FreeAPI.app is an open-source API hub designed to facilitate learning and mastery of API interactions across various programming languages. It is maintained by a community-driven effort, providing diverse APIs and educational resources. The project is in an active development phase, with a focus on expanding features and addressing technical challenges.
Active Development: The project shows robust activity with frequent updates and community engagement.
Feature Expansion: Recent focus on adding new APIs like image compression (#209) and movie data retrieval (#208).
Technical Challenges: Recurring issues with CORS policies (#196) and node version compatibility (#202).
Community Interaction: Strong emphasis on contributions and discussions via Discord.
Security Enhancements: Ongoing efforts to address security vulnerabilities (#200).
Fixed authentication bug related to refresh tokens.
Amit Harwani (amitHarwani)
Worked on ecommerce app features.
Atul Bhatt (atulbhatt-system32)
Implemented frontend features like status codes.
Vivek Moradiya (vvek1402)
Fixed missing .env.sample in the todo app.
Sarthak Agarwal (Sarthak-ONS)
Made minor address handling fixes.
Mitesh Savaliya (Mitesh0807)
Optimized public API performance.
Patterns and Themes
Security improvements are a major focus.
Shubham Waje plays a central role in integrating changes.
Continuous feature enhancements and code refactoring are ongoing.
Emphasis on testing and stability through Playwright.
Risks
Stalled PRs: Several PRs (#189, #183, #158) are delayed due to unresolved conflicts or pending changes, which could hinder progress.
CORS Issues: Persistent CORS policy problems (#196), affecting API usability.
Node Compatibility: Ongoing issues with node version compatibility (#202), potentially impacting users adopting newer tech stacks.
Swagger Documentation: Missing API documentation in swagger.yaml, which could lead to integration challenges.
Of Note
Server Reset Policy: The server resets every two hours, causing data loss, which may affect user experience unless locally hosted.
Community Engagement: Active participation via Discord highlights strong community involvement but requires effective management to maintain focus.
Quantified Reports
Quantify issues
Recent GitHub Issues Activity
Timespan
Opened
Closed
Comments
Labeled
Milestones
7 Days
4
3
8
0
1
30 Days
5
10
10
0
1
90 Days
11
12
21
4
1
1 Year
69
60
263
18
1
All Time
95
84
-
-
-
Like all software activity quantification, these numbers are imperfect but sometimes useful. Comments, Labels, and Milestones refer to those issues opened in the timespan in question.
Rate pull requests
2/5
The pull request is a draft and still a work in progress, with many controllers untested. There are numerous review comments indicating issues with code style, naming conventions, and formatting. The deletion and regeneration of the yarn.lock file introduces potential security risks and reliability issues. While the PR introduces significant functionality, the lack of testing and unresolved issues make it notably flawed at this stage.
[+] Read More
3/5
The pull request addresses minor corrections in string interpolation and message content within a validator and a controller. While it improves clarity and correctness, the changes are minimal and do not introduce significant new functionality or improvements. The PR also has unresolved conflicts and pending requested changes, which detracts from its completeness. Overall, it is an average contribution with some necessary fixes but lacks substantial impact.
[+] Read More
3/5
The pull request addresses a specific CORS issue related to preflight requests by adding 'preflightContinue' and specifying allowed methods. The change is minor, with only two lines added, and lacks detailed explanation or documentation. While it potentially fixes an issue, the significance and impact of the change are not clear from the PR description or comments. The lack of response to a request for clarification suggests incomplete communication, and the PR could benefit from more context or testing evidence. Overall, it's an average contribution with room for improvement in clarity and thoroughness.
[+] Read More
4/5
The pull request introduces a comprehensive admin module for an e-commerce application, implementing features such as category, product, coupon management, and order status updates. The changes are significant and well-structured, with clear additions to the codebase including new components and services. However, the PR has been open for a long time, indicating potential issues with merging or conflicts that need resolution. Additionally, the request for a live link and branch conflicts suggest some integration challenges. Overall, it is a substantial contribution but lacks final polish.
[+] Read More
4/5
The pull request addresses a significant user experience issue by adding a loading state for message sending, which provides immediate feedback to users and prevents multiple identical messages from being sent. The changes are well-documented and tested, ensuring that the enhancements work as intended. However, the PR could be improved by including a demo video of the UI changes, as requested in the comments. Additionally, there are unresolved conflicts that need attention. Overall, it's a well-executed improvement with minor areas for enhancement.
PRs: created by that dev and opened/merged/closed-unmerged during the period
Quantify risks
Project Risk Ratings
Risk
Level (1-5)
Rationale
Delivery
3
The project shows active engagement in addressing issues and feature requests, but the lack of structured labeling and milestone setting may pose risks to delivery due to potential inefficiencies in tracking and prioritizing tasks. Additionally, unresolved pull requests and dependency issues, such as compatibility with Node.js (#202), could impact delivery timelines.
Velocity
4
Recent commit activity reveals minimal engagement from developers, with no commits made by key contributors over the past 14 days. This inactivity signals potential risks related to velocity and delivery timelines. The prolonged open status of several pull requests (e.g., PR #158 open for 167 days) further indicates possible delays in project momentum.
Dependency
3
The project faces dependency risks highlighted by issues like Node.js compatibility (#202) and the deletion/regeneration of yarn.lock files in PRs. These actions introduce potential security vulnerabilities and compatibility challenges that could affect stability and delivery.
Team
3
While there is evidence of collaboration among team members, the lack of recent commits from key developers raises concerns about team engagement and potential burnout. The reliance on individuals like Shubham Waje for key updates may pose risks if responsibilities are not distributed evenly.
Code Quality
3
Code quality is a concern due to unresolved review comments pointing out inconsistencies in code style (e.g., PR #146). The absence of comprehensive testing for new controllers also poses risks to maintainability and quality.
Technical Debt
4
Technical debt is accumulating due to unresolved issues in pull requests, such as PR #146's draft status with numerous review comments. The lack of structured testing and dependency management further contributes to technical debt.
Test Coverage
4
The project lacks comprehensive testing, particularly for new features introduced in pull requests. The absence of explicit test cases or comments indicating test coverage goals suggests insufficient emphasis on testing practices, posing risks to reliability.
Error Handling
3
Error handling is addressed through custom exceptions, but potential risks exist due to synchronous operations in asynchronous contexts. The reliance on external systems like MongoDB requires careful management to avoid runtime errors.
Detailed Reports
Report On: Fetch issues
Recent Activity Analysis
Recent GitHub issue activity in the FreeAPI.app project shows a mix of feature requests, bug reports, and enhancements. The project is actively maintained with contributions from various users, indicating a healthy community engagement.
Notable Anomalies and Themes
Feature Requests and Enhancements:
Several feature requests focus on expanding API capabilities, such as adding image compression (#209) and comprehensive movie data retrieval (#208).
Enhancements like UI improvements (#161) and logging enhancements (#74) highlight ongoing efforts to improve user experience and maintainability.
Bug Reports:
Issues like CORS policy errors (#196) and node version compatibility (#202) indicate recurring technical challenges.
Security concerns are addressed, such as sensitive information exposure (#57).
Common Themes:
Many issues revolve around API functionality and integration, reflecting the project's core focus.
Contributions often suggest improvements to existing features or propose new functionalities, showing active community involvement.
Unaddressed Urgent Issues:
Some bugs related to compatibility with newer technologies (e.g., node versions) remain open, potentially affecting users trying to adopt the latest tech stack.
Community Interaction:
Discussions in comments reveal collaborative problem-solving and knowledge sharing among contributors.
Resolved after identifying configuration issues in user setups.
The project continues to evolve with active participation from its community, focusing on both expanding its API offerings and refining existing functionalities.
Details: Fixes refresh token update issue in the database.
#200: fix: high & medium security vulnerabilities for main & example apps
State: Merged
Details: Addresses security vulnerabilities across multiple apps.
Notable Issues
Stalled PRs: Several open PRs (#189, #183, #158) are stalled due to unresolved conflicts or pending changes. These need attention to avoid further delays.
Closed Without Merging: Some PRs like #207 and #203 were closed without merging due to non-compliance with guidelines or being test commits. This indicates a need for better initial guidance or checks before submission.
Security Fixes: The successful merging of security-related PRs (#200) is crucial for maintaining application integrity.
Large Feature Additions: PRs like #158 and #146 involve significant feature additions but face delays due to conflicts and review requirements. Prioritizing these could enhance project capabilities significantly.
Recommendations
Encourage contributors to resolve conflicts promptly and adhere to guidelines to streamline the review process.
Provide clear feedback on stalled PRs to facilitate progress.
Emphasize the importance of following contribution protocols to prevent unnecessary closures of PRs.
Imports: Comprehensive, covering middleware, routes, and utilities.
Middleware:
Well-organized global middleware setup, including CORS, rate limiting, and session management.
Routing:
Clear separation between public, app-specific, and kitchen sink routes.
Socket.IO Integration: Properly initialized and attached to the app instance.
Error Handling: Centralized error handling middleware is in place.
Swagger Integration: Set up at the root route for API documentation.
Improvements:
Consider modularizing route imports to improve maintainability.
5. Dockerfile
Structure & Quality:
Base Image: Uses a lightweight Node.js Alpine image, which is efficient for production.
Build Optimization:
Copies only necessary files initially to leverage Docker caching during builds.
User Management: Runs as a non-root user (node) enhancing security.
Improvements:
Consider multi-stage builds to further optimize image size.
Overall, the codebase demonstrates good practices in structure and error handling. Key areas for improvement include enhancing security measures in cookie management, ensuring comprehensive API documentation in swagger.yaml, and optimizing Docker build processes.
Report On: Fetch commits
Development Team and Recent Activity
Team Members and Activities
Shubham Waje (wajeshubham)
Recent Activity: Merged a pull request to update the refresh token in the database.
Collaborations: Worked with Suryoday Kaushik on the refresh token update.
Past Contributions: Addressed security vulnerabilities, refactored production URLs, and enabled seeding in production.
Suryoday Kaushik (suryo811)
Recent Activity: Worked on address formatting changes and collaborated with Shubham Waje on updating the refresh token.
Collaborations: Worked with Shubham Waje on the refresh token update.
Anirudh Jwala (jwala-anirudh)
Recent Activity: Resolved security dependencies for multiple apps including todo, chat-app, kitchen sink, and ecommerce web app.
Collaborations: Primarily worked independently on security updates.
Tejas Surse (TejasSurse)
Recent Activity: Updated todo.controllers.js for clarity and correctness using string interpolation.
Arnab Samanta (arnb-smnta)
Recent Activity: Fixed import problems, yarn.lock issues, and added a chatapp logout button feature.
Collaborations: Worked with Shubham Waje on various fixes and features.
Akash Kadlag (yntpdotme)
Recent Activity: Fixed an authentication bug related to clearing refresh tokens upon user logout.
Amit Harwani (amitHarwani)
Recent Activity: Worked on ecommerce web app features and fixed redirection URL issues.
Atul Bhatt (atulbhatt-system32)
Recent Activity: Implemented various frontend features including status codes, quiz page, and improved option selection.
Vivek Moradiya (vvek1402)
Recent Activity: Fixed missing .env.sample in the todo app.
Sarthak Agarwal (Sarthak-ONS)
Recent Activity: Made minor fixes related to address handling in orders.
Mitesh Savaliya (Mitesh0807)
Recent Activity: Improved public API performance by optimizing key removal process.
Patterns and Themes
Security Focus: A significant portion of recent activities involved addressing security vulnerabilities across various applications.
Collaboration: Shubham Waje frequently collaborates with other team members, indicating a central role in integrating changes.
Feature Enhancements: Continuous improvements are being made to both backend functionalities and frontend user interfaces.
Code Refactoring: There is ongoing effort in code refactoring for clarity, performance improvements, and maintaining best practices.
Testing and Stability: Emphasis on testing setups and ensuring stability through automated tests using Playwright.
Conclusions
The development team is actively engaged in improving security, enhancing features, and maintaining code quality across multiple applications within the project. Collaboration is evident among team members, particularly involving Shubham Waje as a key integrator of changes. The focus remains on both backend robustness and frontend user experience enhancements.
Summary
Quantified Reports
Detailed Reports
.png?size=50)
.png?size=50)
.png?size=50)
.png?size=50)