‹ Reports
The Dispatch

OSS Report: myshell-ai/melotts


GitHub Logo GitHub Logo

MeloTTS Development Stagnates Amidst User Demand for Enhanced Language Support

MeloTTS, a multi-lingual text-to-speech library by MyShell.ai, has seen a decline in active development with no significant new features or bug fixes in recent months, despite increasing user requests for improved Korean and Chinese language support.

The project aims to provide real-time, high-quality TTS capabilities across multiple languages, including English, Spanish, French, Chinese, Japanese, and Korean. It is designed for CPU inference and supports mixed-language processing.

Recent Activity

Recent issues primarily revolve around language support and model training challenges. Users have reported inconsistencies in model sizes (#180), warnings during custom dataset training (#179), and pronunciation issues with the Korean text cleaner (#178). These issues suggest a need for enhanced documentation and clearer setup instructions. Additionally, there are ongoing inquiries about voice customization and fine-tuning options, indicating a strong interest in personalized TTS solutions.

Development Team and Recent Activity

The development team has shown limited recent activity, with the most recent contributions focused on minor documentation updates rather than feature development or bug fixes.

Of Note

Quantified Reports

Quantify Issues



Recent GitHub Issues Activity

Timespan Opened Closed Comments Labeled Milestones
7 Days 3 0 1 3 1
30 Days 15 3 12 15 1
90 Days 38 6 73 38 1
All Time 151 36 - - -

Like all software activity quantification, these numbers are imperfect but sometimes useful. Comments, Labels, and Milestones refer to those issues opened in the timespan in question.

Quantify commits



Quantified Commit Activity Over 30 Days

Developer Avatar Branches PRs Commits Files Changes
Zengyi Qin 1 0/0/0 2 2 5
sifat (shhossain) 0 0/0/1 0 0 0

PRs: created by that dev and opened/merged/closed-unmerged during the period

Detailed Reports

Report On: Fetch issues



Recent Activity Analysis

The MeloTTS project has seen a surge in activity, with 115 open issues currently logged. Recent issues highlight various challenges users face while training models, particularly concerning language support and model performance. A notable trend is the repeated requests for improvements in specific language capabilities, especially for Korean and Chinese, indicating a demand for enhanced multilingual support.

Several users have reported critical issues related to model training, such as errors during the preprocessing phase and difficulties with specific configurations. This suggests potential gaps in documentation or complexity in setup procedures that could hinder user experience. Additionally, there are multiple inquiries about voice customization and fine-tuning, reflecting a keen interest in personalized TTS solutions.

Issue Details

Recently Created Issues

  1. Issue #180: train the model

    • Priority: High
    • Status: Open
    • Created: 3 days ago
    • Details: User reports inconsistency in model sizes (200M vs 600M) and seeks resolution.
  2. Issue #179: Warning: Grad strides do not match bucket view strides

    • Priority: Medium
    • Status: Open
    • Created: 3 days ago
    • Details: User encounters warnings while training on a custom dataset, indicating potential performance issues.
  3. Issue #178: Can you improve the Korean cleaner?

    • Priority: Medium
    • Status: Open
    • Created: 4 days ago
    • Details: User requests enhancements to the Korean text cleaner due to pronunciation issues.
  4. Issue #177: Questions Regarding Training Data Volume and Future TTS Technology Directions

    • Priority: Low
    • Status: Open
    • Created: 8 days ago
    • Details: User inquires about the dataset used for training and expresses concerns over model fluency.
  5. Issue #176: mecab-python3 errors.. popping up.

    • Priority: High
    • Status: Open
    • Created: 8 days ago
    • Details: User reports persistent errors related to MeCab installation, complicating usage.

Recently Updated Issues

  1. Issue #166: CUDA error: an illegal memory access was encountered

    • Priority: High
    • Status: Open
    • Last Updated: 11 days ago
    • Details: Users discuss encountering CUDA errors during training, highlighting potential resource management issues.
  2. Issue #164: ONNX infer

    • Priority: Medium
    • Status: Open
    • Last Updated: 12 days ago
    • Details: Users inquire about ONNX model support, indicating interest in model deployment flexibility.
  3. Issue #162: On the issue of training new timbres

    • Priority: Low
    • Status: Open
    • Last Updated: 3 days ago
    • Details: User seeks guidance on audio data requirements for training new timbres.

Summary of Themes

  • There is a clear focus on improving multilingual capabilities, particularly for languages like Korean and Chinese.
  • Users frequently encounter technical challenges related to model training and setup, suggesting a need for clearer documentation or streamlined processes.
  • The community is actively engaged in discussions around feature requests, including voice customization and fine-tuning options, which indicates a strong interest in personalized TTS experiences.
  • Several issues relate to installation problems with dependencies like MeCab and Python packages, pointing to potential barriers for new users trying to adopt the framework.

This analysis reveals both the strengths of the MeloTTS project—such as its active community and feature-rich offerings—and areas where user experience could be enhanced through improved documentation and support for diverse language needs.

Report On: Fetch pull requests



Report on Pull Requests

Overview

The analysis covers a total of 29 pull requests (PRs) from the MeloTTS repository, with 13 currently open and 16 closed. The PRs reflect ongoing efforts to enhance functionality, fix bugs, and improve compatibility with various Python versions and operating systems.

Summary of Pull Requests

Open Pull Requests

  • PR #159: Fix mecab-python3 version
    Updated the version of mecab-python3 to ensure compatibility with recent Python versions. This change addresses issues raised by users regarding building MeCab.

  • PR #143: Support python 3.12.3
    Addresses build errors related to tokenizers on Python 3.12, ensuring that the library remains functional with the latest Python release.

  • PR #124: Update requirements.txt
    Adds dependencies botocore and cached_path, fixing issues related to outdated packages. This PR is part of a broader effort to keep dependencies current.

  • PR #122: 解决中文语音推理声音忽大忽小的问题
    Aimed at fixing volume inconsistencies in Chinese speech inference, indicating a focus on improving user experience for specific language support.

  • PR #117: Add support for Thai
    Introduces Thai language support, showcasing the project's commitment to expanding its multilingual capabilities.

  • PR #88: melo/api.py: add a 'tts' iterator to greatly improve the response speed
    Enhances performance by implementing an iterator for text-to-speech processing, significantly reducing wait times for long texts.

  • PR #82: Add .venv directory to .gitignore
    A minor update to ignore virtual environment files, reflecting standard best practices in Python development.

  • PR #77: download cmu dictionary if does not exist
    Adds functionality to automatically download the CMU dictionary if it is missing, improving usability for new users.

  • PR #65: Adding support to install on Debian 12
    Addresses installation issues specific to Debian 12, indicating responsiveness to user feedback regarding platform compatibility.

  • PR #61: Make training files parsable on windows
    Ensures that training files can be read correctly on Windows systems, highlighting cross-platform considerations.

  • PR #56: Added fastAPI server to support streaming
    Introduces a FastAPI server for streaming capabilities, enhancing the library's flexibility and usability in various applications.

  • PR #21: Update README.md
    A simple typo correction in the documentation, reflecting ongoing maintenance of project documentation.

  • PR #6: Update modules.py
    Corrects a typo in the code comments, which is essential for maintaining clarity in code documentation.

Closed Pull Requests

  • PR #150: Update requirements.txt (mecab-python3 is written twice in requirements.txt)
    Closed without merging; highlights an issue with duplicate entries in dependency management.

  • PR #70: Dev 0309 training
    Merged; adds example metadata for training purposes, contributing to the project's documentation and usability.

  • PR #59: training code done
    Merged; significant updates related to training functionalities were implemented successfully.

  • PR #39: Dev 0229
    Merged; adds Hugging Face hub compatibility, enhancing model accessibility and integration with external resources.

  • PR #38: Update main.py EN-INDIA to EN_INDIA
    Merged; minor update for consistency in language identifiers within the codebase.

  • PR #33: Ensure pip
    Merged; addresses pip-related issues within the project setup.

  • PR #32: Fix GH Actions bug where unable to import pip
    Merged; resolves CI/CD pipeline issues related to package management.

  • PR #30: Add loading from HF hub
    Merged; enhances model loading capabilities from Hugging Face's hub, improving user experience.

Analysis of Pull Requests

The pull requests submitted for the MeloTTS project reveal several key themes and trends that are critical for understanding both the development process and community engagement surrounding this repository.

Active Maintenance and Community Engagement

The presence of multiple open pull requests indicates an active development environment where contributors are continually working on enhancements and fixes. Notably, PRs such as #159 and #143 reflect a proactive approach towards maintaining compatibility with newer Python versions—an essential aspect given the rapid evolution of programming languages and libraries. The engagement from external contributors like Paul O'Leary McCann (polm) shows that the project has fostered a collaborative community willing to address issues that affect users across different platforms and use cases.

Focus on Multilingual Support

A significant number of PRs are dedicated to expanding language support (e.g., PRs #117 for Thai and PR #122 addressing Chinese speech inference). This focus aligns well with the project's goal of providing high-quality multi-lingual TTS capabilities. The addition of new languages not only broadens the user base but also enhances the library's utility in diverse applications, making it more appealing for developers working in multilingual environments.

Dependency Management

Several PRs (e.g., PRs #124 and #150) highlight ongoing efforts to manage dependencies effectively. The need for regular updates reflects a commitment to keeping the software secure and functional while minimizing conflicts that can arise from outdated packages. However, it is concerning that some PRs like #150 were closed without merging, suggesting potential disagreements or lack of consensus on how best to handle certain dependencies. This could indicate a need for clearer guidelines or discussions around dependency management within the community.

Performance Improvements

Performance enhancements are another recurring theme, particularly evident in PRs like #88 which introduces an iterator for TTS processing. Such improvements are crucial for user satisfaction, especially in applications requiring real-time processing. The emphasis on speed and efficiency demonstrates an understanding of user needs and expectations in practical scenarios where latency can significantly impact usability.

Documentation and Usability

The project maintains a strong focus on documentation updates (e.g., PRs like #21 and #6), which is vital for onboarding new users and contributors. Clear documentation helps mitigate confusion around usage and installation processes, particularly for complex libraries like MeloTTS that involve multiple dependencies and configurations across different operating systems.

In conclusion, while there are areas needing attention—such as resolving disputes over dependency management—the overall trajectory of development within MeloTTS appears positive. The active engagement from contributors combined with a clear focus on enhancing functionality positions this project well within the competitive landscape of text-to-speech technologies. Continued emphasis on community collaboration will be essential as it evolves further.

Report On: Fetch commits



Repo Commits Analysis

Development Team and Recent Activity

Team Members:

  • Zengyi Qin (Zengyi-Qin)

    • Recent Activity:
    • Updated README.md (12 days ago).
    • Modified requirements.txt (19 days ago).
    • Engaged in multiple updates to documentation and installation files over the past months.
    • No open pull requests; recent contributions focused on minor updates and documentation.
  • Wenliang Zhao (wl-zhao)

    • Recent Activity:
    • Contributed to several features including training code and improvements to sentence splitting (last major commit 164 days ago).
    • Collaborated with Zengyi Qin on various merges and enhancements, particularly around the training code and API improvements.
  • Xumin Yu (yuxumin)

    • Recent Activity:
    • Last commit was 164 days ago, updating requirements.txt.
    • Involved in earlier updates but no recent activity reported.
  • Elvis Claros Castro (ElvisClaros)

    • Recent Activity:
    • Last contribution was 173 days ago, focused on updating main.py.
    • Limited recent engagement.
  • mrfakename (fakerybakery)

    • Recent Activity:
    • Active in multiple pull requests related to package management and installation issues, with last notable activity around 175 days ago.
    • Engaged in community contributions but no recent commits.

Summary of Recent Activities:

  • The most recent activity is primarily from Zengyi Qin, focusing on documentation updates rather than feature development or bug fixes.
  • Wenliang Zhao has contributed more significantly to feature development in the past but has not committed recently.
  • Other team members show limited recent activity, with some last contributing several months ago.
  • There are currently no open pull requests from any team member, indicating a potential slowdown in active feature development or bug fixes.

Patterns and Conclusions:

  • The project appears to be experiencing a lull in active development, particularly in terms of new features or significant bug fixes.
  • Documentation updates suggest ongoing maintenance but lack of new functionality could indicate a shift in focus or resource allocation.
  • The project's community engagement remains strong, as indicated by the number of forks and stars, but internal contributions have waned recently.