‹ Reports
The Dispatch

OSS Report: twbs/bootstrap


Bootstrap Project Faces Review Bottleneck Amidst Active Contribution Surge

Bootstrap, a leading front-end framework for responsive web development, continues to see active contributions focused on accessibility and customization enhancements, despite a noticeable bottleneck in the review and merging process.

Recent pull requests highlight significant efforts in updating development dependencies (#40895, #40894, #40893), adding utility classes (#40892), and improving component behavior (#40890, #40889). The closure of several PRs without merging suggests potential challenges in the review process or prioritization decisions by maintainers.

Recent Activity

Recent issues and pull requests indicate a strong focus on improving accessibility and customization. Issues such as overlapping icons in input fields (#40885) and form validation with browser-saved data (#40879) reflect ongoing UX concerns. Pull requests like #40888 address keyboard accessibility, while #40891 introduces new CSS variables for enhanced customization.

Development Team Activity

Of Note

  1. Accessibility Enhancements: Recent PRs emphasize making components more accessible, aligning with modern web standards.
  2. Documentation Improvements: A substantial portion of recent commits is dedicated to updating documentation, indicating a focus on usability.
  3. Dependency Management: Active management of dependencies through automated tools like Dependabot ensures project stability.
  4. Feature Customization: Introduction of new CSS variables and utility classes reflects an effort to enhance developer customization capabilities.
  5. Review Process Bottleneck: The closure of multiple PRs without merging suggests potential inefficiencies or prioritization challenges in the review process.

Quantified Reports

Quantify Issues



Recent GitHub Issues Activity

Timespan Opened Closed Comments Labeled Milestones
7 Days 4 2 7 1 1
30 Days 36 16 55 8 1
90 Days 98 59 207 30 1
1 Year 319 200 639 93 1
All Time 22517 22049 - - -

Like all software activity quantification, these numbers are imperfect but sometimes useful. Comments, Labels, and Milestones refer to those issues opened in the timespan in question.

Quantify commits



Quantified Commit Activity Over 30 Days

Developer Avatar Branches PRs Commits Files Changes
dependabot[bot] 1 20/9/12 9 4 760
Julien Déramond 4 3/1/0 7 5 57
XhmikosR 1 2/2/0 3 3 29
Dmitry 1 2/1/0 1 2 21
Louis-Maxime Piton 3 1/1/0 3 3 12
Christian Oliff 1 3/3/0 3 4 9
Hannah Issermann 1 4/3/0 3 3 5
Johannes Raggam (thet) 0 1/0/1 0 0 0
Vadim Kazakov (yads) 0 1/0/0 0 0 0
None (v3yar) 0 1/0/1 0 0 0
Ghislain B. (ghiscoding) 0 1/0/1 0 0 0
Nar Alvarez (naralvarez) 0 1/0/1 0 0 0
None (thaiguides) 0 1/0/1 0 0 0
None (travelchina) 0 1/0/1 0 0 0
Mohamad Salman (MohamadSalman11) 0 5/0/1 0 0 0

PRs: created by that dev and opened/merged/closed-unmerged during the period

Detailed Reports

Report On: Fetch issues



Recent Activity Analysis

The Bootstrap project has seen a significant uptick in activity with 468 open issues, indicating ongoing engagement and a variety of concerns from users. Notably, several issues relate to the interaction of Bootstrap's components with modern web practices, such as dark mode compatibility and responsive design features. A recurring theme is the need for enhancements in accessibility and usability, particularly regarding modals, tooltips, and form elements.

Several issues exhibit anomalies, such as the persistent problem of dropdowns and popovers not functioning correctly when combined with other components. Additionally, there are multiple requests for improved documentation and examples that clarify usage scenarios, especially for new features introduced in recent versions.

Issue Details

Most Recently Created Issues

  1. Issue #40885: Design Issues Due to Overlapping Icons in Input Field

    • Priority: Normal
    • Status: Open
    • Created: 3 days ago
    • Updated: 1 day ago
  2. Issue #40879: Form Validation does not work when browser saved data is used

    • Priority: Normal
    • Status: Open
    • Created: 4 days ago
    • Updated: 2 days ago
  3. Issue #40875: Pure CSS tooltip

    • Priority: Normal
    • Status: Open
    • Created: 6 days ago
    • Updated: Not updated
  4. Issue #40873: Option to Synchronize Modal Backdrop and Dialog Transitions

    • Priority: Normal
    • Status: Open
    • Created: 8 days ago
    • Updated: Not updated
  5. Issue #40872: Error when using $body-bg with a custom property

    • Priority: Normal
    • Status: Open
    • Created: 9 days ago
    • Updated: 7 days ago

Most Recently Updated Issues

  1. Issue #40885: Design Issues Due to Overlapping Icons in Input Field

    • Updated by Siddhesh-wagh with a workaround suggestion.
  2. Issue #40879: Form Validation does not work when browser saved data is used

    • Updated discussions about validation issues related to autofill.
  3. Issue #40872: Error when using $body-bg with a custom property

    • Ongoing discussions about Sass variable compatibility.
  4. Issue #40875: Pure CSS tooltip

    • Discussion on potential implementations of CSS-only tooltips.
  5. Issue #40873: Option to Synchronize Modal Backdrop and Dialog Transitions

    • Proposal for enhancing modal behavior during transitions.

Analysis of Themes and Commonalities

A clear theme among recent issues is the interaction between Bootstrap components and modern web practices, particularly regarding user experience (UX) and accessibility:

  • Form Elements: Multiple issues (#40879, #40885) highlight problems with form validation and overlapping icons, especially when using browser autofill features.

  • Modals and Tooltips: There is an ongoing discussion around improving modal transitions (#40873) and tooltip functionality (#40875), indicating that users are seeking more intuitive interactions.

  • Documentation Gaps: Several issues express frustration over insufficient documentation or examples for new features (e.g., how to implement responsive collapsibles or manage color themes effectively).

  • Dark Mode Compatibility: Issues related to dark mode (#39070) suggest that while Bootstrap has made strides in supporting this feature, there are still inconsistencies that need addressing.

These themes suggest that while Bootstrap remains a robust framework, there is a pressing need for enhancements that align its components with contemporary web standards and user expectations.

Report On: Fetch pull requests



Overview

The analysis of the provided pull requests (PRs) for the Bootstrap project reveals a diverse range of contributions aimed at enhancing functionality, fixing bugs, and improving documentation. The PRs cover various aspects of the framework, including accessibility improvements, new features, and refinements to existing components.

Summary of Pull Requests

  1. PR #40895: Updates development dependencies across the project.
  2. PR #40894: Similar to PR #40895, it updates development dependencies but was closed without merging.
  3. PR #40893: Another update to development dependencies, closed without merging.
  4. PR #40892: Adds a new utility class for cursor properties.
  5. PR #40891: Introduces new CSS variables for better customization options.
  6. PR #40890: Fixes an issue with the modal backdrop in sticky containers.
  7. PR #40889: Enhances the dropdown component by allowing cycling inside nested dropdowns.
  8. PR #40888: Addresses accessibility issues by ensuring scrollable regions are keyboard accessible.

Analysis of Pull Requests

Common Themes

  • Dependency Management: Several PRs focus on updating development dependencies, which is crucial for maintaining security and compatibility with other tools and libraries used in the project.
  • Accessibility Improvements: There is a strong emphasis on enhancing accessibility features across various components, ensuring that Bootstrap remains compliant with modern web standards and is usable by everyone.

Notable Features

  • The introduction of new utility classes and CSS variables indicates an effort to provide developers with more customization options directly through CSS, reducing the need for extensive overrides in custom stylesheets.
  • Fixes related to component behavior (e.g., modal backdrop handling) demonstrate ongoing maintenance and refinement efforts to improve user experience.

Anomalies

  • Some PRs were closed without merging despite addressing important updates or fixes (e.g., PR #40894). This could be due to overlapping changes with other PRs or decisions made by maintainers regarding the necessity or implementation approach.

Lack of Recent Merge Activity

While there is a steady flow of PRs being opened and updated, the lack of recent merges (as seen in the closed PRs) may indicate either a high volume of contributions that require careful review or potential bottlenecks in the review process.

Conclusion

The pull requests analyzed reflect Bootstrap's commitment to continuous improvement through community contributions. The focus on dependency updates, accessibility enhancements, and feature refinements highlights an active effort to keep the framework modern, secure, and user-friendly. However, the closure of several PRs without merging suggests a need for clearer communication or prioritization within the project's contribution process.

Report On: Fetch commits



Repo Commits Analysis

Development Team and Recent Activity

Team Members:

  • Hannah Issermann (hannahiss)

    • Recent Activity:
    • Updated documentation to indicate links in foreign languages on the Translations page.
    • Added missing aria-label to SVG with tooltip.
    • Added missing $enable-css-grid in 'Customize > Options'.
  • Julien Déramond (julien-deramond)

    • Recent Activity:
    • Fixed $enable-css-grid variable name in documentation.
    • Dropped Safari version notice in 'Helpers > Stacks'.
    • Made multiple updates to the layout documentation, including descriptions and formatting of Sass code.
  • XhmikosR

    • Recent Activity:
    • Ignored more dependencies in package.json.
    • Updated multiple development dependencies including jasmine and stylelint.
    • Managed various dependency bumps through Dependabot.
  • Christian Oliff (coliff)

    • Recent Activity:
    • Removed unneeded flexbug workaround for Internet Explorer.
    • Updated modal documentation regarding min-height.
  • Dependabot[bot]

    • Recent Activity:
    • Automated updates for numerous dependencies, resulting in significant changes across files.
    • Engaged in fixing stylelint-config issues and updating npm packages.
  • Louis-Maxime Piton (louismaximepiton)

    • Recent Activity:
    • Added .border-circle and .border-pill classes to border utility documentation.
    • Made adjustments to grid layout documentation.
  • Dmitry Sergienko (bbonch)

    • Recent Activity:
    • Fixed popover behavior when toggled after being shown.

Patterns and Themes

  1. Documentation Focus: A significant portion of recent commits is dedicated to improving and updating documentation, indicating a strong emphasis on clarity and usability for developers using Bootstrap.

  2. Collaborative Efforts: Several commits feature co-authorship, suggesting a collaborative environment where team members frequently work together on tasks.

  3. Dependency Management: There is ongoing maintenance of dependencies, particularly through automated tools like Dependabot, which helps keep the project up-to-date with minimal manual intervention.

  4. Feature Enhancements: The team is actively enhancing features such as accessibility improvements (aria-labels, tooltips) and refining existing functionalities (e.g., modal behaviors).

  5. Active Branch Management: Multiple branches are being actively developed, indicating ongoing feature work and enhancements beyond just bug fixes.

Conclusion

The development team is actively engaged in enhancing Bootstrap through documentation updates, collaborative feature improvements, and diligent dependency management. The focus on accessibility and usability reflects a commitment to maintaining Bootstrap's relevance in modern web development practices.