‹ Reports
The Dispatch

OSS Report: sz3/libcimbar


Development Stagnation in libcimbar Project as No Recent Commits or Pull Requests Are Observed

libcimbar, an innovative project for high-speed data transfer via color-icon-matrix barcodes, has experienced a period of inactivity with no recent commits or pull requests in the last 30 days. The project aims to enable offline data transfer between computer monitors and smartphone cameras.

Recent Activity

The project has seen no new commits or pull requests in the past 30 days. The most recent activities were conducted by sz3 and notune, with the last significant contributions occurring over 82 days ago. This lack of recent activity suggests a pause in development efforts.

Team Members and Recent Contributions

The absence of recent contributions highlights a potential need for renewed focus or additional resources to sustain momentum.

Of Note

  1. User Feature Requests: Issues like #100 (Windows support) and #104 (Decoder web app) indicate user demand for broader platform compatibility and new features.

  2. Community Engagement: Despite development stagnation, there is active community engagement with ongoing discussions in issues like #95 (WebGL issue).

  3. Performance Optimization Needs: Several issues point to the necessity for performance enhancements, such as decoding speed adjustments (#105).

  4. Error Handling Improvements: User feedback emphasizes the need for better error reporting mechanisms, particularly in scenarios involving hardware limitations.

  5. Cross-Platform Challenges: The lack of Windows support remains a significant barrier, as highlighted in multiple user issues.

The current state of the project reflects a need for strategic planning to address user demands and maintain development progress.

Quantified Reports

Quantify Issues



Recent GitHub Issues Activity

Timespan Opened Closed Comments Labeled Milestones
7 Days 1 0 2 1 1
30 Days 8 2 20 8 1
90 Days 8 2 20 8 1
1 Year 15 2 47 13 1
All Time 28 11 - - -

Like all software activity quantification, these numbers are imperfect but sometimes useful. Comments, Labels, and Milestones refer to those issues opened in the timespan in question.

Detailed Reports

Report On: Fetch issues



Recent Activity Analysis

The GitHub repository for libcimbar has seen a moderate level of recent activity, with 17 open issues currently logged. Notably, several issues highlight user requests for features like Windows support and frame rate adjustments, indicating a growing interest in usability across different platforms. A recurring theme is the need for better error handling and user guidance, particularly in scenarios involving hardware limitations or specific use cases such as remote desktop environments.

Several issues also reflect a community-driven approach to problem-solving, with users actively discussing potential solutions and workarounds. However, some critical issues remain unaddressed, such as the need for a browser-based decoder and enhancements to error reporting mechanisms.

Issue Details

Recently Created Issues

  • Issue #105: Add Decoding Speed Adjustment Feature

    • Priority: Medium
    • Status: Open
    • Created: 4 days ago
    • Updated: N/A
  • Issue #104: Decoder web app

    • Priority: High
    • Status: Open
    • Created: 9 days ago
    • Updated: N/A
  • Issue #102: take photos and decode

    • Priority: Medium
    • Status: Open
    • Created: 15 days ago
    • Updated: N/A
  • Issue #101: Suggest supporting frame rate adjustment

    • Priority: Medium
    • Status: Open
    • Created: 16 days ago
    • Updated: 15 days ago
  • Issue #100: Windows support

    • Priority: High
    • Status: Open
    • Created: 16 days ago
    • Updated: 15 days ago

Recently Updated Issues

  • Issue #95: WebGL issue

    • Priority: Medium
    • Status: Open
    • Created: 192 days ago
    • Updated: 12 days ago
  • Issue #71: hoping to send on windows and decode on another windows

    • Priority: Low
    • Status: Open
    • Created: 497 days ago
    • Updated: 12 days ago
  • Issue #96: Aborted(OOM) error

    • Priority: High
    • Status: Open
    • Created: 125 days ago
    • Updated: 122 days ago

These issues indicate a mix of feature requests and bug reports, with particular emphasis on improving the user experience across various platforms. The discussions within these issues often reveal user frustration with existing limitations, such as the lack of Windows support and inadequate error handling in specific scenarios.

Overall, the repository reflects an engaged community that is actively seeking improvements while also facing challenges related to platform compatibility and performance optimization.

Report On: Fetch pull requests



Overview

The libcimbar project has a total of 77 closed pull requests, with the most recent being PR #97, which involved various UI tweaks and updates to the cimbar.js encoder. The project shows active maintenance and development efforts, with a focus on enhancing user experience and fixing bugs.

Summary of Pull Requests

  • PR #97: Closed 84 days ago. Miscellaneous tweaks to the cimbar.js encoder UI, including error message display on WebGL init failure, menu toggling improvements, mobile touch event handling, new background, auto-expanding canvas for larger displays, and ensuring minimum padding around the barcode.
  • PR #94: Closed 203 days ago. Updated decoder objects for per-frame mode switching.
  • PR #93: Closed 208 days ago. Switched encoder default back to 4C temporarily.
  • PR #92: Closed 212 days ago. Updated cimbar_js UI with "mode B" toggle and documentation.
  • PR #91: Closed 212 days ago. Added functionality to split encoding/decoding of colors and symbols.
  • PR #90: Closed 226 days ago. Fixed issues related to no-fsanitize.
  • PR #89: Closed 226 days ago. Fixed memory corruption due to bad flood decode bounds check.
  • PR #87: Closed 243 days ago. CSS bugfix and tweak to package-portable-linux script.
  • PR #86: Closed 243 days ago. Updated index.html.
  • PR #85: Closed 264 days ago. Pinned "portable" Linux script to use an old (known good) CMake version.
  • PR #82: Closed 292 days ago. Fixed bug/change in iOS (un)focus behavior.
  • PR #81: Closed 296 days ago. Added progressive web app config and minor bugfix for symbol decoding.
  • PR #78: Closed 359 days ago. Updated dependencies for Fall 2023.
  • PR #75: Closed 469 days ago. Fixes for cimbar.js and cimbar_send.
  • PR #73: Closed 478 days ago. Decoding improvements and more flexible config for alternate grid dimensions.
  • PR #68: Closed 580 days ago. Packaging cimbar HTML.
  • PR #63: Closed 838 days ago. CLI update to read input filenames from stdin.
  • PR #61: Closed 910 days ago. Bugfixes and addition of cimbar_recv, a test decoder app.
  • PR #60: Closed 939 days ago. Added scripts to build asm/wasm and portable Linux, plus GitHub action to draft release on tag.
  • PR #59: Closed 944 days ago. Misc bugfixes and dependency upgrades.
  • PR #58: Closed 1178 days ago. Added service worker script for cimbar.org.
  • PR #57: Closed 1188 days ago. Misc CSS changes/fixes for cimbar.js.
  • PR #56: Closed 1240 days ago. Removed OpenCV highgui code path.
  • PR #55: Closed 1272 days ago. Minor tweak to the decode's preprocessing "sharpen".
  • PR #54: Closed 1295 days ago. Encoder improvements achieving a speed of 118 KB/s.
  • PR #53: Closed 1312 days ago. Configurable color correction for the decoder.
  • PR #52: Closed 1325 days ago. Decoupled symbol and color decode to enable better caching.
  • PR #50 - PR #28: Various bug fixes, updates, and improvements spanning from minor tweaks to significant feature additions like WASM encoder (#33) and zstd compression (#29).

Analysis of Pull Requests

The pull requests for the libcimbar project reflect a robust development process with a clear focus on continuous improvement and feature enhancement. The most recent PR (#97) showcases efforts to enhance user experience through UI tweaks in the web application interface (cimbar.js). This includes practical features like error messages on WebGL initialization failures, mobile touch event handling, and auto-expanding canvas sizes for larger displays.

Notably, there is a trend towards improving cross-platform compatibility and performance optimization, as seen in PRs like updating dependencies (#78), fixing memory corruption issues (#89), and enhancing encoding speeds (#54). The project also demonstrates an active response to community feedback and issues, evident from PRs addressing specific bugs or feature requests.

The diversity of changes across the pull requests indicates a well-rounded approach to development, covering aspects from UI/UX improvements, performance enhancements, bug fixes, to infrastructure updates like switching from Travis CI to GitHub Actions (#43). This not only helps in maintaining the project's health but also ensures that it evolves in line with technological advancements and user expectations.

Furthermore, the presence of closed pull requests without merges (e.g., PRs that were edited or closed without merging) suggests a meticulous review process where changes are carefully considered before integration into the main branch.

In conclusion, the pull request history of libcimbar reflects a dynamic project environment with active maintenance efforts aimed at enhancing functionality, performance, and user experience while ensuring stability and reliability through rigorous testing and review processes.

Report On: Fetch commits



Repo Commits Analysis

Development Team and Recent Activity

Team Members

  • sz3: Primary contributor and maintainer.
  • notune: Contributor focused on bug fixes.

Recent Activities

  • sz3:

    • 82 days ago: Implemented CSS tweaks for the 0.6.1f release, improving UI aesthetics.
    • 84 days ago: Merged pull request #97, which included miscellaneous updates to the cimbar.js encoder UI.
    • 90 days ago: Enhanced canvas size auto-calculation and added padding for better visual output on high-resolution displays.
    • Multiple commits (160-212 days ago): Focused on various improvements, including toggling pause functionality, error handling for WebGL initialization failures, and UI updates related to encoding modes.
    • Recent bug fixes (226 days ago): Addressed memory corruption issues and improved bounds checks in decoding functions.
    • Ongoing work: Continuous updates to the encoder and decoder functionalities, including enhancements for color correction, adaptive thresholding, and performance optimizations.
  • notune:

    • 226 days ago: Contributed a fix for a memory corruption bug related to flood decoding.

Patterns and Themes

  • The majority of recent activity has been led by sz3, indicating a strong central leadership in development.
  • Recent commits focus heavily on UI improvements, bug fixes, and performance enhancements, particularly around encoding and decoding functionalities.
  • Collaboration between team members is evident through merged pull requests, with notune contributing specifically to bug fixes.
  • There is a clear emphasis on maintaining backward compatibility while introducing new features (e.g., mode toggles).
  • The project appears to be in a phase of refining existing features rather than introducing entirely new functionalities, as indicated by the focus on bug fixes and UI tweaks.

Conclusions

The development team is actively engaged in enhancing the libcimbar project with a focus on stability, performance, and user experience. The collaborative nature of the contributions suggests a healthy development environment, despite the primary leadership role held by sz3. The ongoing work reflects a commitment to improving both the technical aspects of the software and its usability.