‹ Reports
The Dispatch

OSS Report: reorproject/reor


Reor Project Development Stagnates Amidst Dependency Management and UI Enhancements

The Reor Project, an AI-powered desktop note-taking application focused on privacy and local data storage, has seen limited progress in terms of new feature development over the past month, with most activities centered around dependency updates and UI improvements.

Recent Activity

Recent issues and pull requests indicate a focus on maintaining existing functionality rather than introducing new features. Key issues include enhancements to the markdown editor (#351) and improvements to the writing assistant (#350). The team is also addressing bugs affecting user experience, such as installation difficulties on Windows (#338) and database initialization errors (#320).

Development Team and Recent Activity

Of Note

  1. Dependency Management Focus: A significant portion of recent activity involves updating dependencies, suggesting a priority on maintaining security and compatibility rather than new feature development.

  2. UI/UX Refinements: Continuous efforts to enhance the user interface indicate a focus on improving user experience despite limited new feature rollouts.

  3. Installation Challenges: Persistent installation issues on Windows could impact user adoption and need urgent resolution.

  4. Complexity in Feature Implementation: Draft PRs like #266 for custom prompts remain unresolved, highlighting challenges in implementing complex features.

  5. Community Feedback Integration: The project actively incorporates user feedback into its development process, as seen in PRs addressing user-reported issues.

Quantified Reports

Quantify Issues



Recent GitHub Issues Activity

Timespan Opened Closed Comments Labeled Milestones
7 Days 11 1 6 9 1
30 Days 16 13 25 12 1
90 Days 41 30 88 36 1
All Time 156 68 - - -

Like all software activity quantification, these numbers are imperfect but sometimes useful. Comments, Labels, and Milestones refer to those issues opened in the timespan in question.

Quantify commits



Quantified Commit Activity Over 30 Days

Developer Avatar Branches PRs Commits Files Changes
MohamedIlaiwi 1 0/0/0 7 42 57723
milaiwi 1 2/1/1 14 35 1122
Sam L'Huillier 3 5/4/0 16 26 998
Lawrence Li 1 1/1/0 5 1 371
None (dependabot[bot]) 1 6/0/5 1 2 61
Donz 1 0/0/0 1 1 2
Jose Playero 1 0/0/0 1 1 2
None (razorback21) 0 1/1/0 0 0 0
Tushar Karan (tusharkaran) 0 1/0/0 0 0 0

PRs: created by that dev and opened/merged/closed-unmerged during the period

Detailed Reports

Report On: Fetch issues



Recent Activity Analysis

The Reor project has seen a flurry of activity, with numerous issues being created and updated recently. Notably, there is a focus on improving user experience and functionality, such as enhancing the markdown editor (#351), integrating LLM tools in chat (#347), and addressing bugs related to writing assistants (#348, #349). There is also significant interest in expanding the app's capabilities, as evidenced by requests for new features like spell-checking (#258) and support for additional file formats (#276).

Several issues stand out due to their complexity or potential impact on user experience. Issue #338 highlights installation difficulties on Windows, which could hinder user adoption. Issue #320 describes a persistent error during database initialization, indicating potential stability concerns. The discussion around issue #286 suggests ongoing challenges with rendering formulas and images correctly in notes. Additionally, issue #296 points to the need for enhanced flashcard functionality, which could significantly improve the app's educational utility.

Themes among the issues include a strong emphasis on improving the markdown editor's capabilities, enhancing integration with other tools and platforms, and addressing user-reported bugs to ensure a smooth user experience. There is also a clear focus on expanding the app's feature set to cater to diverse user needs.

Issue Details

Most Recently Created Issues

  • #351: Update Editor Markdown

    • Priority: Not specified
    • Status: Open
    • Created: 1 day ago
  • #350: Writing assistant improvements

    • Priority: Not specified
    • Status: Open
    • Created: 4 days ago

Most Recently Updated Issues

  • #345: Improve the context controls for chat window

    • Priority: Not specified
    • Status: Open
    • Created: 4 days ago
    • Updated: 0 days ago
  • #337: 2024 ROADMAP

    • Priority: Not specified
    • Status: Open
    • Created: 15 days ago
    • Updated: 3 days ago

These issues reflect ongoing efforts to enhance the application's functionality and address user feedback promptly.

Report On: Fetch pull requests



Overview

The dataset provides a list of open and closed pull requests (PRs) for the Reor Project, an AI-powered desktop note-taking application. The PRs cover a variety of updates, including new features, bug fixes, dependency updates, and code refactoring.

Summary of Pull Requests

Open Pull Requests

  1. #342: Introduces changes to the formula editor and adds a new TipTap Pro extension for mathematics. It requires installing specific dependencies and includes discussions on making the mathematics extension optional.
  2. #330: Updates five npm and yarn packages, including electron-updater and vite, to their latest versions.
  3. #336: Renames files related to OpenAI with comments on logic and style improvements needed in the code.
  4. #266: Draft PR for setting up custom prompts, indicating ongoing work with significant changes in chat-related components.
  5. #191: Draft PR to add text focus from related notes, which is yet to be fixed due to formatting issues.

Closed Pull Requests

  1. #339: Adds tab support, improves UI elements, and addresses overflow issues. It was merged after resolving several review comments.
  2. #319: A backup for UI tab changes that was not merged but led to further development in #339.
  3. #335: Fixes a search debounce issue in the file sidebar.
  4. #334: Changes markdown copy behavior in the editor settings.
  5. #333: Modifies GitHub workflow to continue on error during builds.
  6. #332: Fixes a chat deletion issue reported by users.
  7. #329 - #325: Series of dependency bumps for various packages like braces, vite, follow-redirects, ejs, and electron-updater.
  8. #324: Enforces line endings to LF across the project.
  9. #321: Fixes UI issues with the AI writing assistant's generated text positioning.
  10. #317 - #313: Series of PRs focused on code styling, linting fixes, and reverting previous changes for cleanup purposes.

Analysis of Pull Requests

The pull requests reveal several key themes and trends within the Reor Project's development:

  1. Feature Enhancements: The project is actively enhancing its feature set, as seen in PRs like #342 (mathematics extension) and #339 (tab support). These updates aim to improve user experience by adding functionality that aligns with modern note-taking needs.

  2. Dependency Management: A significant portion of the closed PRs (#330, #329 - #325) are dedicated to updating dependencies, ensuring that the project remains secure and up-to-date with the latest improvements from third-party libraries.

  3. UI/UX Improvements: Multiple PRs focus on refining the user interface and experience (#339, #321). This indicates a strong emphasis on making the application more intuitive and visually appealing, which is crucial for user retention in desktop applications.

  4. Bug Fixes and Code Quality: There is a continuous effort to address bugs (#332) and improve code quality through linting and stylistic adjustments (#310). This reflects a commitment to maintaining a stable and high-quality codebase.

  5. Community Engagement and Feedback Integration: The project seems responsive to community feedback, as seen in PRs addressing user-reported issues (#332) and incorporating suggestions for improvements (#321).

  6. Ongoing Development Challenges: Some PRs remain open or in draft status due to unresolved issues or ongoing discussions (#266, #191). This highlights challenges in implementing complex features or achieving consensus on certain design decisions.

Overall, the Reor Project demonstrates active development with a balanced focus on new features, maintenance, UI enhancements, and community-driven improvements. The project's commitment to local AI processing for privacy sets it apart from competitors, aligning well with current trends towards data privacy and decentralized computing solutions.

Report On: Fetch commits



Repo Commits Analysis

Development Team and Recent Activity

Team Members and Activities

  • Jose Playero (joseplayero)

    • Recent Activity: Bumped version in package.json.
    • Collaborations: None reported.
    • Work in Progress: None reported.
  • MoTheRoar (milaiwi)

    • Recent Activity: Added tab support, cleaned up codebase, fixed sidebar issues, and made UI adjustments. Significant changes across multiple files for tab support and UI improvements.
    • Collaborations: Merged pull requests from other branches.
    • Work in Progress: Continued improvements on UI and tab functionalities.
  • Mohamed Ilaiwi (mohamedilaiwi)

    • Recent Activity: Added tab support, cleaned up codebase, and made UI enhancements. Large number of changes in recent commits.
    • Collaborations: Worked on merging branches related to tab support.
    • Work in Progress: Ongoing UI enhancements and tab functionality improvements.
  • Sam L'Huillier (samlhuillier)

    • Recent Activity: Addressed lint issues, added PostHog to writing assistant, worked on AI model integration, and renamed files. Engaged in multiple pull requests.
    • Collaborations: Merged pull requests with contributions from other team members.
    • Work in Progress: Continued work on AI model integration and frontend logic.
  • Lawrence Li (weilirs)

    • Recent Activity: Fixed lint issues, worked on writing assistant features, and integrated custom prompts. Engaged in merging upstream changes.
    • Collaborations: Merged remote-tracking branches into the writing assistant branch.
    • Work in Progress: Enhancements to the writing assistant feature.
  • Donz

    • Recent Activity: Fixed delete chat issue with minor changes.
    • Collaborations: None reported.
    • Work in Progress: None reported.
  • Dependabot[bot]

    • Recent Activity: Automated dependency updates for several packages.
    • Collaborations: None reported.
    • Work in Progress: Ongoing dependency management.

Patterns and Themes

  • Focus on Tab Support: A significant portion of recent activity revolves around adding and refining tab support within the application. This includes UI adjustments and codebase cleanup to accommodate this new feature.

  • Codebase Cleanup: Multiple team members have been involved in cleaning up the codebase, indicating a focus on improving code quality and maintainability.

  • AI Model Integration: There is ongoing work related to integrating AI models more effectively into the application, including bypassing content filtering and setting up new configurations.

  • UI/UX Improvements: Continuous efforts are being made to enhance the user interface and experience, as seen in various commits addressing styling issues and dynamic UI components.

  • Collaboration: The team exhibits a collaborative approach with frequent merges of branches and pull requests, suggesting active teamwork across different features and fixes.

Conclusions

The development team is actively working on enhancing the application's functionality with a strong emphasis on tab support and UI improvements. There is a concerted effort towards maintaining code quality through regular cleanups. Integration of AI models remains a priority, aligning with the project's core focus on local AI processing. The team's collaborative dynamics are evident through frequent merges and shared responsibilities across features.