FreeAskInternet, a project aimed at providing a private, locally running search aggregator using multiple LLMs without GPU requirements, has seen no recent development activity from its sole contributor, nash_su, since April 2024. Despite this, the project has attracted significant community interest, evidenced by over 8,000 stars on GitHub.
The project currently has 60 open issues and pull requests, with user-reported challenges primarily centered around Docker configurations and LLM integrations. The community has been active in discussing these issues, indicating a strong user base eager to resolve setup difficulties. Notably, Issue #89 highlights critical failures in retrieving content from LLMs, while Issues #57 and #30 point to persistent Docker-related errors. These issues suggest a need for improved documentation and clearer setup instructions.
Summary
Quantified Reports
Detailed Reportsdocker-compose.yaml.Community Engagement vs. Solo Development: Despite high community interest and engagement, development remains a solo effort by nash_su with no recent contributions.
Critical Bug Reports: Issue #89's failure to retrieve LLM content is significant, potentially impacting user trust and adoption.
Documentation Gaps: Frequent user-reported setup issues indicate that existing documentation may not be sufficient for less experienced users.
Stagnant Codebase: No code commits or pull requests have been merged recently, suggesting a potential slowdown in active development.
High Star Count vs. Open Issues: The project's popularity contrasts with the number of unresolved issues, highlighting a gap between user interest and project stability or usability.
| Timespan | Opened | Closed | Comments | Labeled | Milestones |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 7 Days | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 30 Days | 1 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 1 |
| 90 Days | 7 | 2 | 3 | 7 | 1 |
| All Time | 78 | 24 | - | - | - |
Like all software activity quantification, these numbers are imperfect but sometimes useful. Comments, Labels, and Milestones refer to those issues opened in the timespan in question.
The FreeAskInternet repository has seen active engagement, with 54 open issues currently logged. Notably, several issues reflect common user challenges related to Docker configurations and LLM integrations. A recurring theme is the difficulty in obtaining responses from the system, often attributed to network errors or misconfigurations. The presence of multiple issues regarding language output and API integration indicates a need for clearer documentation and troubleshooting guidance.
Several issues stand out due to their implications for user experience. For instance, Issue #89 highlights a failure to retrieve content from LLMs, which could deter users relying on this functionality. Additionally, Issues #57 and #30 reveal persistent Docker-related errors that suggest a lack of clarity in setup instructions, potentially alienating less experienced users. The community appears engaged, with many users sharing solutions or similar experiences, which may foster a collaborative environment for troubleshooting.
Issue #89: Cant get content with any LLM, after searched
Issue #57: ERROR: Invalid interpolation format for "searxng" option in service "services"
Issue #87: 搜到内容了，显示在下面列表中了，但是没回答
Issue #86: docker镜像无法拉取...有没有大佬分享一下镜像源啊...
Issue #85: Try
The analysis reveals significant user interaction with the FreeAskInternet project, particularly around setup and functionality issues related to LLMs and Docker configurations. The community's active participation in discussing solutions is a positive sign, but the frequency of these issues suggests that improvements in documentation and user support could enhance overall satisfaction and usability of the platform.
The repository nashsu/FreeAskInternet currently has six open pull requests (PRs) and four closed PRs. These pull requests reflect ongoing improvements, bug fixes, and feature enhancements to a project designed to provide a free, private, and locally running search aggregator and answer generator.
PR #74: fix: out of index while stream begin
Created 122 days ago by Chuck (aiyogg). This PR addresses an "out of index" error in the free_ask_internet.py file by adding a check for empty response choices before attempting to access them. This fix is critical for ensuring stability during streaming operations.
PR #66: chore: remove .DS_Store and update .gitignore
Created 127 days ago by Zhoukun Cheng (zhoukuncheng). This housekeeping PR removes unnecessary .DS_Store files from the repository and updates the .gitignore file to prevent similar files from being tracked in the future. Such maintenance is essential for keeping the repository clean.
PR #65: Update free_ask_internet.py
Created 127 days ago by aotsuki (aotsukiqx). This PR fixes an issue where the local LLM always used a hardcoded "CUSTOM" API token instead of allowing user-defined tokens. This change enhances flexibility for users who want to customize their configurations.
PR #28: Create devcontainer.json
Created 131 days ago by meahari. This PR introduces a devcontainer.json file, which facilitates development within a containerized environment. This addition is significant for developers looking to standardize their development setup.
PR #22: Refactor code in free_ask_internet.py
Created 131 days ago by Ole Strauss (olestrauss). The refactoring includes adding type annotations and removing redundant imports, which improves code readability and maintainability. Such improvements are beneficial for long-term project health.
PR #20: Update README.md
Created 132 days ago by Ikko Eltociear Ashimine (eltociear). A minor correction in the README file changes "runing" to "running." While trivial, such edits contribute to overall documentation quality.
PR #36: Update prompt to fix wrong language in response
Closed after being deemed resolved by the author. However, there was some contention regarding whether the issue was fully addressed, indicating potential communication gaps within the team.
PR #31: Update README.md
Closed due to being labeled as spam. The discussion around this PR highlights community sensitivity towards irrelevant contributions.
PR #21: Extract searxng and freechatgpt hosts as environment variables
Closed without merging. The proposed changes were not accepted, possibly due to lack of consensus on their necessity.
PR #10: Replaced FreeGPT35 with aurora
Closed with concerns raised about unrelated changes in URLs and repository ownership. This indicates a need for clearer guidelines on what constitutes relevant changes in PRs.
The current set of pull requests for FreeAskInternet reveals several themes that are noteworthy for both project maintainers and contributors.
Firstly, there is a strong focus on bug fixing and code quality improvements. For instance, PR #74 addresses a critical bug that could lead to runtime errors, while PR #65 enhances user flexibility by allowing custom API tokens instead of hardcoding values. These changes indicate that contributors are actively engaged in improving the user experience and reliability of the software.
Secondly, there is evidence of ongoing maintenance work reflected in PR #66's removal of unnecessary files and updates to .gitignore. Such housekeeping tasks are essential for maintaining a clean codebase, especially as projects grow larger and more complex. The introduction of a devcontainer.json file in PR #28 also signals an intention to streamline development processes, which can be particularly beneficial for onboarding new contributors or maintaining consistency across development environments.
However, there are also notable anomalies within the closed pull requests that suggest areas for improvement in community engagement and communication. For example, PR #36 was closed despite ongoing discussions about whether it adequately resolved the underlying issue. This reflects potential gaps in communication among contributors regarding issue resolution processes. Similarly, PR #31 was labeled as spam, indicating that contributors may need clearer guidelines on acceptable contributions or better mechanisms for discussing proposed changes before they escalate into formal pull requests.
Moreover, the closed PRs reveal some friction points within the community regarding expectations around contributions. The comments on PR #10 highlight concerns about unrelated changes being introduced alongside substantive ones, suggesting that contributors should be encouraged to keep their changes focused and relevant to facilitate smoother reviews.
In conclusion, while the open pull requests demonstrate active engagement with both bug fixing and feature enhancements, there is room for improvement in community communication practices and contribution guidelines. Establishing clearer expectations can help streamline the review process and foster a more collaborative environment among contributors.
docker-compose.yaml and reduced context length in the application.The recent activities reflect a concentrated effort on improving usability and fixing critical issues within the FreeAskInternet project. The lack of recent collaborative efforts may indicate a phase of solo development or preparation for future contributions from other team members or the community.