‹ Reports
The Dispatch

GitHub Repo Analysis: hoppscotch/hoppscotch

Executive Summary

Hoppscotch is an open-source API development tool designed to be a lightweight alternative to Postman and Insomnia. Managed by the organization hoppscotch, it offers a comprehensive set of features for API testing and development. The project is active with a strong community presence, indicated by its high number of stars and forks on GitHub. Currently, the project is focused on improving synchronization, UI/UX, and compatibility with other tools.

Recent Activity

Recent activities show a collaborative effort in addressing both frontend and backend issues. The team is actively working on feature enhancements and bug fixes, with a focus on improving user experience and system stability.

Risks

Of Note

Quantified Reports

Quantify issues



Recent GitHub Issues Activity

Timespan Opened Closed Comments Labeled Milestones
7 Days 8 3 26 0 1
30 Days 46 16 120 1 1
90 Days 113 52 234 5 1
1 Year 371 182 869 10 1
All Time 1627 1219 - - -

Like all software activity quantification, these numbers are imperfect but sometimes useful. Comments, Labels, and Milestones refer to those issues opened in the timespan in question.

Rate pull requests



2/5
The pull request involves a large number of changes across multiple JSON files, indicating a potentially significant update. However, the lack of detailed description and context about what these changes achieve or fix makes it difficult to assess their importance or quality. The absence of a linked issue or clear explanation further detracts from its clarity and potential impact. Without more information, this PR appears incomplete and lacks the necessary detail to be considered above average.
[+] Read More
3/5
The pull request primarily involves updating dependencies for the hoppscotch-backend, which is a routine task. While it includes a significant number of changes in terms of lines and files, the nature of these changes is not particularly complex or innovative. The PR does address a failing test case, which adds some value, but overall, it lacks significant impact or complexity. There are no major flaws, but also no exceptional aspects that would warrant a higher rating.
[+] Read More
3/5
This pull request involves a straightforward update of dependencies in the sh-admin repo. While it is important to keep dependencies up-to-date for security and performance reasons, the PR lacks complexity or significant changes beyond version bumps. The PR is well-structured, with all tests passing, but it remains a routine maintenance task rather than a substantial or innovative contribution. It does not require documentation updates and is still in draft form, indicating it might not be ready for final review. Overall, it is an average PR that fulfills its purpose without any remarkable aspects.
[+] Read More
3/5
This pull request is a routine update to bump dependencies across multiple packages in the project. While it addresses necessary maintenance, it lacks significant innovation or complexity. The changes are mostly straightforward updates to version numbers and minor syntax adjustments. The PR is still in draft state, indicating that further verification is needed. Overall, it is an average PR that fulfills its purpose but doesn't introduce any remarkable improvements or features.
[+] Read More
3/5
The pull request involves major version dependency bumps for the 'hoppscotch-selfhost-desktop' package, which is a routine maintenance task. While it is important to keep dependencies up-to-date for security and performance reasons, this PR does not introduce any new features or significant changes to the codebase. The changes are straightforward and appear to be correctly implemented, but they lack any notable innovation or complexity. As such, this PR is average and unremarkable, fitting well within the criteria for a rating of 3.
[+] Read More
3/5
The pull request introduces an OpenSSL-only fork of the `curl-rust` crate, which enhances cross-platform compatibility. It removes support for alternative TLS backends and modifies the build process to ensure static linking with OpenSSL. While these changes are significant for ensuring consistent SSL handling, they also reduce flexibility by removing support for other TLS backends. The PR is well-structured but lacks thorough documentation and testing details, which are crucial for such a fundamental change. Overall, it's a solid update but not without its trade-offs.
[+] Read More
4/5
This pull request introduces a user-friendly feature by displaying login dialogues for features that require authentication, enhancing user experience. The implementation is clear and concise, with appropriate checks for user authentication before triggering actions. The changes are well-contained within specific components, ensuring minimal disruption to existing functionality. However, the PR could benefit from additional testing or documentation to ensure robustness and clarity, which prevents it from achieving a perfect score.
[+] Read More
4/5
This pull request effectively addresses a significant issue by differentiating CORS settings for development and production environments, enhancing security while maintaining flexibility. The changes are well-structured, with clear logic and code cleanup that removes redundancy. The PR is tested locally, ensuring functionality. However, it lacks detailed documentation or additional test cases that could further validate the changes. Overall, it's a solid improvement but not exemplary.
[+] Read More
4/5
The pull request introduces a new component, HttpResponseMeta, to enhance GraphQL response handling, which is a significant and useful improvement. It also removes redundancy by commenting out the AppShortcutsPrompt. The changes are well-contained and improve the codebase without introducing complexity. However, the PR could benefit from additional testing or validation to ensure that the new data handling logic in connection.ts is robust. Overall, it's a solid contribution with minor room for improvement.
[+] Read More
4/5
The pull request introduces a useful feature by allowing customization of the collection import size limit, enhancing flexibility for users. The code changes are well-contained, with appropriate updates to internationalization strings and platform configuration. However, the lack of documentation updates is a minor drawback, as it may lead to confusion for users unaware of this new capability. Overall, it's a significant and well-executed improvement but not exemplary due to the missing documentation update.
[+] Read More

Quantify commits



Quantified Commit Activity Over 14 Days

Developer Avatar Branches PRs Commits Files Changes
James George (jamesgeorge007) 1 1/0/0 4 19 17101
Andrew Bastin 1 1/2/0 8 114 15351
Mir Arif Hasan (mirarifhasan) 1 1/0/0 6 7 13331
Anwarul Islam 1 3/1/1 1 3 465
Joel Jacob Stephen 1 3/1/0 1 2 114
Shreyas (CuriousCorrelation) 1 2/0/0 3 3 40
Dmitry 1 0/1/0 1 1 11
Akash K 1 2/1/0 1 2 11
Nivedin 1 1/1/0 1 1 4
shuaixr 1 1/1/0 1 1 4
None (HetuKariya) 0 1/0/0 0 0 0
Luke Barrett (barrettluke) 0 1/0/0 0 0 0
Binayak Bhattacharjee (ZenMachina16) 0 1/0/0 0 0 0
Pranay Pandey (Pranay-Pandey) 0 2/0/0 0 0 0
Perpetuity (gitadityakumar) 0 1/0/0 0 0 0

PRs: created by that dev and opened/merged/closed-unmerged during the period

Quantify risks



Project Risk Ratings

Risk Level (1-5) Rationale
Delivery 4 The project faces significant delivery risks due to a persistent backlog of unresolved issues. In the past 90 days, 113 issues were opened and only 52 closed, indicating a growing backlog. Key issues like #4436 and #4423 highlight critical data synchronization problems that could lead to data loss, affecting delivery timelines and user satisfaction. The draft status of several pull requests, such as PR #4444, further suggests potential delays in integration.
Velocity 3 Velocity is moderate but at risk due to the high volume of changes and unresolved issues. While there is active development with significant contributions from key developers like James George and Andrew Bastin, the presence of long-standing open PRs such as #3600 indicates potential stagnation. The rapid pace of development requires careful management to avoid introducing bugs or inconsistencies.
Dependency 2 Dependency risks are being actively managed through routine updates and dependency bumps, as seen in PRs #4444 and #4426. The use of tools like 'vet' for automated vetting of open-source dependencies (#4439) further mitigates these risks. However, the complexity of managing numerous dependencies could pose challenges if not regularly reviewed.
Team 3 The team shows strong collaboration with multiple co-authored commits and active management of pull requests. However, the uneven distribution of workload among developers could lead to burnout for heavily involved contributors. The growing backlog of issues also suggests potential stress on the team if not addressed.
Code Quality 4 Code quality is at risk due to the high number of unresolved issues and large volume of changes without detailed documentation or testing information. Issues like #4436 and PR #4438 highlight potential problems in maintaining code quality. The lack of comprehensive testing details in several PRs poses additional risks.
Technical Debt 4 Technical debt appears to be accumulating, as indicated by persistent bugs and performance concerns with large datasets (#3935). The high number of open issues and draft pull requests suggest underlying problems that need addressing to prevent further debt accumulation.
Test Coverage 3 Test coverage is moderate but requires improvement. While some efforts are made to address test failures, such as in PR #4442, the lack of detailed testing information in many PRs poses risks to stability. The rapid pace of development necessitates robust testing to ensure reliability.
Error Handling 3 Error handling is moderately addressed but needs enhancement. Issues related to OAuth2 token management (#4410) and JSON parsing errors (#4403) indicate gaps in error handling that could affect security and user experience. Efforts are being made to improve this area, but more comprehensive strategies are needed.

Detailed Reports

Report On: Fetch issues



GitHub Issues Analysis

Recent Activity Analysis

Recent activity in the Hoppscotch repository shows a mix of bug reports, feature requests, and discussions around enhancements. Notably, there are several issues related to synchronization, data handling, and user interface improvements.

Anomalies and Themes

  • Data Synchronization and Loss: Multiple issues (#4436, #4423) highlight problems with data synchronization, particularly when switching environments or after updates. Users report losing collections or having unsynchronized environments across devices.

  • User Interface Concerns: There are reports of UI elements not behaving as expected (#4409, #4404), such as buttons not functioning or visual inconsistencies in dark mode (#4389).

  • Import/Export Challenges: Users face difficulties importing collections from Postman (#3961) and exporting to OpenAPI format (#3821), indicating potential compatibility issues.

  • Authorization and Security: Several issues relate to OAuth2 and token management (#4410, #3956), suggesting a need for more robust handling of authentication processes.

  • Performance and Usability: Performance concerns are raised regarding large datasets (#3935) and slow rendering times (#4349). Usability features like environment variable management (#4069) and request tab management (#3866) are frequently requested.

Issue Details

Most Recently Created Issues

  • #4439: Proposal to adopt vet for automated vetting of OSS dependencies. Created 1 day ago.
  • #4436: Feature request for improved sync strategy for user data. Created 2 days ago.
  • #4434: Feature request to read OAuth2 config from OIDC auto-configuration endpoint. Created 3 days ago.

Most Recently Updated Issues

  • #4428: Bug about workspace invitation errors. Updated 2 days ago.
  • #4427: Feature request for JSON beautification. Updated 5 days ago.
  • #4425: Bug with CLI collection execution. Updated 1 day ago.

High Priority Issues

  • #4410: Feature request for using two environments simultaneously, highlighting a significant usability enhancement.
  • #4403: Critical bug affecting JSON parsing due to recent changes, impacting many users.
  • #4383: Bug causing loss of personal workspace data after updates, affecting user trust and data integrity.

These issues reflect ongoing challenges in maintaining data integrity, enhancing user experience, and ensuring compatibility with other tools like Postman. The focus on improving synchronization, authorization handling, and UI responsiveness is critical for the project's continued success and user satisfaction.

Report On: Fetch pull requests



Analysis of Pull Requests

Open Pull Requests

Notable Open PRs

  1. #4444: Bump Dependencies

    • State: Open, Draft
    • Created by: James George
    • Details: This PR aims to update dependencies across multiple packages. It's crucial to verify behavior post-update, especially since major version bumps are included. The draft status indicates ongoing work or pending verification.

  2. #4440: Custom Collection Import Size Limit

    • State: Open
    • Created by: Joel Jacob Stephen
    • Details: Introduces the ability to set a custom import size limit for collections, changing the default from 10MB to 50MB for self-host-web. This could impact users handling large datasets.

  3. #4435: GraphQL Response Meta Component

    • State: Open
    • Created by: Luke Barrett
    • Details: Adds a component to handle GraphQL HTTP responses, potentially improving response handling and user experience.

  4. #4416: Fix Trailing Comma in JSON

    • State: Open
    • Created by: Anwarul Islam
    • Details: Fixes an issue with trailing commas in JSON causing invalid requests. This is crucial for maintaining data integrity during server communication.

Issues with Open PRs

  • #3600: Collection Runner Feature (323 days old)
    • This PR has been open for almost a year and is still in draft status. It indicates significant delays or challenges in implementation. Community interest is high, as seen from comments, but progress seems stalled.

Recently Closed Pull Requests

  1. #4429: Resolve i18n Strings on Error Toast

    • Merged by: James George
    • Details: Fixes internationalization issues in error messages related to member removal actions.

  2. #4402: Comments Stripping in JSON

    • Merged by: James George
    • Details: Addresses an issue where JSON comments were incorrectly stripped, affecting URL parsing.

  3. #4398: Fallback for REST Tab Schema Type

    • Merged by: James George
    • Details: Adds a fallback mechanism for missing type fields in REST tab schema, preventing app crashes.

  4. #4396: Hoppscotch Agent and Interceptor

    • Merged by: James George
    • Details: Introduces a new agent app and interceptor service, enhancing request execution capabilities without restrictions.

Notable Closed Without Merge

  • #4441: Back Collection Runner
    • Closed without merging after one day, indicating potential issues or reconsideration of the approach.

General Observations

  • The project is actively maintained with frequent updates and fixes.
  • There are several long-standing open PRs which may indicate complex features or resource constraints.
  • Recent merges focus on bug fixes and feature enhancements, showing a commitment to improving user experience and functionality.
  • The introduction of the Hoppscotch Agent (#4396) is a significant addition that could enhance the tool's capabilities in handling requests locally without browser limitations.

Recommendations

  • Prioritize resolving long-standing PRs like #3600 (Collection Runner) due to high community interest.
  • Ensure thorough testing of dependency updates (#4444) to prevent breaking changes.
  • Monitor the impact of newly introduced features like the Hoppscotch Agent on user workflows and gather feedback for further improvements.
  • Continue addressing bug fixes promptly to maintain stability and reliability of the application.

Report On: Fetch Files For Assessment



Analysis of Source Code Files

1. packages/hoppscotch-backend/package.json

  • Purpose: Defines the backend dependencies and scripts for building, testing, and running the application.

  • Structure:

    • Metadata: Includes basic information such as name, version, and author.
    • Scripts: Comprehensive set of scripts for various tasks like building (nest build), testing (jest), and starting the application in different modes (development, production).
    • Dependencies: Lists a wide range of dependencies including NestJS modules, Prisma, GraphQL, and authentication libraries like Passport.
    • DevDependencies: Includes tools for development such as ESLint, Jest, and TypeScript.

  • Quality:

    • The structure is well-organized with clear separation between dependencies and devDependencies.
    • Uses specific versions for dependencies which ensures stability but may require regular updates to avoid security vulnerabilities.
    • The use of scripts is extensive and covers most development needs.

2. packages/hoppscotch-common/src/components.d.ts

  • Purpose: TypeScript declaration file for Vue components used in the frontend.

  • Structure:

    • Declares a module augmentation for Vue, defining global components available throughout the application.
    • Each component is imported dynamically using typeof import.

  • Quality:

    • The file is auto-generated, indicated by comments such as /* eslint-disable */ and // @ts-nocheck, which suggests it may not be manually edited.
    • Provides a comprehensive list of components which aids in type safety and IntelliSense support in IDEs.

3. packages/hoppscotch-agent/src-tauri/Cargo.toml

  • Purpose: Defines Rust dependencies for the Hoppscotch agent using Tauri.

  • Structure:

    • Package Metadata: Basic information about the package including name, version, description, and authors.
    • Library Configuration: Specifies crate types for different build outputs.
    • Dependencies: Includes Tauri plugins and other Rust libraries like Serde for serialization and Tokio for async operations.

  • Quality:

    • Well-organized with clear separation between build dependencies and regular dependencies.
    • Uses specific versions for dependencies which is good for reproducibility but requires maintenance to keep up with updates.

4. packages/hoppscotch-common/src/pages/index.vue

  • Purpose: Main entry point for the frontend application, handling routing and initial rendering.

  • Structure:

    • Template Section: Defines the layout using custom components like AppPaneLayout, HoppSmartWindows, and others.
    • Script Section: Uses Vue's Composition API to manage state and lifecycle hooks. Imports various services and utilities to handle tab management and user interactions.

  • Quality:

    • The code is modular with a good separation of concerns, utilizing Vue's Composition API effectively.
    • State management appears robust with reactive references (ref) and computed properties (computed).
    • The use of TypeScript enhances type safety.

5. pnpm-lock.yaml

  • Purpose: Provides a snapshot of the entire dependency tree for the project using pnpm.

  • Structure:

    • Contains detailed information about each package version, its dependencies, and any overrides or settings applied globally.

  • Quality:

    • Essential for ensuring consistent installations across different environments.
    • The file is very large (over 28k lines), indicating a complex dependency tree which might complicate dependency management.

Overall Assessment

The codebase appears well-structured with a clear separation of concerns across different files. Dependency management is thorough but could benefit from regular updates to mitigate potential security risks. The use of TypeScript across the project enhances maintainability by providing type safety. The project leverages modern frameworks (Vue, NestJS) effectively to build a comprehensive API development tool.

Report On: Fetch commits



Repo Commits Analysis

Development Team and Recent Activity

Team Members and Activities

  • Andrew Bastin (AndrewBastin)

    • Recent activities include version bumps, dependency updates, and fixing JSON request body issues.
    • Worked on multiple files across different packages.

  • Joel Jacob Stephen (JoelJacobStephen)

    • Fixed i18n string issues and collaborated on admin dashboard features.
    • Involved in error handling improvements.

  • Akash K (amk-dev)

    • Worked on adding full request context and AI experiments.
    • Collaborated with James George on multiple features.

  • Dmitry (shipko)

    • Resolved issues with personal environments and collaborated on file download features.

  • Anwarul Islam (anwarulislam)

    • Implemented JSON prettification and support for comments in request bodies.
    • Engaged in multiple collaborations.

  • Nivedin (nivedin)

    • Focused on bug fixes related to UI elements and environment sorting.
    • Collaborated with various team members.

  • James George (jamesgeorge007)

    • Involved in dependency updates, AI experiments, and CLI improvements.
    • Frequent collaborator across different branches.

  • Shreyas (CuriousCorrelation)

    • Worked on client certificate settings and OpenSSL-only fork of curl-rust.
    • Made changes to authors list for alphabetical order.

  • Mir Arif Hasan (mirarifhasan)

    • Updated backend dependencies and fixed test cases.
    • Engaged in multiple backend-related tasks.

Patterns, Themes, and Conclusions

  • Collaborative Work: Many commits are co-authored, indicating a high level of collaboration among team members. This is evident in features like AI experiments, JSON prettification, and backend updates.

  • Frequent Version Bumps: Regular version updates suggest an emphasis on maintaining up-to-date dependencies and addressing vulnerabilities promptly.

  • Focus on Bug Fixes: A significant portion of recent activity revolves around resolving bugs, particularly related to UI/UX and backend functionality.

  • Diverse Contributions: Team members are involved in a wide range of tasks from frontend UI improvements to backend service enhancements, showcasing a versatile skill set within the team.

  • Continuous Improvement: The project exhibits ongoing refinement through refactoring efforts, such as improving error handling and updating configurations.

Overall, the development team is actively engaged in enhancing both the frontend and backend aspects of the project, with a strong focus on collaboration and continuous improvement.