‹ Reports
The Dispatch

Bluesky Social's AT Protocol Repository Faces Performance and Validation Challenges Amidst Active Development

The AT Protocol Reference Implementation, developed by Bluesky, is a backend project for the app.bsky microblogging application, focusing on decentralized social media through the Authenticated Transfer Protocol (ATP).

Recent activities highlight a strong focus on enhancing features and addressing bugs, particularly in video content management and OAuth functionality. Notable PRs include #2779, which adds attribution fields to video records, and #2776, which improves did:web validation. However, there is a noticeable lack of recent merges, suggesting potential bottlenecks in the review process.

Recent Activity

Recent issues and pull requests indicate a concerted effort to enhance platform capabilities and address technical debt. Feature enhancements such as video metadata (#2779) and pinned posts (#2771) are prominent, while bug fixes focus on improving API reliability (#2776). Performance optimization is also a key theme, with efforts to improve PDS efficiency (#2770).

Development Team Activity

Of Note

Overall, while the project is actively evolving with diverse contributions, addressing merge delays and API inconsistencies will be vital for sustaining momentum and user satisfaction.

Quantified Reports

Quantify Issues



Recent GitHub Issues Activity

Timespan Opened Closed Comments Labeled Milestones
7 Days 3 1 4 0 1
30 Days 10 2 7 3 1
90 Days 28 9 54 11 1
1 Year 169 74 300 73 1
All Time 547 355 - - -

Like all software activity quantification, these numbers are imperfect but sometimes useful. Comments, Labels, and Milestones refer to those issues opened in the timespan in question.

Quantify commits



Quantified Commit Activity Over 30 Days

Developer Avatar Branches PRs Commits Files Changes
Matthieu Sieben 5 13/10/2 50 480 18583
Daniel Holmgren 5 9/6/0 39 377 10625
Foysal Ahamed 6 6/4/1 27 149 7450
devin ivy 2 7/7/0 17 123 5661
Eric Bailey 3 9/9/0 12 98 5319
github-actions[bot] 2 13/12/0 13 123 3569
Hailey 1 4/6/0 6 71 2975
Samuel Newman 4 4/1/2 14 50 1621
bnewbold 1 0/2/0 1 21 50
Shoshána Abigail 1 0/1/0 1 1 2
Yoshihiro Sugi (sugyan) 0 2/0/1 0 0 0
lukeacl (lukeacl) 0 1/0/0 0 0 0
None (itaru2622) 0 1/0/0 0 0 0
Tom Sherman (tom-sherman) 0 1/0/1 0 0 0

PRs: created by that dev and opened/merged/closed-unmerged during the period

Detailed Reports

Report On: Fetch issues



Recent Activity Analysis

The Bluesky Social AT Protocol repository has seen a significant volume of activity, with 192 open issues currently logged. Notably, there are several recurring themes, including bugs related to API functionality, user experience issues, and feature requests aimed at enhancing the platform's capabilities. A prominent issue is the handling of blocked users and their interactions, indicating a potential area for improvement in user privacy and content moderation.

Several issues highlight inconsistencies in API responses, particularly regarding user interactions and data retrieval methods. For example, users have reported problems with fetching likes and followers, as well as discrepancies in how blocked posts are displayed. This suggests that while the platform is evolving, there may be underlying architectural challenges that need to be addressed to ensure a seamless user experience.

Issue Details

Here are some of the most recently created and updated issues:

  1. Issue #2781: Record type is {}

    • Created: 0 days ago
    • Priority: Bug
    • Status: Open
    • Details: Users report receiving unexpected empty objects when interacting with certain API calls.
  2. Issue #2747: OAuth Polish

    • Created: 8 days ago
    • Priority: Enhancement
    • Status: Edited
    • Details: Ongoing refinements to OAuth implementation notes.
  3. Issue #2577: getKnownFollowers is missing cursor in response

    • Created: 82 days ago
    • Priority: Bug
    • Status: Edited
    • Details: The backend implementation does not return a cursor for pagination, affecting usability.
  4. Issue #2551: Increase Post Character limit to 500

    • Created: 90 days ago
    • Priority: Feature Request
    • Status: Edited
    • Details: Proposal to increase character limits for posts to enhance user engagement.
  5. Issue #2723: detectFacets Doesn't Include Hashtags After (

    • Created: 17 days ago
    • Priority: Bug
    • Status: Open
    • Details: Hashtags following certain characters are not detected correctly.
  6. Issue #2719: OAuth provider: yet more client-metadata error descriptions

    • Created: 18 days ago
    • Priority: Bug
    • Status: Open
    • Details: Suggestions for improving error messaging related to client metadata fetch problems.

Important Observations

  • There appears to be a consistent issue with the handling of blocked users and their visibility in feeds, which has been raised multiple times across different issues.
  • The API's handling of pagination and cursors is another recurring theme, with several users reporting difficulties in accessing complete data sets.
  • Feature requests are focused on enhancing user interaction capabilities, such as increasing character limits and improving content moderation tools.
  • Bugs related to data retrieval (e.g., likes and follows) indicate potential gaps in the API's reliability that could affect user trust and engagement.

This analysis underscores the importance of addressing both functional bugs and enhancing feature sets to improve overall user experience on the platform.

Report On: Fetch pull requests



Overview

The dataset contains a comprehensive list of 70 open pull requests (PRs) from the bluesky-social/atproto repository, along with 1761 closed PRs. The open PRs cover a variety of enhancements, bug fixes, and feature implementations aimed at improving the functionality and performance of the AT Protocol Reference Implementation.

Summary of Pull Requests

Open Pull Requests

  • #2780: ❇️ Template language
    Created: 0 days ago
    This PR introduces a language property for communication templates, allowing moderators to manage email templates more effectively. It also implements specific error handling for duplicate template names.

  • #2779: [Videos] Add attribution and license fields
    Created: 1 day ago
    This PR adds fields for attribution and license URI to video embed records, enhancing metadata management for video content.

  • #2776: Properly validate atproto did:web
    Created: 1 day ago
    This PR focuses on improving validation logic for did:web, ensuring compliance with expected behaviors.

  • #2774: Handle negative cursors on subscribeRepos as relative to current
    Created: 1 day ago
    Adjusts cursor logic to handle negative integers, allowing users to backfill events more intuitively.

  • #2773: Bsky performance
    Created: 2 days ago (Draft)
    A draft PR aimed at improving performance metrics within the Bsky application.

  • #2771: Pinned posts
    Created: 3 days ago (Draft)
    A draft proposal for implementing pinned posts functionality, currently under development.

  • #2770: Micro optimizations in PDS
    Created: 3 days ago
    Introduces several micro-optimizations to enhance performance in the Personal Data Server.

  • #2768: Pds performance tweaks
    Created: 3 days ago (Draft)
    Draft PR focusing on performance improvements in the PDS.

  • #2767: Update email templates
    Created: 4 days ago
    Updates email templates used within the application, including significant changes to structure and content.

  • #2766: Rework dataplane subscription
    Created: 5 days ago
    Refactors subscription logic to utilize a new sync package, enhancing data handling efficiency.

Closed Pull Requests

  • #2777: :bug: Fix appealed param's usage
    Closed recently; this PR fixed a bug related to the handling of the appealed parameter in moderation queries.

  • #2762: :memo: Add changeset for moderation subject's embed type tagging
    Closed recently; this PR added a changeset related to moderation subjects and their tagging.

  • #2761: Version packages
    Closed recently; this PR was automatically generated for versioning updates across various packages.

Analysis of Pull Requests

The open pull requests in the bluesky-social/atproto repository reflect ongoing efforts to enhance functionality, improve user experience, and address technical debt. Several themes emerge from the analysis:

Feature Enhancements

A significant portion of the open PRs focuses on feature enhancements such as adding new properties (e.g., video attribution and license fields in #2779) and implementing new functionalities like pinned posts (#2771). These enhancements are crucial for keeping the platform competitive and responsive to user needs. The introduction of language properties in templates (#2780) also indicates a push towards localization and better user engagement across diverse communities.

Bug Fixes and Improvements

Many open PRs are dedicated to fixing bugs or improving existing functionalities. For instance, #2776 addresses validation issues with did:web, while #2774 enhances cursor logic for event subscriptions. This focus on refining existing features is vital for maintaining system reliability and user trust.

Performance Optimization

Performance-related improvements are evident in multiple PRs (#2770, #2768), indicating an awareness of the need for efficiency as user demand grows. Optimizing backend processes is essential for scaling applications effectively without sacrificing responsiveness or user experience.

Draft Status and Collaboration

Several open PRs are marked as drafts (#2773, #2771), suggesting that contributors are still iterating on their ideas or awaiting feedback before finalizing their proposals. This collaborative approach is beneficial as it allows for community input and ensures that multiple perspectives are considered before merging significant changes into the main branch.

Lack of Recent Merge Activity

Despite having numerous active pull requests, there is a noticeable lack of recent merge activity. This could indicate potential bottlenecks in code review processes or resource allocation issues among maintainers. Addressing these bottlenecks is crucial to ensure that contributions do not stagnate and that developers remain engaged with the project.

Historical Context

The dataset also shows a rich history of closed pull requests (1761), which reflects an active development cycle over time. However, some older PRs may have been left unattended or closed without resolution, which can lead to frustration among contributors if not managed properly. Regular reviews of both open and closed pull requests can help maintain momentum within the community and ensure that valuable contributions are recognized and integrated into the project.

In conclusion, while the current state of open pull requests indicates robust ongoing development efforts within the bluesky-social/atproto repository, attention must be paid to merging processes and community engagement strategies to sustain growth and innovation in this evolving project.

Report On: Fetch commits



Repo Commits Analysis

Development Team and Recent Activity

Team Members and Recent Contributions

  1. Foysal Ahamed (foysalit)

    • Recent Activity:
    • Fixed the usage of the appealed parameter in a bug fix (#2777).
    • Worked on moderation subject's embed type tagging (#2762).
    • Applied specific tags for video, image, and external content (#2703).
    • Contributed to changes related to moderation events and account actions.
    • Collaborations: Collaborated with multiple team members on various features.
  2. Daniel Holmgren (dholms)

    • Recent Activity:
    • Implemented repo write commit metadata (#2745).
    • Revised repo write validation for unknown Lexicons (#2748).
    • Made various contributions to OAuth features and PDS improvements.
    • Collaborations: Frequently collaborated with Foysal Ahamed and Devin Ivy.
  3. Devin Ivy (devinivy)

    • Recent Activity:
    • Worked on multiple features including video lexicons and app view updates (#2751).
    • Fixed client-side crashes in OAuth (#2749).
    • Contributed to validation improvements and repository write logic.
    • Collaborations: Often collaborated with Daniel Holmgren and Foysal Ahamed.
  4. Eric Bailey (estrattonbailey)

    • Recent Activity:
    • Added tests for viewer block functionality (#2759).
    • Fixed viewer block references (#2758).
    • Contributed to various testing efforts across different modules.
    • Collaborations: Collaborated with other team members on testing and feature implementations.
  5. Matthieu Sieben (matthieusieben)

    • Recent Activity:
    • Focused on security improvements, particularly around JWT handling and OAuth enhancements.
    • Made significant contributions to error handling and client metadata validation.
    • Collaborations: Worked closely with other developers on OAuth-related tasks.
  6. Samuel Newman (mozzius)

    • Recent Activity:
    • Contributed to the addition of autoplay preferences in lexicons.
    • Engaged in code generation tasks across various modules.
    • Collaborations: Collaborated with other team members on lexicon updates.
  7. Hailey (haileyok)

    • Recent Activity:
    • Worked on filtering posts with embed blocks and improving thread handling.
    • Engaged in various feature enhancements related to user interactions.
    • Collaborations: Collaborated with Eric Bailey on testing and feature development.

Patterns, Themes, and Conclusions

  • Active Collaboration: The team exhibits strong collaboration across multiple features, particularly between Foysal Ahamed, Daniel Holmgren, and Devin Ivy. This suggests a well-integrated workflow where team members frequently assist each other on overlapping tasks.

  • Focus on Features and Bug Fixes: Recent commits indicate a balanced focus on both new feature development (e.g., video embedding, moderation tagging) and critical bug fixes (e.g., OAuth issues, viewer block references). This reflects a commitment to maintaining software quality while enhancing functionality.

  • Diverse Contributions: Each member is contributing to different aspects of the project, from core functionalities like OAuth handling to user interface improvements. This diversity in contributions helps ensure that various components of the project are being actively developed and maintained.

  • Testing Emphasis: There is a noticeable emphasis on adding tests for new features, which is crucial for maintaining code quality as the project evolves. Eric Bailey's recent contributions highlight this focus on robust testing practices.

  • Security Enhancements: Matthieu Sieben's contributions towards improving security protocols indicate a proactive approach to safeguarding the application against vulnerabilities, especially in authentication mechanisms.

Overall, the development team is actively engaged in enhancing the AT Protocol Reference Implementation through collaborative efforts, diverse contributions, and a strong focus on both new features and maintaining code quality through testing and security measures.