‹ Reports
The Dispatch

GitHub Repo Analysis: public-apis/public-apis

Executive Summary

The project in focus is the GitHub repository public-apis/public-apis, managed by the organization public-apis. It serves as a curated list of free APIs for developers, categorized across various domains like Animals, Anime, and Business. The repository is highly popular, evidenced by its significant number of stars and forks, and it is maintained actively with contributions primarily in Python. The overall trajectory of the project is positive with regular updates and active community involvement.

Key Points:

Recent Activity

Team Members and Contributions:

Recent Issues:

Recent Pull Requests:

These activities indicate a focus on maintaining up-to-date and accurate API listings and expanding the repository's offerings.

Risks

  1. Repetitive and Spam Issues: Multiple issues from the same user lacking content could indicate spam, reducing the quality of discussions and potentially leading to management overhead.
  2. Perception of Project Neglect: Issue #3484 suggests some users believe the original repository is no longer active, which could divert potential contributors to forked versions, diluting efforts on the main project.
  3. Duplicate Pull Requests: Instances of multiple PRs for the same update (e.g., PR #3937 and PR #3936) suggest a need for better coordination or clearer contribution guidelines.

Of Note

  1. High Fork Rate: The repository has been forked over 32,000 times, indicating significant interest and possibly leading to multiple divergent versions of the project.
  2. License Type: Operating under the MIT License, which promotes wide adoption and modification, potentially contributing to the high engagement level.
  3. Global Contributor Base: The diversity in the contributor team spans multiple continents, reflecting global interest and varied input into the project’s evolution.

Quantified Reports

Quantify commits



Quantified Commit Activity Over 14 Days

Developer Avatar Branches PRs Commits Files Changes
APILayer 1 0/0/0 1 1 2
Adam Ross (R055A) 0 2/0/0 0 0 0
Ingo (in60dev) 0 1/0/1 0 0 0
lkchen (lk-chen) 0 1/0/0 0 0 0
Wenbin Fang (wenbinf) 0 1/0/0 0 0 0
Marc Paquette (masvmarc) 0 1/0/0 0 0 0
Kyle Calica (stcalica) 0 1/0/1 0 0 0
Mitul Patel (bittricky) 0 3/0/2 0 0 0
Peter (karussell) 0 1/0/0 0 0 0
None (The-Wolfson) 0 1/0/0 0 0 0
Benjamin Brasseur (benjaminbra) 0 1/0/0 0 0 0
Birdkalon (prechayimmee) 0 1/0/0 0 0 0
Ezekiel A. Tobiloba (zeekielcodes) 0 2/0/0 0 0 0
Vinn (vinn-capsolver) 0 1/0/0 0 0 0
Fabian Noll (FabianRolfMatthiasNoll) 0 1/0/0 0 0 0

PRs: created by that dev and opened/merged/closed-unmerged during the period

Detailed Reports

Report On: Fetch issues



Recent Activity Analysis

The GitHub repository public-apis/public-apis has recently seen a mix of activities ranging from fixing broken links to addressing outdated API references. The most recent issues primarily focus on updating links and documentation, which is crucial for maintaining the utility and accuracy of the repository as a reliable resource for developers.

A notable anomaly is the presence of multiple issues opened by the same user, Santiago Mafla Gonzalez, which are repetitive and lack specific content, suggesting either spam or testing error. Additionally, issue #3484 indicates that the original project may be considered dead by some community members, directing users to a forked version of the repository.

Common themes among the issues include:

  • Updates and fixes for API links.
  • Suggestions for using alternative repositories due to dissatisfaction with current management or updates.
  • General maintenance tasks like updating documentation files.

Issue Details

Most Recently Created Issues

  • Issue #3943: "Optimising Nursing Education: The Significance of Custom Writing Services" - Priority: Unknown, Status: Open, Created 0 days ago by MaryCathy.
  • Issue #3942: "Fix: Old link of Jokes > Excuser API" - Priority: Unknown, Status: Open, Created 0 days ago by Rayyan Nafees.

Most Recently Updated Issues

  • Issue #3932: "Cartes.io API link is legacy" - Priority: Unknown, Status: Open, Created 5 days ago by Adam Ross, Last Edited 1 day ago.
  • Issue #3484: "USE THIS REPO INSTEAD: https://github.com/public-apis-dev/public-apis" - Priority: Unknown, Status: Open, Created 480 days ago by Andrei (andrei-cb), Last Edited 7 days ago.

These issues reflect ongoing efforts to keep the repository relevant and useful amidst evolving external resources and changing project status perceptions.

Report On: Fetch pull requests



Analysis of Pull Requests in the public-apis/public-apis Repository

Notable Open Pull Requests

  1. PR #3944: Improve GraphHopper description

    • Status: Open
    • Created: 0 days ago
    • Description: This PR aims to improve the description of the GraphHopper API by linking directly to the "GraphHopper Directions API" and emphasizing the Route Optimization API.
    • Significance: Enhances clarity and relevance of API description in the README, which could help users better understand the offerings of GraphHopper.

  2. PR #3941: Add CapSolver API

    • Status: Open
    • Created: 0 days ago
    • Description: Addition of the CapSolver API, which provides AI-powered automated CAPTCHA solutions.
    • Significance: Introduces a new API to the collection, expanding the utility of the repository for developers needing CAPTCHA solutions.

  3. PR #3940: Add Podcast API to News

    • Status: Open
    • Created: 1 day ago
    • Description: This PR adds a new Podcast API under the News category but lacks details on compliance with contribution guidelines.
    • Significance: Expands the News category but needs review for guideline compliance.

  4. PR #3939: Replacing Nordigen by GoCardless

    • Status: Open
    • Created: 1 day ago
    • Description: Updates the API listing from Nordigen to GoCardless due to acquisition and service integration.
    • Significance: Keeps the API list updated with current service providers, reflecting accurate and up-to-date information.

  5. PR #3938: Added U.S Food Central API

    • Status: Open
    • Created: 3 days ago
    • Description: Adds a new entry for the U.S Department of Agriculture's FoodData Central API.
    • Significance: Provides users with access to a government database for food nutrient data, enhancing the repository's value in health and nutrition app development.

Recently Closed Pull Requests

  1. PR #3937: Added U.S Deptartment of Agriculture food central api

    • Status: Closed without merge
    • Closed: 3 days ago
    • Reason for Closure: It appears this PR was closed without merging, possibly due to duplication as another similar PR (#3938) was opened around the same time.
    • Significance: Indicates possible coordination issues among contributors or duplication of efforts.

  2. PR #3936: [API]: U.S Department of Agriculture food API

    • Status: Closed without merge
    • Closed: 3 days ago
    • Reason for Closure: Similar to PR #3937, this seems redundant as there is another similar PR addressing the same API addition. Significance: Highlights potential improvements needed in managing PRs and avoiding duplications.

Summary

The repository is actively receiving contributions that expand its utility by adding new APIs and updating existing ones. However, there are instances of duplicate PRs which indicate a need for better coordination or a clearer contribution process. The open PRs are generally well-aligned with the repository's goal of providing a comprehensive list of public APIs, though some may require additional scrutiny to ensure they meet all contribution guidelines.

Report On: Fetch Files For Assessment



Source Code Assessment

General Overview

The source code provided spans multiple Python scripts primarily focused on data validation and testing. The scripts are part of a larger application that seems to handle data related to APIs, possibly for a public repository or a similar platform. The primary functionalities include formatting validation, link validation, and their respective tests.

Detailed Analysis

1. scripts/validate/format.py

  • Purpose: Validates the formatting of data entries.
  • Structure:
    • Functions for specific validation tasks (e.g., check_title, check_description).
    • A main function (check_file_format) orchestrates the validation process.
  • Quality:
    • Well-structured with clear separation of concerns.
    • Uses regular expressions for pattern matching which is efficient for the given task.
    • Error handling is done through custom messages which aids in debugging.
  • Potential Improvements:
    • Could benefit from more comments explaining the regular expressions.
    • Exception handling could be added for file operations.

2. scripts/validate/links.py

  • Purpose: Validates the accessibility and correctness of URLs in the dataset.
  • Structure:
    • Functions to find links, check duplicates, and validate link accessibility.
    • Utilizes requests library for HTTP operations which is suitable for link validation tasks.
  • Quality:
    • Functions are focused and perform single tasks which is good practice.
    • Includes user agent randomization to avoid detection by web servers during link validation, showing attention to real-world usage scenarios.
  • Potential Improvements:
    • Error handling could be more robust, especially in network request functions to handle potential runtime issues better.

3. scripts/tests/test_validate_format.py

  • Purpose: Tests the formatting validation logic.
  • Structure:
    • Uses Python’s unittest framework for testing which is appropriate for such testing needs.
    • Test cases are well-defined for various scenarios including edge cases.
  • Quality:
    • Comprehensive tests that cover most of the functionality in the formatting validation script.
    • Makes good use of setup methods to prepare test data which is efficient.
  • Potential Improvements:
    • Could add more negative test cases to ensure the robustness of the format validations.

4. scripts/tests/test_validate_links.py

  • Purpose: Tests the link validation logic.
  • Structure:
    • Similar to test_validate_format.py, it uses unittest framework.
    • Tests various functionalities like link finding, duplication checking, and accessibility checking.
  • Quality:
    • Tests are specific and seem to cover significant parts of the link validation script.
    • Use of mock objects or responses could be observed which is good for testing external requests.
  • Potential Improvements:
    • More comprehensive tests on network failures could enhance reliability.

Conclusion

The codebase is generally well-structured with a clear focus on functionality and maintainability. The use of Python standards and practices in both scripting and testing is evident. However, there are areas such as error handling and negative test cases where improvements could be made to enhance robustness and fault tolerance.

Report On: Fetch commits



Development Team and Recent Activity

Team Members:

  • APILayer (apilayer-admin)
  • Kyle Calica (stcalica)
  • Matheus Felipe (matheusfelipeog)
  • Zaldy Pagaduan Jr. (zopagaduanjr)
  • FayeNichols
  • Diego Parrilla (diegoparrilla)
  • Arne Stittrich (Stitti)
  • S.G. Sudhakar (sudhakar76)
  • Yann Bertrand (yannbertrand)
  • Avi Mamenko (amamenko)
  • seanwlk
  • Roanna Victorio (roannav)
  • Agrim Prasad (AgrimPrasad)
  • caroline (caroldinh)
  • Savičs (Exerra)
  • mike (htimsekim)
  • Gregory Saint-Jean (GregSaintJean)

Recent Activity:

  1. APILayer:

    • Updated README.md 14 days ago.
    • Involved in multiple updates and merges, including adding new APIs and removing broken links.

  2. Kyle Calica:

    • Added postman logos, removed dead links, created popular APIs and Categories section, new copy 132 days ago.

  3. Matheus Felipe:

    • Involved in extensive updates 860 days ago, including adding new APIs to various categories and removing broken or outdated ones.
    • Added Threat Jammer to Security and Owen Wilson Wow to Video categories.

  4. Zaldy Pagaduan Jr.:

    • Added PRC Exam Schedule to Government category.

  5. FayeNichols:

    • Added Hirak OCR to Text Analysis and Hirak IP to Country to Geocoding categories.

  6. Diego Parrilla:

    • Added Threat Jammer to Security category.

  7. Arne Stittrich:

    • Added MFaaS to Video category.

  8. S.G. Sudhakar:

    • Added WhatJobs to Jobs category.

  9. Yann Bertrand:

    • Involved in reverting multiple commits related to README.md updates and file uploads.

  10. Avi Mamenko:

    • Added Owen Wilson Wow API to Video category.

  11. seanwlk:

    • Added Warface to Games & Comics category.

  12. Roanna Victorio:

    • Added National Park Service API to Government category.

  13. Agrim Prasad:

    • Added Lecto Translation to Text Analysis category.

  14. caroline:

    • Added Website Carbon to Environment category.

  15. Savičs:

    • Added NoPhishy to Anti-Malware category.

  16. mike:

    • Fixed typo in the upcoming events description.

  17. Gregory Saint-Jean:

    • Noted the deprecation of traditional APIs by Indeed.

Patterns, Themes, and Conclusions:

The recent activities show a strong focus on updating and maintaining the API listings with current and functional links, as well as expanding the categories with new APIs relevant to current technological trends such as security, video content, and environmental concerns. The team collaborates extensively on updating resources, indicating a well-coordinated effort in keeping the repository relevant and useful for developers looking for public APIs across a wide range of categories. The removal of broken links and outdated APIs is also a recurring theme, ensuring the quality and reliability of the repository's contents.