‹ Reports
The Dispatch

GitHub Repo Analysis: Mbed-TLS/mbedtls

Executive Summary

Mbed TLS is an open-source C library for cryptographic operations, optimized for embedded systems. Managed by TrustedFirmware.org, it supports SSL/TLS protocols and includes a reference implementation of the PSA Cryptography API. The project is actively evolving with a focus on integrating new cryptographic standards and enhancing test coverage.

Recent Activity

Team Members and Activities

  1. Gilles Peskine (gilles-peskine-arm)

    • Merged PRs related to error codes, buffer fixes, and PSA crypto configuration.
    • Collaborated on test suite adjustments and CI performance.

  2. Ronald Cron (ronald-cron-arm)

    • Focused on enabling PSA_CRYPTO_CONFIG in test drivers.
    • Improved build scripts and documentation.

  3. David Horstmann (davidhorstmann-arm)

    • Managed version bumps and changelog updates.
    • Addressed CI testing issues.

  4. Valerio Setti (valeriosetti)

    • Fixed buffer overrun issues in PK write functions.
    • Extended test coverage.

  5. Harry Ramsey (Harry-Ramsey)

    • Refactored duplicate headers and improved code style support.

  6. Gergely Korcsák (gergelykarm)

    • Fixed driver schema JSON default type requirements.

Patterns and Themes

Risks

Of Note

Quantified Reports

Quantify issues



Recent GitHub Issues Activity

Timespan Opened Closed Comments Labeled Milestones
7 Days 13 4 1 2 1
30 Days 78 26 39 4 1
90 Days 149 71 180 25 1
All Time 3997 2765 - - -

Like all software activity quantification, these numbers are imperfect but sometimes useful. Comments, Labels, and Milestones refer to those issues opened in the timespan in question.

Rate pull requests



3/5
The pull request introduces a new feature for interruptible key generation and export public key PSA API, which is a moderately significant change. However, it is still in draft state and lacks a detailed description and checklist completion, indicating potential incompleteness. The changes are extensive but not yet finalized, and without tests provided, it is difficult to assess the quality fully. Therefore, it is rated as average or unremarkable at this stage.
[+] Read More
3/5
This pull request involves moving TLS auxiliary test scripts to a framework, which is a structural change rather than a functional one. The PR is well-documented and includes necessary references to related issues and other PRs. However, the changes are mostly about file movements with minimal code modifications, making it an unremarkable update in terms of complexity or impact. The PR does not introduce new features or fix critical bugs, and the lack of required tests further suggests its limited significance. Thus, it is rated as average.
[+] Read More
3/5
This pull request involves moving TLS auxiliary test scripts to a framework, which is a structural change rather than a functional one. The PR is a backport, indicating it follows an already reviewed change. The changes are mostly file movements with minimal code alterations, and no new tests are required. While the change is necessary for maintaining consistency across versions, it lacks significant complexity or innovation. Therefore, it is average and unremarkable, fitting the criteria for a rating of 3.
[+] Read More
3/5
The pull request effectively splits the error.c file into two separate files and relocates them within the Mbed TLS project, which is necessary for version 4.0. It addresses CI errors and makes several updates to build scripts and test configurations. However, it lacks thorough documentation and clarity in some areas, such as the rationale behind certain changes. Additionally, the PR is still in draft status, indicating it may not be fully complete or ready for final review. The changes are significant but not exceptional, warranting an average rating.
[+] Read More
3/5
This pull request addresses specific issues introduced in a previous PR by re-enabling tests and adjusting compiler flags for older GCC versions. While it resolves performance problems and restores test coverage, the changes are relatively minor and specific to certain configurations. The PR lacks a changelog update and requires further follow-up actions, indicating it is not entirely self-contained. Overall, it is an average contribution that fixes targeted issues without introducing significant new features or improvements.
[+] Read More
3/5
The pull request involves a backport of a refactoring task for the `all.sh` script in the Mbed TLS project. It aligns the script with the development branch and includes additional commits specific to version 3.6. The changes are mostly structural, involving moving functions and aligning code, with one temporary change that is reverted later. While it is a necessary maintenance task, it lacks significant impact or complexity that would warrant a higher rating. The PR is well-organized but not particularly remarkable or innovative.
[+] Read More
4/5
The pull request addresses several minor defects identified by Coverity, focusing on parameter validation to prevent undefined behavior. It includes documentation updates, test enhancements, and code clean-up, which are all positive contributions to the codebase. The changes are well-documented and improve the robustness of the code. However, the impact is limited to specific cases of undefined behavior, which slightly limits its overall significance.
[+] Read More
4/5
The pull request effectively switches the test coverage analysis to enforcement mode, ensuring all test cases are executed in CI. It addresses unexecuted test cases by providing a mechanism for legitimate exceptions. The PR is comprehensive, with numerous commits refining test filtering and improving configurations. It backports changes from a related PR, adapting them for version 3.6, demonstrating thoroughness and attention to detail. However, it lacks groundbreaking changes or innovations that would warrant a perfect score.
[+] Read More
4/5
This pull request is a release candidate for Mbed TLS 3.6.2, focusing on a critical bug fix related to buffer overruns in key writing functions. It includes a version bump, changelog entry, and documentation updates. The changes are well-documented and address specific security vulnerabilities (CVE-2024-49195), making it significant and thorough. However, it is primarily a maintenance release with no groundbreaking new features, which slightly limits its impact. The PR is well-structured with clear commit messages and includes necessary tests, but lacks broader enhancements that would warrant a perfect score.
[+] Read More
4/5
This pull request introduces a Neon implementation of ChaCha20, which offers significant performance improvements and code size reductions compared to the scalar implementation. It is well-tested across various ARM architectures and compiler versions, ensuring broad compatibility. The PR includes detailed performance metrics and configuration options for different block settings, demonstrating thoroughness and attention to detail. However, while the changes are significant and well-documented, the complexity of the implementation could pose maintenance challenges, preventing it from being rated as exemplary.
[+] Read More

Quantify commits



Quantified Commit Activity Over 14 Days

Developer Avatar Branches PRs Commits Files Changes
David Horstmann 5 1/0/1 22 32 496938
Gilles Peskine 2 7/6/1 37 18 3661
Ronald Cron 1 1/2/0 12 6 323
Valerio Setti 4 3/1/1 6 4 164
Harry Ramsey 1 4/4/0 8 37 107
Gergely Korcsák 2 2/2/0 2 3 14
Manuel Pégourié-Gonnard (mpg) 0 2/0/1 0 0 0
Janos Follath 0 0/0/0 0 0 0
Elena Uziunaite (eleuzi01) 0 2/0/0 0 0 0
Dave Rodgman (daverodgman) 0 1/0/0 0 0 0
Tom Cosgrove 0 0/0/0 0 0 0
Waleed-Ziad Maamoun-Elmelegy (waleed-elmelegy-arm) 0 1/0/0 0 0 0

PRs: created by that dev and opened/merged/closed-unmerged during the period

Quantify risks



Project Risk Ratings

Risk Level (1-5) Rationale
Delivery 4 The project faces significant delivery risks due to a growing backlog of issues and unresolved dependencies. With 1232 open issues and a trend of more issues being opened than closed, there's a clear risk of not meeting delivery targets. Dependencies on unmerged PRs like #9690 further exacerbate this risk, as they can delay critical updates.
Velocity 4 Velocity is at risk due to the imbalance in issue resolution (13 opened vs. 4 closed recently) and dependency bottlenecks such as PR #9703 waiting on #9690. The uneven distribution of commits among developers also suggests potential team-related velocity issues.
Dependency 3 Dependency risks are moderate, with specific issues like #9687 indicating challenges in maintaining compatibility with external libraries. Unresolved dependencies in PRs such as #9703 also highlight potential delays.
Team 3 Team risks are present due to uneven workload distribution among developers and potential bottlenecks in decision-making, as indicated by help-wanted labels on several issues (#9677, #9649).
Code Quality 3 Code quality is generally good but faces risks from large changes by key contributors (e.g., David Horstmann's significant refactoring) and incomplete documentation in PRs like #9667. The presence of spurious framework changes in PRs like #9701 also raises concerns.
Technical Debt 3 Technical debt is a concern due to complex logic and conditional compilation blocks in core files like ssl_tls.c and ssl_msg.c. Efforts to refactor and remove outdated code (#9685) are ongoing but need more focus.
Test Coverage 4 Test coverage is at risk due to incomplete testing in key PRs (#9667) and temporary removal of slow tests affecting CI performance. Numerous issues and PRs focus on testing enhancements, but gaps remain.
Error Handling 3 Error handling is addressed through consistent use of return codes and debug messages, but manual memory management poses risks. Recent fixes for buffer overruns (#9690) highlight ongoing challenges.

Detailed Reports

Report On: Fetch issues



GitHub Issues Analysis

Recent Activity Analysis

Recent activity in the Mbed TLS repository shows a focus on enhancing cryptographic capabilities, resolving bugs, and improving test coverage. Notable themes include the integration of PSA Crypto APIs, TLS 1.3 enhancements, and addressing configuration issues.

Notable Anomalies and Themes

  • PSA Cryptography Integration: Many issues (#9705, #9704, #9678) focus on integrating and testing PSA cryptography features, indicating a significant push towards adopting the PSA API.

  • TLS 1.3 Enhancements: Several issues (#9697, #9650) address TLS 1.3 support and improvements, reflecting ongoing efforts to enhance protocol support.

  • Configuration Challenges: Issues like #9627 and #9622 highlight challenges with configuration management, especially concerning generated files and PSA configurations.

  • Legacy Feature Removal: There is a trend towards removing outdated features (e.g., DES in #9164), aligning with modern security practices.

  • Testing Gaps: Multiple issues (#9591, #9589) focus on improving test coverage for various configurations, indicating an ongoing effort to ensure robustness across different setups.

Issue Details

Most Recently Created Issues

  1. #9705: Implement tf-psa-crypto pointer CI check

    • Priority: Enhancement
    • Status: Open
    • Created: 0 days ago

  2. #9704: Implement framework pointer CI check

    • Priority: Enhancement
    • Status: Open
    • Created: 0 days ago

  3. #9697: TLS1.3 support ClientHello extension certificate_authorities

    • Priority: Suggested enhancement
    • Status: Open
    • Created: 3 days ago

Most Recently Updated Issues

  1. #9699: Slow tests with old GCC + Asan in Mbed TLS 3.6.2

    • Priority: Bug
    • Status: Closed
    • Updated: 1 day ago

  2. #9670: mbedtls_ssl_renegotiate and mbedtls_ssl_handshake symbols occur more than once?

    • Priority: Bug
    • Status: Closed
    • Updated: 10 days ago

  3. #9658: Enable MBEDTLS_PSA_CRYPTO_CONFIG in test_psa_crypto_drivers

    • Priority: Enhancement
    • Status: Closed
    • Updated: 1 day ago

Key Observations

  • The recent closure of issues indicates active maintenance and resolution of critical bugs.
  • Enhancements related to PSA Crypto API are prioritized, reflecting strategic alignment with Arm's security architecture.
  • Configuration management remains a recurring theme, with efforts to streamline build processes and improve test coverage.

Overall, the Mbed TLS project is actively evolving to incorporate new cryptographic standards while addressing legacy issues and enhancing its testing infrastructure.

Report On: Fetch pull requests



Analysis of Pull Requests for Mbed TLS

Open Pull Requests

Notable Open PRs

  1. #9703: Revert & fix #9690 workarounds

    • State: Open
    • Priority: High
    • Issues: Depends on #9690, which is not yet merged. Review comments suggest a need for a signoff line to pass checks.
    • Action Needed: Wait for #9690 to merge, then rebase and address review comments.

  2. #9702: [Backport 3.6] Refactor all.sh

    • State: Open
    • Priority: Medium
    • Issues: Minor review comment regarding code suggestion.
    • Action Needed: Address review comments and ensure alignment with development branch.

  3. #9701: Neon impl of ChaCha20 (better size & perf)

    • State: Open
    • Priority: Medium
    • Issues: Review comment suggests a spurious framework change.
    • Action Needed: Clarify or remove the unnecessary framework change.

  4. #9694: Release 3.6.2 with 3.6.1 + the pkwrite patch

    • State: Open
    • Priority: Very High
    • Issues: Marked DO-NOT-MERGE; requires additional CI adjustments.
    • Action Needed: Ensure all CI tests pass and address any outstanding issues before merging.

  5. #9639: Add PSA interruptible key generation setup & abort APIs

    • State: Open
    • Priority: High
    • Issues: Lacks changelog entry; needs further testing.
    • Action Needed: Add changelog entry and complete testing.

Draft and In-Progress PRs

  • Several PRs are in draft status or marked as needing work, such as #9667 and #9567, indicating ongoing development or awaiting further input.

Recently Closed PRs

  • No recently closed PRs were highlighted in the data provided.

General Observations

  • Many open PRs are related to PSA Crypto API enhancements or refactoring efforts, indicating ongoing improvements in cryptographic functionality.
  • There is a focus on backporting changes to maintain consistency across different branches, especially for version 3.6.
  • Some PRs have dependencies on others, which can delay progress if not managed effectively.

Recommendations

  1. Prioritize High-Priority PRs: Focus on resolving issues in high-priority PRs like #9694 to prevent blocking releases.
  2. Manage Dependencies Effectively: Ensure that dependent PRs like #9703 are aligned with their base branches to avoid integration issues.
  3. Improve Documentation and Testing: Ensure that all changes are well-documented and thoroughly tested to maintain code quality.
  4. Address Review Comments Promptly: Encourage contributors to address review comments quickly to facilitate smoother merges.

By addressing these areas, the Mbed TLS project can continue to enhance its cryptographic capabilities while maintaining stability across its various versions and configurations.

Report On: Fetch Files For Assessment



Source Code Assessment

File: library/x509_crt.c

Structure and Quality

  • Purpose: This file handles X.509 certificate parsing and verification, a critical component for TLS operations.
  • Includes and Dependencies:
    • Utilizes several conditional includes based on defined macros, indicating modularity and configurability.
    • Includes headers for cryptographic operations, threading, and platform-specific utilities.
  • Data Structures:
    • Defines structures like x509_crt_verify_chain_item for managing certificate chains.
    • Uses profiles (mbedtls_x509_crt_profile) to enforce security policies.
  • Functions:
    • Functions are well-organized and follow a consistent pattern for error handling using return codes.
    • Implements various helper functions for ASN.1 parsing, which are crucial for certificate handling.
  • Error Handling:
    • Extensive use of error codes and macros for robust error reporting.
  • Code Quality:
    • The code is well-commented, providing context and references to standards (e.g., RFCs).
    • Uses static functions to limit scope where appropriate, enhancing encapsulation.

File: tests/scripts/check_files.py

Structure and Quality

  • Purpose: This script checks source files for common issues like incorrect permissions, line endings, and coding style violations.
  • Class Design:
    • Implements a base class FileIssueTracker with subclasses for specific issues (e.g., ShebangIssueTracker, Utf8BomIssueTracker).
    • Good use of inheritance to extend functionality for different types of file checks.
  • Functionality:
    • Uses regular expressions extensively to identify issues in files.
    • Supports path normalization to ensure cross-platform compatibility.
  • Logging:
    • Utilizes Python's logging module to report issues, allowing easy redirection of output.
  • Code Quality:
    • Code is clear and modular, making it easy to add new checks.
    • Includes detailed docstrings explaining the purpose of classes and methods.

File: tf-psa-crypto/tests/suites/test_suite_pkwrite.function

Structure and Quality

  • Purpose: Tests related to PK write functions, focusing on PEM/DER formats and buffer size handling.
  • Test Design:
    • Defines test cases using macros (BEGIN_CASE, END_CASE) for structured test definitions.
    • Includes helper functions like fix_new_lines to handle platform-specific newline issues.
  • PSA Integration:
    • Conditional compilation based on PSA configuration indicates integration with PSA Crypto API.
  • Code Quality:
    • Tests are comprehensive, covering both public and private key scenarios.
    • Uses assertions (TEST_EQUAL, TEST_ASSERT) to validate outcomes effectively.

File: CMakeLists.txt

Structure and Quality

  • Purpose: Manages build configurations using CMake, supporting various build options and environments.
  • Configuration Options:
    • Provides numerous options (ENABLE_PROGRAMS, UNSAFE_BUILD) to customize the build process.
    • Supports both static and shared library builds, enhancing flexibility.
  • Compiler Support:
    • Contains logic to handle different compilers (GCC, Clang, MSVC), ensuring broad compatibility.
  • Code Quality:
    • Well-documented with comments explaining design considerations and policy settings.
    • Uses modern CMake practices like target-based include directories.

File: docs/architecture/psa-keystore-design.md

Structure and Quality

  • Purpose: Describes the architecture of the PSA key store in Mbed TLS, focusing on memory management and concurrency.
  • Content Organization:
    • Clearly structured into sections covering key slot management, concurrency, and implementation variants.
    • Provides detailed explanations of different key store designs (static vs. dynamic).
  • Concurrency Considerations:
    • Discusses reader-writer locks for thread safety, indicating attention to multithreading concerns.
  • Future Improvements:
    • Mentions potential future enhancements, showing forward-thinking design considerations.

Overall, the codebase demonstrates high quality with a focus on modularity, configurability, and adherence to standards. Error handling is robust across files, with clear documentation aiding maintainability.

Report On: Fetch commits



Repo Commits Analysis

Development Team and Recent Activity

Team Members and Activities

Gilles Peskine (gilles-peskine-arm)

  • Recent Work:
    • Merged several pull requests related to error codes, buffer overrun fixes, and PSA crypto configuration.
    • Worked on test suite adjustments, CI performance issues, and documentation updates.
    • Involved in refactoring and splitting scripts for better modularity.
  • Collaboration: Collaborated with Valerio Setti, Ronald Cron, and others on various bug fixes and feature enhancements.

Ronald Cron (ronald-cron-arm)

  • Recent Work:
    • Focused on PSA_CRYPTO_CONFIG enabling in test drivers.
    • Made improvements to build scripts and configuration files.
    • Fixed comments and minor documentation errors.
  • Collaboration: Worked with Gilles Peskine on several pull requests.

David Horstmann (davidhorstmann-arm)

  • Recent Work:
    • Deferred static keystore changes to future releases.
    • Managed version bumps and changelog updates for new releases.
    • Addressed CI testing issues by commenting out problematic tests.
  • Collaboration: Coordinated with Gilles Peskine and Valerio Setti on release management tasks.

Valerio Setti (valeriosetti)

  • Recent Work:
    • Fixed buffer overrun issues in PK write functions.
    • Extended test coverage for PK write checks.
  • Collaboration: Worked closely with Gilles Peskine on bug fixes.

Harry Ramsey (Harry-Ramsey)

  • Recent Work:
    • Refactored duplicate header files and improved code style support for submodules.
    • Fixed documentation errors and updated includes for generated files.
  • Collaboration: Engaged with Gilles Peskine and others on code improvements.

Gergely Korcsák (gergelykarm)

  • Recent Work:
    • Fixed driver schema JSON default type requirements.
  • Collaboration: Collaborated with Tom Cosgrove on schema fixes.

Patterns, Themes, and Conclusions

  • Active Collaboration: The team shows strong collaboration across various branches, focusing on bug fixes, feature enhancements, and performance improvements.
  • Focus on PSA Crypto: Significant efforts are directed towards enabling PSA_CRYPTO_CONFIG across different components, indicating a strategic focus on PSA cryptography integration.
  • Release Management: Regular updates to versioning and changelogs suggest a structured approach to release management, ensuring that changes are well-documented.
  • Code Quality Improvements: Refactoring efforts and code style enhancements are ongoing, highlighting a commitment to maintaining high code quality standards.
  • Testing Enhancements: Continuous improvements in test coverage and CI performance reflect an emphasis on robust testing practices.

Overall, the development team is actively engaged in enhancing Mbed TLS's functionality, performance, and maintainability through collaborative efforts.