Quantify commits

Quantified Commit Activity Over 14 Days

_{PRs: created by that dev and opened/merged/closed-unmerged during the period}

Report On: Fetch issues

Recent Activity Analysis

The repository "whisper-diarization" by MahmoudAshraf97 has been actively addressing issues related to the integration of speaker diarization with OpenAI's Whisper model. The project aims to enhance Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) by accurately identifying and attributing spoken content to individual speakers within audio files.

Notable Issues and Themes

1. Dependency and Installation Challenges:

   • Several issues, such as #154, #157, and #136, highlight problems with dependency conflicts and installation processes on different systems, including Windows and Debian WSL. These issues often involve conflicts between package versions or difficulties in setting up the environment.

2. Diarization Accuracy:

   • Issues like #99 and #113 indicate challenges with the diarization accuracy where all dialogue is attributed to a single speaker, suggesting potential improvements in the diarization algorithm or parameter tuning.

3. Error Handling and Bug Fixes:

   • Various errors have been reported, such as RuntimeError (#116, #105), IndexError (#103), and TypeError (#165). These errors are often related to specific functions within the codebase or compatibility issues with external libraries.

4. Feature Requests and Enhancements:

   • Users have requested additional features like support for more languages (#134) and output formats (#132), indicating a demand for more versatile functionality.

5. Performance Issues:

   • Reports of kernel crashes in Jupyter notebooks (#104) and performance bottlenecks when processing lengthy audio files (#106) suggest that there are opportunities to optimize the system for better stability and efficiency.

Commonalities Among Issues

• Many issues are related to installation difficulties and compatibility problems with dependencies, reflecting the need for a more robust setup process.
• Errors during execution, particularly with longer audio files, indicate potential memory management issues or inefficiencies in processing.
• Requests for additional language support and output formats highlight the need for the tool to be more adaptable to various user requirements.

Issue Details

Most Recently Created Issue

• Issue #202: "Cannot import name 'ModelFilter' from 'huggingface_hub'"
  • Created 23 days ago by Tibo (thibaudbrg)
  • Closed 22 days ago
  • Priority: High
  • Status: Closed
  • Last Updated: 22 days ago

Most Recently Updated Issue

• Issue #188: "Conflicting dependencies while installing requirements.txt"
  • Created 81 days ago by Anshuman Parida (AnshumanParidaIL)
  • Last Edited 1 day ago
  • Priority: High
  • Status: Open
  • Updates involve ongoing discussions about dependency conflicts and errors encountered during installation.

These issues reflect critical areas needing attention, primarily focusing on enhancing the installation process, improving error handling, and expanding functionality to meet user demands.

Report On: Fetch pull requests

Analysis of Pull Requests for the Repository: MahmoudAshraf97/whisper-diarization

Overview

The repository "whisper-diarization" by MahmoudAshraf97 focuses on integrating speaker diarization capabilities with OpenAI's Whisper model for enhanced Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR). The project has seen significant community engagement and active contributions.

Detailed Review of Notable Pull Requests

Closed Pull Requests Without Merge

1. PR #205: Pin Critical Dependencies

   • Summary: This PR aimed to pin critical dependencies (transformers and huggingface-hub) to specific versions to address compatibility issues.
   • Problem: Closed without merging due to concerns about potential future conflicts with other dependencies and the outdated version of transformers being pinned.
   • Impact: The rejection of this PR leaves the project at risk of encountering compatibility issues that the PR aimed to resolve.

2. PR #144: Add initial prompt argument support

   • Summary: Introduced an "initial prompt" argument to improve transcription accuracy by providing context.
   • Problem: Closed without merging, but no explicit reason provided in the available data.
   • Impact: The project misses out on potentially improved transcription accuracy that could have been beneficial for users requiring context-driven ASR.

3. PR #155: Add support for any language diarization

   • Summary: Added support for diarization in any language by allowing users to upload custom wav2vec2 models.
   • Problem: Closed without merging as it became redundant after the merge of PR #184, which provided a more integrated solution for multilingual support.
   • Impact: While the specific implementation in PR #155 was not merged, its objectives were indirectly achieved through another update, minimizing any negative impact.

Significant Merged Pull Requests

1. PR #184: Change alignment library from whisperx to ctc-forced-aligner

   • Summary: This PR replaced the alignment library to improve processing speed and reduce dependency complexities.
   • Benefits: Enhanced performance with a reported 2x speed increase and simplified model management for deployment scenarios.
   • Drawbacks: The new default model has a non-commercial license, which could limit its use in certain environments.

2. PR #167: Update requirements.txt so faster-whisper==1.0.0 is used

   • Summary: Updated dependency to a newer version of faster-whisper to resolve compatibility issues.
   • Outcome: Successfully merged, ensuring that the project uses an updated and compatible version of an essential dependency.

General Observations

• The repository maintains an active approach towards updating and refining its dependencies and functionalities, as seen in PRs like #167 and #184.
• Issues related to dependency management (e.g., PR #205) highlight ongoing challenges in maintaining a stable development environment amidst rapidly evolving external libraries.
• The project benefits from a responsive community that engages with proposed changes, as evidenced by detailed discussions in PRs like #184.

Recommendations

1. Establish a Clear Policy on Dependency Management: To avoid issues like those attempted to be addressed in PR #205, a clear policy or strategy for managing dependencies should be developed, possibly incorporating automated tools for dependency updates and conflict checks.

2. Enhance Documentation on Handling Licenses: Given the licensing issues discussed in PR #184, enhancing documentation to guide users on handling different licenses and suggesting alternative models could be beneficial.

3. Encourage Community Contributions with Clear Guidelines: Continue encouraging community contributions by providing clear contribution guidelines, especially on critical aspects like dependency updates and new feature proposals.

This analysis provides insights into the current state of the repository's pull requests, highlighting both achievements and areas for improvement in managing an open-source project with significant community involvement.

Report On: Fetch Files For Assessment

Source Code Assessment

General Overview

The repository "whisper-diarization" by MahmoudAshraf97 integrates OpenAI's Whisper model for Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) with additional tools for speaker diarization. The project uses various technologies like Whisper, NeMo, and Demucs to enhance the diarization process. The repository includes Python scripts, a Jupyter Notebook, and YAML configuration files.

Detailed Analysis

1. diarize.py

Structure and Functionality

• Imports: Standard libraries for system operations, audio processing (torchaudio), and machine learning (torch).
• Argument Parsing: Uses argparse to handle command-line inputs for audio file processing.
• Audio Processing: Includes options for source separation using demucs, transcription via Whisper, and numeral suppression for better diarization accuracy.
• Model Loading and Inference: Loads alignment models and performs forced alignment using ctc_forced_aligner.
• Error Handling: Basic logging for errors in source separation.
• Output: Saves transcriptions and speaker diarization results in various formats including text and SRT.

Quality Assessment

• Readability: Code is generally well-structured with clear separation of functionality and use of descriptive variable names.
• Error Handling: Includes basic logging but could be expanded to handle more specific exceptions or errors.
• Performance: Implements batch processing for efficiency but lacks detailed profiling or optimization comments.

2. helpers.py

Structure and Functionality

• Utility Functions: Provides numerous helper functions for file handling, configuration setup, language processing, and cleanup tasks.
• Language Support: Extensive mapping of languages to ISO codes which supports the multilingual capabilities of Whisper.
• Configuration Management: Dynamically creates configuration files for NeMo models based on domain types.

Quality Assessment

• Modularity: Functions are well-decomposed, each performing a single task, which aids in maintenance and testing.
• Hardcoding: Some paths and settings are hardcoded which might limit flexibility in different environments.

3. nemo_msdd_configs/diar_infer_general.yaml

Structure and Functionality

• Configuration Settings: Detailed settings for VAD, speaker embeddings, clustering, and diarization parameters.
• Flexibility: Allows customization of numerous parameters affecting the diarization process.

Quality Assessment

• Clarity: While comprehensive, the file is dense with configurations which might be overwhelming without adequate documentation.

4. Whisper_Transcription_+_NeMo_Diarization.ipynb

Structure and Functionality

• Interactive Demonstration: Provides a step-by-step guide through the diarization process using Whisper and NeMo.
• Code Cells: Includes code for installation of dependencies, audio processing, transcription, alignment, and diarization.
• Documentation: Each step is well-documented with markdown cells explaining the processes.

Quality Assessment

• Usability: Highly usable as an educational tool or for demonstration purposes due to its interactive nature.
• Reproducibility: Includes fixed versions for dependencies ensuring consistent behavior across different setups.

Conclusion

The repository provides a robust framework for integrating Whisper with advanced diarization techniques. While the code quality is generally high with good practices in modularity and documentation, areas such as error handling and dependency management could be further improved. The inclusion of a Jupyter Notebook enhances usability significantly by providing an interactive environment for users to experiment with the technology.

Report On: Fetch commits

Development Team and Recent Activity

Team Members and Recent Commits

Mahmoud Ashraf (MahmoudAshraf97)

• Recent Activities:
  • Updated installation steps, compatibility adjustments, and formatting changes.
  • Worked on integrating and updating libraries like ctc-forced-aligner and demucs.
  • Addressed issues related to punctuation in speech recognition outputs.
  • Enhanced the project with new installation steps and library transitions.
  • Co-authored a commit for adding long-form audio speaker diarization.

Alexuh (ALEXuH)

• Recent Activities:
  • Co-authored a commit with Mahmoud Ashraf for adding long-form audio speaker diarization.

transcriptionstream

• Recent Activities:
  • Updated requirements.txt to use a specific version of faster-whisper.
  • Co-authored by Mahmoud Ashraf.

Bastian Schulz (gexxxter)

• Recent Activities:
  • Upgraded faster-whisper to resolve dependency conflicts.
  • Co-authored by Mahmoud Ashraf.

Joseph Martinez (josephrmartinez)

• Recent Activities:
  • Corrected typographical errors in documentation.

Zach Graber (zacharygraber)

• Recent Activities:
  • Resolved edge case issues with .txt output files.
  • Co-authored by Mahmoud Ashraf.

jamesqh

• Recent Activities:
  • Improved robustness in filename-extension splitting.

Stefan Moises (smxsm)

• Recent Activities:
  • Added device argument support for CPU, specifically addressing compatibility with Silicon M1.
  • Co-authored by Mahmoud Ashraf.

Federico Torrielli (federicotorrielli)

• Recent Activities:
  • Simplified requirements and added command line options.
  • Co-authored by Mahmoud Ashraf.

WiegerWolf

• Recent Activities:
  • No direct commits in the past 14 days but involved in a PR activity.

Patterns, Themes, and Conclusions

• Mahmoud Ashraf is the most active contributor, handling a wide range of updates from bug fixes to feature enhancements. His work spans across all technical aspects of the project including dependency management, feature additions, and documentation updates.

• There is significant collaboration within the team, as evidenced by multiple co-authored commits. This suggests a cooperative development environment where contributions from various team members are integrated frequently.

• The recent activities focus heavily on maintaining compatibility with different systems and enhancing the functionality of the software to handle more complex audio processing tasks like long-form diarization and punctuation handling in transcriptions.

• The project shows a pattern of continuous improvement with regular updates to address both user-reported issues and enhancements suggested by the developers themselves.

Overall, the development team behind the "whisper-diarization" project demonstrates a strong commitment to advancing the project's capabilities while ensuring stability and compatibility across different platforms.