‹ Reports
The Dispatch

OSS Report: mui/material-ui


Material UI Faces Persistent Accessibility Challenges Amidst Active Development

Material UI, a leading React component library implementing Google's Material Design, continues to face significant accessibility challenges, particularly with components like Autocomplete and Stepper, as highlighted by recent user reports.

Recent Activity

The project has seen a surge in issues related to accessibility and component behavior inconsistencies. Notably, the Autocomplete component has been flagged for bugs affecting its interaction with props and states, indicating a need for immediate attention. Additionally, there is a strong community push towards enhancing keyboard navigation and screen reader compatibility, aligning with industry trends for inclusive design.

Development Team and Recent Activity

  1. Olivier Tassinari (oliviertassinari)

    • Recent Activity: 81 commits; major contributions in refactoring and documentation.
  2. Siriwat K (siriwatknp)

    • Recent Activity: 23 commits; focused on animations and component functionality.
  3. Jan Potoms (Janpot)

    • Recent Activity: 11 commits; involved in regression tests and code refactoring.
  4. Diego Andai (DiegoAndai)

    • Recent Activity: 10 commits; feature enhancements and bug fixes.
  5. Aarón García Hervás (aarongarciah)

    • Recent Activity: 9 commits; bug fixes and enhancements.

The team is actively engaged in both feature development and maintenance tasks, with a strong collaborative culture evidenced by frequent co-authorship of commits.

Of Note

Quantified Reports

Quantify Issues



Recent GitHub Issues Activity

Timespan Opened Closed Comments Labeled Milestones
7 Days 29 23 69 0 2
30 Days 144 91 414 0 4
90 Days 307 190 975 0 4
All Time 19328 17605 - - -

Like all software activity quantification, these numbers are imperfect but sometimes useful. Comments, Labels, and Milestones refer to those issues opened in the timespan in question.

Quantify commits



Quantified Commit Activity Over 30 Days

Developer Avatar Branches PRs Commits Files Changes
Olivier Tassinari 10 26/25/0 81 239 45662
Victor Zanivan Monteiro 2 4/4/0 7 272 37399
Siriwat K 5 18/16/0 23 438 13753
Rom Grk 2 0/0/0 3 85 10936
renovate[bot] 9 43/42/0 81 74 9204
Marija Najdova 1 5/5/0 6 36 1223
Diego Andai 3 9/6/1 10 371 1077
Jan Potoms 3 18/6/3 11 24 823
Alexandre Fauquette 2 3/2/0 3 141 675
Sycamore 2 1/1/0 2 13 443
Zeeshan Tamboli 3 1/1/0 5 18 434
Aarón García Hervás 3 9/4/2 9 46 369
Ale 1 0/0/0 1 4 347
Bharat Kashyap 1 0/0/0 1 4 315
Eng Zer Jun 1 1/1/0 1 75 308
Michał Dudak 2 1/1/0 3 54 308
José Rodolfo Freitas 1 1/1/0 1 4 288
sai chand 3 7/4/1 7 30 282
Jose C Quintas Jr 1 4/3/0 3 18 247
Nadeem Ahmad 1 0/0/0 1 15 186
Michael Hutchinson 1 7/4/3 4 9 169
Rajat 1 0/0/0 1 38 128
Sergio Rene Tapia-Fikes 1 0/0/0 1 3 108
None (github-actions[bot]) 1 1/1/0 2 18 98
Brijesh Bittu 1 1/1/0 1 20 87
Prakhar Gupta 1 1/0/0 3 6 75
Jay 1 0/0/0 1 54 74
Raffaella Luzi Stoutland 1 1/0/1 1 4 68
Andrew Cherniavskii 1 2/2/0 2 3 64
Lukas Tyla 3 3/2/1 4 6 56
Lucas Hilgert 1 0/0/0 1 13 54
Mateusz Groth 1 1/1/0 1 2 53
Michel Engelen 1 4/4/0 4 16 53
binsmyth 1 0/0/0 1 12 36
Ritesh Biswas 1 1/1/0 1 2 30
sydneyjodon-wk 1 0/0/0 1 3 16
Jialing (Vxee) 1 1/0/0 1 1 14
Ollie Slater 1 1/1/0 1 1 12
GoOrit-Anima 1 1/1/0 1 1 11
Ilya Molostov 1 0/0/0 1 1 10
Shreyans Pathak 1 1/1/0 1 1 10
Sahil Agarwal 1 1/1/0 1 1 4
Kalmar Lorand 1 0/0/0 1 2 4
Carl Topham 1 1/1/0 1 1 2
Bahman World 1 0/0/0 1 1 2
Andrei Luca 1 1/1/0 1 1 2
Lokendra Saini 1 1/1/0 1 1 2
megos (megos) 0 1/0/0 0 0 0
Gillpreet (Gill-7) 0 1/0/1 0 0 0
None (Nashyn) 0 7/0/6 0 0 0
Raman (morozow) 0 3/0/0 0 0 0
Filip Czaplicki (starsep) 0 1/0/1 0 0 0
Harvey (harvey56) 0 1/0/1 0 0 0
Tomas Nikl (tomasnikl) 0 1/0/1 0 0 0
Derick M (TurtIeSocks) 0 1/0/0 0 0 0
İlyas Torun (ilyastorunn) 0 1/0/1 0 0 0
HAPPYmetal (jiangdonghan) 0 1/0/0 0 0 0
Tobi (tobilobasalawu) 0 1/0/0 0 0 0

PRs: created by that dev and opened/merged/closed-unmerged during the period

Detailed Reports

Report On: Fetch issues



Recent Activity Analysis

The Material UI project currently has 1,723 open issues on GitHub, indicating a high level of ongoing activity and engagement from the community. Recent issues highlight several themes, including accessibility concerns, component behavior inconsistencies, and requests for enhanced features. Notably, there are multiple reports of bugs related to the Autocomplete component and its interaction with various props and states, suggesting that this component may require immediate attention from maintainers.

Several issues also reflect a trend towards improving accessibility and usability, particularly in relation to keyboard navigation and screen reader compatibility. This focus aligns with broader industry standards for inclusive design, indicating that the community is actively advocating for better user experiences.

Issue Details

Most Recently Created Issues

  1. Issue #43741: Button color="inherit" prop regression for variant="contained

    • Priority: Normal
    • Status: Waiting for maintainer
    • Created: 0 days ago
    • Update: N/A
  2. Issue #43738: [Dialog]: Providing onKeyDown breaks closing via Escape

    • Priority: Normal
    • Status: Waiting for maintainer
    • Created: 1 day ago
    • Update: N/A
  3. Issue #43737: [docs] Outdated version entry should be cleaned up and removed from version table

    • Priority: Low
    • Status: Waiting for maintainer
    • Created: 1 day ago
    • Update: N/A
  4. Issue #43732: [material-ui][Dialog] Compatibility between MUI's dialogs and React Hook Form with FormProvider

    • Priority: Normal
    • Status: Waiting for maintainer
    • Created: 1 day ago
    • Update: N/A
  5. Issue #43727: [docs] MUI-X pages give 404 in v5 docs

    • Priority: Normal
    • Status: Waiting for maintainer
    • Created: 1 day ago
    • Update: N/A

Most Recently Updated Issues

  1. Issue #43689: Stepper lacks accessibility

    • Priority: High
    • Status: Waiting for maintainer
    • Last Updated: 3 days ago
  2. Issue #43688: [docs] Unclear explanations in Color doc

    • Priority: Normal
    • Status: Waiting for author
    • Last Updated: 3 days ago
  3. Issue #43687: [question] How to combine the two different Joy-UI themes.

    • Priority: Normal
    • Status: Waiting for author
    • Last Updated: 3 days ago
  4. Issue #43686: [material-ui][Grid] codemod not updating Grid

    • Priority: Normal
    • Status: Waiting for maintainer
    • Last Updated: 3 days ago
  5. Issue #43685: Error in @mui/system when using TypeScript

    • Priority: High
    • Status: Waiting for maintainer
    • Last Updated: 4 days ago

Analysis of Notable Issues

  • The regression reported in issue #43741 regarding the Button component's color prop indicates a potential breaking change that could affect many users upgrading to newer versions of Material UI. The lack of documentation around such changes could lead to confusion among developers.

  • Accessibility issues are prevalent, as seen in issue #43689 regarding the Stepper component. The community's focus on improving accessibility reflects a growing awareness of inclusive design principles.

  • The ongoing discussions about integrating React Hook Form with MUI components (issue #43732) highlight the need for better compatibility between popular libraries within the React ecosystem.

  • The presence of multiple documentation-related issues suggests that while the library is robust, its documentation may not fully meet user needs, particularly concerning migration guides and examples.

Overall, these insights reveal both strengths and areas needing improvement within the Material UI project, emphasizing the importance of community feedback in shaping future development efforts.

Report On: Fetch pull requests



Overview

The dataset contains a comprehensive list of open pull requests (PRs) for the Material UI project, totaling 149 open PRs. The PRs cover a wide range of topics, including bug fixes, documentation updates, feature enhancements, and experimental changes related to the transition to React 19 and the introduction of new design paradigms.

Summary of Pull Requests

  1. PR #43743: [test] Remove position:relative from regression container
    Created by Aarón García Hervás, this PR aims to refine regression tests by removing unnecessary CSS properties that could affect test outcomes.

  2. PR #43742: [test][docs] Improve demos for better regression screenshots
    Also by Aarón García Hervás, this PR improves demo layouts to ensure better visual representation in regression tests.

  3. PR #43739: [system] Pass the stylesheet directly to GlobalStyles
    Submitted by Siriwat K, this PR addresses issues with global style injection order in Emotion when using <StyledEngineProvider injectFirst>.

  4. PR #43736: [bugfix] Refactor prop types generation and add import optimization
    Created by Raman, this PR enhances prop type generation and optimizes imports across the codebase.

  5. PR #43735: [material-ui][docs] Document Typography color prop breaking change
    Aarón García Hervás documents a breaking change in the Typography component's color prop, ensuring users are aware of the changes in v6.

  6. PR #43733: [grid] Fix column spacing for nested containers
    Jan Potoms fixes spacing issues in nested grid components, addressing a bug reported in issue #43707.

  7. PR #43731: [docs] Remove HighlightedCode max-width
    Jan Potoms proposes removing max-width constraints on code highlighting components to improve responsiveness.

  8. PR #43730: [styled-engine-sc] Fix missing @types/hoist-non-react-statics causing styled returns any
    Submitted by megos, this PR resolves type definition issues that were causing problems with styled components.

  9. PR #43717: [material-ui] Bring back GridProps and GridTypeMap
    Diego Andai restores previously removed types related to the Grid component, addressing concerns raised in issue #43686.

  10. PR #43716: [docs] Add @mui/styles to list of packages that can have their version changed
    This documentation update by HAPPYmetal clarifies the status of the legacy @mui/styles package during upgrades.

  11. PR #43714: [material-ui][IconButton] Fix disableRipple behaviour when disableRipple is set in MuiButtonBase theme
    Sai Chand addresses issues with ripple effects in IconButtons based on theme settings.

  12. PR #43711: [docs-infra] Strengthen CSP
    Olivier Tassinari enhances Content Security Policy rules for improved security in documentation infrastructure.

  13. PR #43709: [code-infra] Fix and update bundling fixtures
    Jan Potoms updates bundling fixtures for better testing practices within the code infrastructure.

  14. PR #43708: [docs-infra] Add CodeSandbox/Stackblitz to the rest of the templates
    Siriwat K integrates CodeSandbox and Stackblitz support into template documentation for easier user access.

  15. PR #43702: [bugfix] Refactor default exports to named exports
    Raman standardizes export styles across the codebase for improved maintainability and tree-shaking capabilities.

  16. PR #43693: [draft] Reuse buildrsc
    Alexandre Fauquette drafts a proposal to reuse build resources for better efficiency in builds.

  17. PR #43684: [core] Remove Font Awesome visual regression tests
    Diego Andai removes flaky visual tests related to Font Awesome icons from regression testing due to instability.

  18. PR #43682: Rename mui/mui-toolpad => mui/toolpad
    Jan Potoms proposes renaming a repository for clarity and consistency within project structures.

  19. PR #43671: [docs][material-ui] Fix slider in color customization playground twitches when sliding
    Nashyn resolves layout issues affecting sliders in color customization demos.

  20. PR #43639: [docs] Rename jsx-runtime in window object
    Jialing proposes updates to documentation regarding JSX runtime references.

Analysis of Pull Requests

The analysis reveals several key themes and patterns among the recent pull requests:

Focus on Bug Fixes and Enhancements

A significant number of PRs are dedicated to fixing bugs and enhancing existing features, particularly around layout issues (e.g., PRs related to Grid spacing and Typography color props). This indicates an active effort by contributors to improve user experience and maintain functionality as the library evolves.

Documentation Improvements

Several PRs focus on updating documentation (e.g., breaking changes in Typography and enhancements for demos). This reflects a commitment to keeping users informed about changes that may impact their usage of the library, especially during major version upgrades like v6.

Transitioning to React 19

A notable trend is the preparation for React 19 compatibility, as seen in multiple PRs addressing type definitions and component behavior adjustments (e.g., handling refs). This indicates proactive planning for future-proofing the library against upcoming changes in React's ecosystem.

Community Engagement

The discussions within PRs often involve multiple contributors providing feedback and suggestions, showcasing a collaborative environment where ideas are shared openly. This engagement is critical for maintaining high-quality contributions and ensuring that various perspectives are considered before merging changes into the main branch.

Anomalies and Challenges

Some PRs highlight challenges faced by contributors, such as dealing with legacy code or dependencies that are not fully compatible with new standards (e.g., styled-components). These challenges can slow down progress but also present opportunities for refactoring and improving overall code quality moving forward.

Lack of Merges

Despite a high volume of open PRs (149), there appears to be a backlog in merging some of these changes into the main branch. This could indicate resource constraints or prioritization challenges within the team, which may need addressing to maintain momentum in development efforts.

In conclusion, while there is robust activity around bug fixes, documentation updates, and feature enhancements, attention should be given to managing merge processes effectively and addressing compatibility challenges as the project evolves towards React 19 support.

Report On: Fetch commits



Repo Commits Analysis

Development Team and Recent Activity

Team Members and Recent Contributions

  1. Siriwat K (siriwatknp)

    • Recent Activity: 23 commits with 13,753 changes across 438 files. Focused on fixing animations, updating documentation, and enhancing component functionality.
    • Collaborations: Worked with multiple team members including ZeeshanTamboli on various PRs.
  2. Sergio16T

    • Recent Activity: 1 commit with 108 changes. Documented the CondensedWithMenu option for Breadcrumbs.
    • Collaborations: Co-authored with ZeeshanTamboli.
  3. Jan Potoms (Janpot)

    • Recent Activity: 11 commits with 823 changes. Involved in regression tests and code refactoring.
    • Collaborations: Active in multiple PRs, contributing to code quality improvements.
  4. Zeeshan Tamboli (ZeeshanTamboli)

    • Recent Activity: 5 commits with 434 changes. Worked on documentation and component updates.
    • Collaborations: Frequently collaborated with Siriwat K and others.
  5. Sai Chand (sai6855)

    • Recent Activity: 7 commits with 282 changes. Focused on documentation updates and new feature demos.
    • Collaborations: Collaborated with ZeeshanTamboli on several PRs.
  6. Olivier Tassinari (oliviertassinari)

    • Recent Activity: 81 commits with 45,662 changes. Major contributions included code refactoring, fixing bugs, and enhancing documentation.
    • Collaborations: Extensive collaboration across various branches and PRs.
  7. Sahil Agarwal (sahil-ag)

    • Recent Activity: 1 commit with 4 changes related to release schedule updates.
  8. Lukas Tyla (LukasTy)

    • Recent Activity: 4 commits with 56 changes focused on utility functions and testing improvements.
  9. Binsmyth

    • Recent Activity: 1 commit with 36 changes addressing ESLint issues.
  10. Eng Zer Jun (Juneezee)

    • Recent Activity: 1 commit with significant changes across multiple files, focusing on code quality improvements.
  11. Aarón García Hervás (aarongarciah)

    • Recent Activity: 9 commits with 369 changes, involved in various bug fixes and enhancements.
  12. Andrew Cherniavskii (cherniavskii)

    • Recent Activity: Contributed to documentation fixes and improvements.
  13. Renovate[bot]

    • Recent Activity: 81 commits focused on dependency updates across multiple packages.
  14. Diego Andai (DiegoAndai)

    • Recent Activity: 10 commits related to feature enhancements and bug fixes.
  15. Others: Several contributors made minor contributions or participated in documentation updates, bug fixes, or dependency management.

Patterns and Themes

  • The team is actively engaged in both feature development and maintenance tasks, indicating a balanced approach to innovation and stability.
  • There is a strong collaborative culture, as evidenced by the frequent co-authorship of commits among team members.
  • Recent activities show a focus on improving documentation alongside code enhancements, which is crucial for user adoption and understanding of the library.
  • The high volume of contributions from Olivier Tassinari suggests a leadership role in guiding the project’s direction and maintaining its quality.
  • The use of automated tools like Renovate indicates an emphasis on keeping dependencies up-to-date, which is essential for security and performance.

Conclusions

The development team is highly active, demonstrating effective collaboration and a commitment to both new features and ongoing maintenance of the Material UI library. The recent activities reflect a well-organized effort to enhance the library's functionality while ensuring comprehensive documentation for users.