• Areas of Work: Focused on security features and visibility settings within the game client.

Koenari

• Recent Commits: Corrected visibility settings for party members.
• Areas of Work: Minor but crucial fixes related to game client states.

Critical-Impact

• Recent Commits: Major refactoring efforts to make interfaces from non-public/sealed classes.
• Areas of Work: Focused on improving code architecture and accessibility for plugin development.

MidoriKami, bleatbot, and others

• Minor or indirect contributions through PR reviews or specific feature enhancements without direct commits during the analyzed period.

Patterns, Themes, and Conclusions

1. High Activity in Enhancements and Refactoring:

   • The team is actively working on enhancing existing features like auto-updates, plugin installers, and lifecycle management. There is a strong emphasis on refactoring to improve code quality and maintainability.

2. Focus on Plugin Development Support:

   • Many commits revolve around improving the developer experience for plugin creators, such as better API handling, improved lifecycle hooks, and enhanced debugging capabilities.

3. Collaborative Efforts Across Branches:

   • There is significant collaboration across different branches indicating a well-coordinated effort in managing features and fixes across the project’s scope.

4. Security and Stability:

   • Updates related to anti-debugging features and client structure adjustments suggest a focus on maintaining security and stability within the software.

5. Continuous Integration and Deployment:

   • Frequent updates to build configurations and project targets indicate an ongoing effort to keep the development environment up-to-date with modern standards (e.g., .NET versions).

The team's recent activities demonstrate a robust approach to both enhancing user-facing features and strengthening backend processes, ensuring a stable yet progressive development environment.

Report On: Fetch issues

Recent Activity Analysis

The recent activity in the goatcorp/Dalamud GitHub repository shows a consistent flow of issue creation and resolution, with a noticeable focus on enhancing existing features, addressing bugs, and refining the API for better usability and performance. Several issues have been closed recently, indicating active maintenance and responsiveness to community feedback and needs.

Notable Issues and Themes

1. ClientStructs Updates: Multiple issues (#1868, #1826, #1814, #1813) relate to updating ClientStructs, suggesting ongoing adjustments to keep up with game updates or changes in data structures. This is crucial for maintaining compatibility and functionality of plugins relying on this data.

2. API Enhancements: Issues like #1820 and #1807 indicate efforts to make the API more robust and developer-friendly by introducing interfaces for non-public classes and improving service implementations.

3. Error Handling Improvements: Several issues address error handling and system resilience. For instance, #1867 focuses on fixing anti-debug measures, while #1851 aims to improve the plugin installer's robustness against failures.

4. Performance Enhancements: Issues such as #1834 and #1829 suggest a focus on performance improvements, either through code optimization or better lifecycle management of add-ons and services.

5. User Experience Improvements: Issues like #1842 aim to enhance user experience by making more commands visible in help sections, potentially making the platform more user-friendly for new users.

Commonalities and Patterns

• Frequent Updates to Core Components: Regular updates to critical components like ClientStructs indicate a need to keep pace with external changes (e.g., game updates).
• Enhancing Developer Tools and Documentation: Many issues focus on improving the clarity and usability of the API, which is essential for plugin developers.
• Focus on Stability and Error Handling: Several issues aim to improve error handling and system stability, which is crucial for ensuring a smooth user experience.

Issue Details

Most Recently Created Issue

• Issue #1871: Add clientstruct widget
  • Priority: Medium
  • Status: Open
  • Created: 0 days ago by Infi (Infiziert90)

Most Recently Updated Issue

• Issue #1851: [master] Update ClientStructs
  • Priority: High
  • Status: Closed
  • Created: 9 days ago by None (bleatbot)
  • Updated: 0 days ago

These issues highlight ongoing efforts to refine Dalamud’s capabilities and ensure its stability and effectiveness as a tool for the Final Fantasy XIV community. The focus on both developer-facing improvements and end-user experience enhancements suggests a balanced approach to maintaining and evolving the platform.

Report On: Fetch pull requests

Analysis of Open and Recently Closed Pull Requests in goatcorp/Dalamud

Open Pull Requests

Notable PRs

1. PR #1871: Add clientstruct widget

   • Status: Open
   • Summary: Adds a new widget for displaying client structures related to proxy addresses.
   • Concerns: None indicated from the description. It's a new feature addition that might need thorough testing to ensure it doesn't affect existing functionalities.

2. PR #1865: Add font properties to IUiBuilder

   • Status: Open
   • Summary: Enhances IUiBuilder with font properties to match static counterparts.
   • Concerns: The PR seems straightforward but could impact UI elements across plugins using Dalamud if not properly integrated.

3. PR #1857: Use IconFontFixedWidth

   • Status: Open
   • Summary: Adjusts the icon font width, potentially affecting UI alignment and design across plugins that use this feature.
   • Concerns: Changes in UI elements need careful review to avoid visual regressions.

4. PR #1853: [apiX] Dalamud API X to Mainline

   • Status: Open (Draft)
   • Summary: Major API changes preparing for integration into the main branch.
   • Concerns: Being a draft and a major change, this PR requires extensive review and testing to ensure compatibility and stability.

5. PR #1852: [apiX] Rollup changes from master

   • Status: Open
   • Summary: Regular rollup PR to keep the apiX branch updated with master branch changes.
   • Concerns: Routine operation, but essential to maintain branch consistency and integration readiness.

PRs Needing Attention

• PR #1843: Implement hook stacking and priorities
  • This PR introduces significant changes to how hooks are managed, which could impact plugin interactions fundamentally if not handled correctly.

Recently Closed Pull Requests

Merged PRs

1. PR #1868: Update MarketBoard related packet structs

   • Merged recently and included updates to MarketBoard structures which are crucial for plugins interacting with market data.

2. PR #1867: fix anti debug

   • A quick fix merged that addresses anti-debugging measures, important for maintaining the security aspects of the project.

3. PR #1866: Correct PartyMember visibility

   • This minor yet crucial fix ensures correct visibility settings for PartyMember, which could impact features related to party management in plugins.

Not Merged PRs

• PR #1864: Allow InterfaceManager fonts to be null
  • Was closed without merging. It proposed changes that would allow more flexibility during development but raised concerns about potential impacts in production environments.

Summary

The project is currently handling a mix of routine updates, significant feature enhancements, and crucial fixes. The open PRs suggest active development in enhancing the API capabilities and UI elements, while the closed PRs reflect ongoing efforts to maintain code quality and project integrity. Special attention may be needed for PRs like #1843 due to their potential widespread impact on how plugins interact with the core system. Additionally, the draft PR #1853 indicates preparation for major changes, suggesting a pivotal development phase for the project.

Report On: Fetch Files For Assessment

Analysis of Source Code Files

1. AutoUpdateManager.cs

Structure and Quality

• Purpose: Manages automatic updates for plugins, including scheduling updates, handling user notifications, and executing update logic.
• Design Patterns: Utilizes dependency injection for service dependencies, indicating a well-structured approach to managing dependencies.
• Error Handling: Includes logging for various states (verbose, error), which aids in debugging and monitoring the update process.
• Concurrency: Uses Task for asynchronous operations, ensuring that the UI thread is not blocked during long-running operations like plugin updates.
• Code Quality:
  • Good use of constants for time intervals makes the code more readable and maintainable.
  • Proper separation of concerns is observed; the class is solely responsible for update logic.
  • The use of an enum (UpdateListingRestriction) for update restrictions enhances readability and maintainability.

Potential Improvements

• Exception Handling: While logging is implemented, explicit exception handling around critical update operations could be improved to ensure stability.
• Configuration Dependency: Direct dependency on DalamudConfiguration suggests tight coupling. Using an interface could decouple the configuration management.

2. PluginInstallerWindow.cs

Structure and Quality

• Purpose: Manages the UI and interactions for installing, updating, and managing plugins.
• Size: The file is extremely large (4095 lines), which could indicate that it handles multiple responsibilities or contains complex logic that might be better modularized.
• Code Quality:
  • Due to its size, it's likely challenging to maintain. Splitting this into smaller components or services could improve maintainability.
  • The complexity suggested by its size could also hinder unit testing.

3. PluginCategoryManager.cs

Structure and Quality

• Purpose: Manages plugin categories for filtering and display in the Plugin Installer Window.
• Design Patterns:
  • Uses data structures effectively to map plugins to categories, facilitating efficient category management.
• Code Quality:
  • Well-documented with summaries explaining methods and properties, which improves readability.
  • Uses enums to define category types, enhancing code clarity and reducing errors.

Potential Improvements

• Refactoring: Some methods appear lengthy; breaking these down into smaller methods could improve readability and testability.

4. BattleNpc.cs

Structure and Quality

• Purpose: Represents a battle NPC in the game client state.
• Simplicity: The class is straightforward, extending BattleChara with specific properties relevant to NPCs.
• Code Quality:
  • Minimalist design appropriate for its function, enhancing understandability.
  • Proper use of inheritance shows good OOP practice.

5. ContextMenu.cs

Structure and Quality

• Purpose: Handles interactions with the game's context menu including custom menu items added by plugins.
• Complexity:
  • Contains complex logic for managing menu items, including hooks into game functions which adds to its complexity.
• Code Quality:
  • Use of hooks and low-level memory manipulation indicates a deep integration with the game client, suggesting this file is critical and sensitive to changes in the game client.
  • Well-segmented into methods handling specific parts of the context menu lifecycle.

Potential Improvements

• Error Handling: Enhanced error handling around hooking and memory operations could prevent potential crashes or undefined behaviors.

Conclusion

The reviewed files generally exhibit good software engineering practices with clear structuring and responsibility segregation. However, improvements in error handling, decoupling, and breaking down large files could further enhance maintainability and robustness.