‹ Reports
The Dispatch

OSS Report: chen08209/FlClash


FlClash Faces Stability Challenges Amidst Active Development and User Feedback

FlClash, an open-source multi-platform proxy client, has been experiencing a surge in user-reported issues and feature requests, particularly concerning its latest version 0.8.54, highlighting potential stability concerns.

FlClash is designed to provide a seamless, ad-free proxy client experience across Android, Windows, macOS, and Linux. The project is built on ClashMeta and emphasizes a user-friendly interface using Material You Design principles.

Recent Activity

The recent activity in the FlClash project is characterized by a high volume of user-reported issues focusing on bugs and desired enhancements. Key issues include problems with the user interface such as non-responsive taskbar icons (#276, #273), auto-start failures (#278), and configuration errors (#274). These issues suggest that while the software is under active development, there are significant usability challenges that need addressing.

Development Team and Recent Activity

The development team, led by chen08209, has been actively working on feature enhancements and bug fixes, with a focus on optimizing user experience across platforms. However, collaboration appears limited among team members.

Of Note

Quantified Reports

Quantify Issues



Recent GitHub Issues Activity

Timespan Opened Closed Comments Labeled Milestones
7 Days 45 9 33 45 1
30 Days 125 72 159 125 1
90 Days 268 155 333 268 1
All Time 271 159 - - -

Like all software activity quantification, these numbers are imperfect but sometimes useful. Comments, Labels, and Milestones refer to those issues opened in the timespan in question.

Quantify commits



Quantified Commit Activity Over 30 Days

Developer Avatar Branches PRs Commits Files Changes
chen08209 2 0/0/0 21 127 23598
txyyh 1 0/1/0 2 3 6
Ikko Eltociear Ashimine (eltociear) 0 1/0/0 0 0 0

PRs: created by that dev and opened/merged/closed-unmerged during the period

Detailed Reports

Report On: Fetch issues



Recent Activity Analysis

The FlClash project has seen a surge in recent activity, with 112 open issues currently reported. Notably, several issues have been created and updated within the last few days, indicating ongoing user engagement and a responsive development environment. A significant number of these issues revolve around bugs and feature requests related to the latest version (0.8.54), highlighting potential usability challenges and areas for improvement.

Common themes among the recent issues include problems with the user interface, such as missing context menus and issues with taskbar icons not responding. Additionally, users are requesting enhancements like clipboard support for node imports and improved configuration management. The frequency of these issues suggests that while the software is actively being developed, there may be stability concerns that need to be addressed promptly.

Issue Details

Most Recently Created Issues:

  1. Issue #280: 云备份报这个

    • Priority: Normal
    • Status: Open
    • Created: 0 days ago
    • Comments: None
  2. Issue #278: v0.8.54版本,无法自启动

    • Priority: High
    • Status: Open
    • Created: 0 days ago
    • Comments: User reports that the application requires manual startup despite settings indicating otherwise.
  3. Issue #276: v0.8.54 右下角任务栏图标右键没有弹出菜单了

    • Priority: High
    • Status: Open
    • Created: 0 days ago
    • Comments: Users are unable to access essential functions via the taskbar icon.
  4. Issue #275: 希望支持从剪贴板一键导入V2Ray节点

    • Priority: Normal
    • Status: Open
    • Created: 1 day ago
    • Comments: Users express a desire for easier node management.
  5. Issue #274: 有本地配置存在時選擇全部更新時報錯

    • Priority: High
    • Status: Open
    • Created: 1 day ago
    • Comments: Error occurs when trying to update configurations, potentially due to local file conflicts.
  6. Issue #273: 安装最新版后Windows系统托盘图标右键点击没有反应。

    • Priority: High
    • Status: Open
    • Created: 1 day ago
    • Comments: Users report non-responsiveness in system tray interactions.
  7. Issue #272: 强烈反对默认就自动开启管理员模式。

    • Priority: Normal
    • Status: Open
    • Created: 1 day ago
    • Comments: Users request more control over application permissions.
  8. Issue #271: 请求支持自定义UA

    • Priority: Normal
    • Status: Open
    • Created: 1 day ago
    • Comments: Users want the ability to customize User-Agent strings for better compatibility with servers.
  9. Issue #270: 请问作者会考虑出模块版吗?

    • Priority: Low
    • Status: Open
    • Created: 2 days ago
    • Comments: Inquiry about potential modular versions of the software.
  10. Issue #269: 添加配置出现以下问题如何解决?

    • Priority: High
    • Status: Open
    • Created: 2 days ago
    • Comments: Users report specific errors related to configuration updates.

Important Observations

  • Several high-priority issues are related to critical functionalities like auto-starting, taskbar interactions, and configuration management.
  • The presence of multiple requests for enhanced features indicates a user base that is actively seeking improvements and more intuitive functionality.
  • The recurring theme of UI-related issues suggests that while the software is feature-rich, its usability may be suffering from bugs or design oversights that need urgent attention.
  • The rapid creation of new issues alongside ongoing discussions in comments reflects a dynamic interaction between users and developers, which is crucial for iterative improvements in open-source projects like FlClash.

Report On: Fetch pull requests



Overview

The analysis of the pull requests (PRs) for the FlClash project reveals a mix of recent activity, particularly focused on localization and documentation improvements, alongside several closed PRs that highlight various development efforts and challenges faced by contributors.

Summary of Pull Requests

Open Pull Requests

  • PR #247: docs: add Japanese README
    • State: Open
    • Created: 7 days ago
    • Significance: This PR introduces a Japanese version of the README file, enhancing accessibility for Japanese-speaking users. It reflects an effort to broaden the project's user base and improve documentation in multiple languages.

Closed Pull Requests

  • PR #140: 添加自建 F-Droid 仓库相关 workflow

    • State: Closed (Merged)
    • Created: 35 days ago
    • Significance: This PR added workflows to support the deployment of the project to an F-Droid repository. It demonstrates a commitment to making the application available on alternative platforms, which is crucial for open-source projects.
  • PR #131: macos arm64打包支持

    • State: Closed (Not merged)
    • Created: 36 days ago
    • Significance: This PR aimed to add support for packaging on macOS ARM64 architecture. Its closure without merging may indicate issues with compatibility or lack of follow-up from maintainers.
  • PR #107: Update package.dart

    • State: Closed (Not merged)
    • Created: 44 days ago
    • Significance: This PR sought to update the user agent string for better compatibility with external services. Its closure suggests potential disagreements or oversight regarding its necessity.
  • PR #73: Fix View Translate English

    • State: Closed (Not merged)
    • Created: 61 days ago
    • Significance: This PR attempted to fix translation issues within the application. The lack of merging indicates possible unresolved conflicts or prioritization of other tasks.
  • PR #30: 优化mac构建文档

    • State: Closed (Not merged)
    • Created: 72 days ago
    • Significance: Focused on optimizing macOS build documentation, this PR's closure without merging may reflect a lack of alignment with current documentation standards or practices.
  • PR #3: Bump github.com/cloudflare/circl from 1.3.6 to 1.3.7 in /core

    • State: Closed (Not merged)
    • Created: 102 days ago
    • Significance: This PR was intended to update a dependency but was not merged, possibly indicating a need for further testing or review before integration.

Analysis of Pull Requests

The pull requests for FlClash present a mixed landscape of active contributions and challenges that can be critical for the project's ongoing development. The most recent open PR (#247) highlights a significant step towards inclusivity by adding a Japanese README, which is essential for reaching non-English speaking users and expanding the project's community engagement. This aligns well with modern open-source practices where localization is increasingly prioritized.

However, looking at the closed PRs reveals several notable trends and potential issues within the project. For instance, multiple PRs aimed at improving functionality or documentation were closed without being merged (#131, #107, #73, #30). This raises questions about the project's review process and responsiveness to contributions. The closure of these PRs could indicate either a lack of resources to review contributions adequately or possible disagreements on implementation approaches among contributors and maintainers.

Moreover, the presence of several unmerged PRs suggests a backlog that could hinder progress if not addressed promptly. The project has a relatively high number of open issues and pull requests (113), which may reflect either rapid development cycles or challenges in maintaining momentum due to resource constraints or prioritization issues. The fact that some contributions are not being integrated could lead to contributor frustration and potentially deter future contributions if not managed effectively.

Another point of concern is the closure of dependency updates like PR #3 without merging, which could lead to outdated libraries and potential security vulnerabilities if not addressed timely. Regular maintenance of dependencies is crucial for any software project, especially one that aims to provide secure proxy services.

In conclusion, while FlClash shows promise with its recent localization efforts and community engagement metrics, it faces significant challenges in managing contributions effectively. Addressing these issues through improved communication with contributors, timely reviews of pull requests, and prioritizing critical updates will be essential for sustaining growth and ensuring project stability moving forward.

Report On: Fetch commits



Repo Commits Analysis

Development Team and Recent Activity

Team Members

  • chen08209

    • Recent Activity:
    • 8 days ago: Optimized app logic, added support for Windows administrator auto-launch and Android VPN closure.
    • 10 days ago: Implemented profile sorting, added country flags for Windows, and optimized the proxies and profiles pages.
    • 18 days ago: Updated the access control page and fixed a bug.
    • 19 days ago: Optimized the provider page, delay test, and added support for local backup and recovery.
    • 22 days ago: Fixed Android tile service issues.
  • txyyh

    • Recent Activity:
    • 25 days ago: Merged a pull request to add workflows related to self-built F-Droid repositories.
    • 25 days ago: Renamed README fingerprint and workflow deploy repo name.
  • eltociear

    • Recent Activity: No recent commits; has one open pull request.

Summary of Activities

  • The primary contributor, chen08209, has been highly active with 21 commits in the last 30 days, focusing on optimizations, feature enhancements, and bug fixes.
  • Collaborations are evident with txyyh, who contributed to workflow improvements but has limited recent activity.
  • There is a noticeable emphasis on optimizing user experience across platforms (Android, Windows) and addressing bugs in existing features.
  • The project maintains an active development pace with ongoing enhancements to UI components and functionality.

Patterns and Themes

  • Feature Enhancements: Continuous improvements are being made to enhance user experience, particularly in UI/UX aspects such as sorting profiles and optimizing pages.
  • Bug Fixes: Regular updates indicate a proactive approach to maintaining software stability by addressing reported issues promptly.
  • Collaboration: While most contributions come from chen08209, there are signs of collaboration with other team members like txyyh.
  • Activity Level: The high number of commits suggests a robust engagement with the project, though the presence of numerous open issues may indicate challenges in managing ongoing development.

Conclusions

The development team is actively working on enhancing the FlClash project through consistent feature additions and bug fixes. The primary contributor shows a strong commitment to improving the application, while collaboration exists but is limited among other team members. The project appears to be in a dynamic state of development, with ongoing efforts to refine its functionality across multiple platforms.