Quantify issues

Recent GitHub Issues Activity

_{Like all software activity quantification, these numbers are imperfect but sometimes useful. Comments, Labels, and Milestones refer to those issues opened in the timespan in question.}

Rate pull requests

PR#4419 - chore(deps): update dependency mypy to v1.13.0open

2_/5

renovate[bot]Created: 2024-10-23

The pull request is a simple dependency update from mypy 1.12.1 to 1.13.0, generated by a bot. It lacks any significant code changes or improvements beyond the version bump in the lock file. While keeping dependencies up-to-date is important, this PR does not introduce any notable enhancements or fixes to warrant a higher rating. The absence of automerge also suggests manual intervention is needed, which could have been streamlined.

[+] Read More

PR#4282 - feat: Support additional compression algorithmsopen

3_/5

Erik (HowRuck)Created: 2024-09-28

The pull request introduces support for additional compression algorithms, which is a useful feature for performance improvement. However, the performance gains are noted to be minor, and the addition of a new dependency may not be justified. The PR lacks thorough testing or benchmarks to demonstrate significant benefits, and the discussion suggests alternative approaches that might be more efficient. Overall, it's an average contribution with potential but not fully realized impact.

[+] Read More

PR#4295 - fix: user full name on recipe commentsopen

3_/5

Krit Kruaykitanon (OozyGrub)Created: 2024-10-01

This pull request addresses a minor bug by replacing the username with the full name in recipe comments, which is a straightforward change. It includes a small code modification and an additional test to ensure the full name is displayed correctly. While the change is necessary for user clarity, it is not particularly significant or complex. The PR lacks thorough documentation and could benefit from more extensive testing to cover edge cases. Overall, it's an average contribution that resolves a specific issue without introducing new features.

[+] Read More

PR#4378 - feat: Shopping list UI overhaul - collapsible labelsopen

3_/5

Cody (Wetzel402)Created: 2024-10-16

The pull request introduces a new feature to make labels in the shopping list collapsible, which is a useful enhancement. However, it lacks thorough documentation and testing details, which are crucial for ensuring stability and understanding the changes. The code changes are moderate in scope but include some unnecessary elements that were pointed out in the review comments. Overall, it's an average PR with room for improvement in clarity and completeness.

[+] Read More

PR#4415 - feat: Shopping list UI overhaul - three dot menuopen

3_/5

Cody (Wetzel402)Created: 2024-10-22

The pull request introduces a UI change by moving the shopping list action bar into a three-dot menu, which is a common design pattern for decluttering interfaces. The change is straightforward and maintains existing functionality while improving user experience. However, it lacks significant innovation or complexity, and there are no associated issue fixes or extensive testing details provided. As it is still in draft state, further refinements may be needed. Overall, it is an average PR with room for improvement.

[+] Read More

PR#4413 - fix(deps): update dependency fastapi to v0.115.3open

3_/5

renovate[bot]Created: 2024-10-22

This pull request updates the FastAPI dependency from version 0.115.2 to 0.115.3, which includes minor upgrades and documentation fixes. The change is straightforward, involving only a version bump in the lock file with no additional code changes or significant impact on the project. While necessary for keeping dependencies up-to-date, it lacks complexity or notable improvements that would warrant a higher rating. Therefore, it is considered average and unremarkable.

[+] Read More

PR#4421 - feat: vrslev/pre-commit-autoupdate archivedopen

3_/5

Brian Choromanski (Choromanski)Created: 2024-10-23

The pull request replaces a deprecated GitHub action with a direct implementation, which is necessary to avoid future issues with unsupported node versions. It includes the setup of Python and caching for efficiency. However, the change is relatively straightforward and does not introduce any significant new features or improvements beyond maintaining existing functionality. Testing has been performed, but the impact of the change is limited to internal development processes. Overall, it is a necessary update but not particularly remarkable or complex.

[+] Read More

PR#3781 - feat: Added support for _FILE pattern in Docker Compose secretsopen

4_/5

Andrew Vaughan (andrewvaughan)Created: 2024-06-23

This pull request introduces a useful feature by adding support for the `_FILE` pattern in Docker Compose secrets, enhancing security and flexibility. It is well-documented and maintains backward compatibility, which is crucial for existing users. The implementation is straightforward, modifying only the entrypoint script and documentation. However, it remains in draft status with some unresolved issues, such as potential permissions problems during testing. While significant and beneficial, these pending concerns prevent it from achieving an exemplary rating.

[+] Read More

PR#4252 - feat: Groups/households custom invitationsopen

4_/5

Arsène Reymond (p0lycarpio)Created: 2024-09-22

The pull request introduces a significant feature allowing admins to invite users to specific groups or households, enhancing functionality. The implementation includes both frontend and backend changes, with new components and API modifications. The code is well-structured, and the feature is tested with Pytests and manual testing. However, it lacks detailed documentation on potential impacts or edge cases, and the changes are not groundbreaking enough for a perfect score. Overall, it's a solid addition but could benefit from more comprehensive testing or user feedback consideration.

[+] Read More

PR#4329 - feat: Move alembic config into mealie package for easier distributionopen

4_/5

Michael Chisholm (chishm)Created: 2024-10-07

The pull request effectively consolidates Alembic configuration within the Mealie package, streamlining installation and usage by eliminating the need for additional configuration steps. This change enhances consistency and reduces setup complexity, which is beneficial for users. The PR is well-documented, and testing has been conducted to ensure functionality. However, the changes are primarily organizational and do not introduce new features or significant improvements beyond ease of distribution, which limits the impact of the PR. Overall, it is a solid improvement but lacks groundbreaking significance.

[+] Read More

Quantify commits

Quantified Commit Activity Over 14 Days

Developer	Avatar	Branches	PRs	Commits	Files	Changes
Hayden		1	13/12/1	12	88	58636
Michael Genson		1	8/11/0	11	84	3144
renovate[bot]		3	25/25/1	27	2	1525
Tom Brennan		1	0/1/0	1	16	336
Kuchenpirat		1	4/4/0	4	11	118
boc-the-git		1	2/2/0	2	6	79
Carter		1	1/1/0	1	4	54
Nicole Zeckner		1	1/1/0	1	1	36
github-actions[bot]		1	2/3/0	3	6	16
Aaron Echols		1	1/1/0	1	1	6
Dan Webb		1	1/1/0	1	1	4
besque		1	1/1/0	1	1	2
Cody (Wetzel402)		0	2/0/0	0	0	0
Andrey Blazejuk (ablazejuk)		0	1/0/1	0	0	0
Brian Choromanski (Choromanski)		0	2/0/1	0	0	0
Kaiwalya Koparkar (kaiwalyakoparkar)		0	1/0/1	0	0	0

_{PRs: created by that dev and opened/merged/closed-unmerged during the period}

Quantify risks

Project Risk Ratings

Report On: Fetch issues

Recent Activity Analysis

Recent GitHub issue activity for the Mealie project shows a mix of bug reports, feature requests, and discussions about enhancements. There is a focus on authentication issues, scraper functionality, and UI/UX improvements. Notably, several issues involve integration with third-party services like OpenAI and OIDC.

Notable Issues

• OIDC Integration (#4424): Users are experiencing login failures after updates, indicating potential configuration or documentation gaps.
• Scraper Challenges (#4024, #3593): Issues with scraping content from specific sites due to anti-bot measures highlight the need for robust scraping solutions.
• User Management (#3171): Problems arise when deleting users without reassigning their recipes, leading to data integrity issues.
• Localization Bugs (#4380): Translation inconsistencies suggest a need for improved handling of plural forms in different languages.

Themes and Commonalities

• Authentication and Authorization: Several issues relate to OIDC and user management, indicating ongoing challenges in these areas.
• Data Integrity: Problems with recipe imports and user deletions suggest a need for better data handling practices.
• Scraping Reliability: Frequent reports of scraping failures point to the complexity of maintaining compatibility with diverse recipe sources.

Issue Details

Recently Created Issues

1. #4424: Authentik OIDC not working after update to 2.0.0

   • Priority: High
   • Status: Open
   • Created: 0 days ago

2. #4407: Mealie Nightly Shortcuts Broken

   • Priority: Medium
   • Status: Open
   • Created: 2 days ago
   • Updated: 0 days ago

3. #4404: Generating recipe from image failing using Ollama

   • Priority: Medium
   • Status: Open
   • Created: 2 days ago

Recently Updated Issues

1. #4424: Authentik OIDC not working after update to 2.0.0

   • Updated: 0 days ago

2. #4407: Mealie Nightly Shortcuts Broken

   • Updated: 0 days ago

3. #4401: 500 error on PUT method for updating Recipe

   • Updated: 3 days ago

These issues reflect ongoing efforts to address critical bugs and enhance the user experience across various functionalities of the Mealie project.

Report On: Fetch pull requests

Analysis of Pull Requests for Mealie

Open Pull Requests

Notable Open PRs

• #4421: feat: vrslev/pre-commit-autoupdate archived

  • Issue: Replaces a deprecated GitHub action with a direct source. This is crucial to prevent future compatibility issues.
  • Testing: Successfully tested with multiple checks.
  • Action Needed: Ensure thorough review to confirm stability.

• #4419: chore(deps): update dependency mypy to v1.13.0

  • Issue: Dependency update for mypy. Automerge is disabled, requiring manual intervention.
  • Action Needed: Review and merge if tests pass.

• #4415: feat: Shopping list UI overhaul - three dot menu

  • Issue: UI/UX improvement for shopping list actions.
  • Status: Draft, needs completion and testing.
  • Action Needed: Await further development and testing.

• #4295: fix: user full name on recipe comments

  • Issue: Bug fix to display full names in comments.
  • Action Needed: Review requested changes and ensure test coverage.

Concerns with Open PRs

• #3781: feat: Added support for _FILE pattern in Docker Compose secrets
  • Issue: Stale with no recent activity, potential permissions issue noted.
  • Action Needed: Requires attention to resolve outstanding issues or close if not feasible.

Recently Closed PRs

Notable Closed PRs

• #4422: chore(l10n): New Crowdin updates

  • Significance: Merged quickly, indicating efficient localization updates.

• #4418 & #4417 (Dependency Updates)

  • Significance: Regular maintenance of dependencies like openai and orjson, ensuring up-to-date security and functionality.

• #4414: feat: Group and household deletion tooltips

  • Significance: Enhances user understanding of UI elements, improving user experience.

Closed Without Merge

• #4420: Removed some stuff to see where the error is
  • Issue: Experimental PR closed without merging, likely used for debugging purposes.
  • Action Needed: Ensure any findings are documented or integrated into other solutions.

General Observations

• The project maintains an active development cycle with regular updates and improvements.
• There is a strong focus on dependency management, ensuring the project remains secure and functional.
• Some PRs are left stale, indicating potential bottlenecks in review or decision-making processes.

Recommendations

1. Prioritize resolving stale PRs like #3781 to avoid prolonged inactivity.
2. Encourage contributors to provide detailed testing information to streamline the review process.
3. Consider automating more dependency updates where feasible to reduce manual workload.

Overall, the Mealie project shows robust activity with a focus on continuous improvement and community engagement.

Report On: Fetch Files For Assessment

Source Code Assessment

1. Alembic Migration File: add_summary_to_recipe_instructions.py

Structure and Quality:

• Purpose: This migration script adds a summary column to the recipe_instructions table.
• Imports: Uses sqlalchemy and alembic for database operations, which are standard for migrations.
• Revision Details: Clearly defines revision, down_revision, and other metadata.
• Upgrade/Downgrade Functions:
  • The upgrade() function adds a nullable summary column.
  • The downgrade() function removes the summary column.
• Comments: Auto-generated comments by Alembic are present, but no additional comments are provided.
• Type Hints: Utilizes Python type hints effectively.

Analysis:

• The file is concise and adheres to typical Alembic migration patterns.
• It lacks custom comments or documentation, which could help in understanding the context of changes.

2. Vue Component: RecipePageInstructions.vue

Structure and Quality:

• Template Section:

  • Contains a well-organized structure with dialogs, draggable components, and transitions.
  • Uses Vuetify components extensively for UI elements.
  • Implements the new summary feature in recipe steps.

• Script Section:

  • Written in TypeScript, enhancing type safety.
  • Uses Vue Composition API for state management and lifecycle hooks.
  • Contains complex logic for handling recipe instructions, including ingredient linking and step management.
  • Includes functions for drag-and-drop operations, ingredient linking, and UI state toggling.

• Style Section:

  • Scoped CSS ensures styles are component-specific.
  • Contains utility classes for UI effects like transitions and overlays.

Analysis:

• The component is large (765 lines), suggesting potential for refactoring into smaller sub-components for maintainability.
• Logic is complex but appears well-organized with clear separation of concerns between UI rendering and data manipulation.

3. Database Model: instruction.py

Structure and Quality:

• Classes Defined:

  • RecipeIngredientRefLink: Manages ingredient references linked to instructions.
  • RecipeInstruction: Represents recipe instructions with attributes like id, recipe_id, position, etc., including the new summary field.

• ORM Mapping: Uses SQLAlchemy ORM features like relationships and mapped columns effectively.

• Initialization: Uses an auto_init decorator for constructor initialization, which simplifies object creation.

Analysis:

• The model is well-defined with appropriate use of SQLAlchemy features.
• The addition of the summary field aligns with the migration changes, ensuring consistency across the database layer.

4. Schema File: recipe_step.py

Structure and Quality:

• Classes Defined:

  • IngredientReferences: Represents a list of ingredient references using Pydantic models.
  • RecipeStep: Defines a recipe step schema with fields like id, title, summary, etc.

• Pydantic Usage: Utilizes Pydantic's data validation and serialization capabilities effectively.

Analysis:

• The schema reflects changes made in other parts of the application by incorporating the new summary field.
• The use of Pydantic ensures data integrity and validation at the schema level.

5. Localization File: en-US.json

Structure and Quality:

• Content: Contains key-value pairs for UI text strings, including new entries related to tooltips and summaries.
• Organization: Follows a hierarchical structure for categorizing messages (e.g., "recipe", "general").

Analysis:

• The file is extensive (1366 lines), indicating comprehensive localization support.
• New entries related to the summary feature are integrated seamlessly into existing structures.

Overall, the codebase demonstrates good practices in terms of structure, use of modern frameworks/libraries (Vue.js, SQLAlchemy, Pydantic), and adherence to project conventions. However, there is room for improvement in terms of documentation within migration scripts and potential refactoring of large Vue components for better maintainability.

Report On: Fetch commits

Development Team and Recent Activity

Team Members and Activities

boc-the-git

• Commits: 2
• Changes: 79 across 6 files
• Collaborations: Co-authored with Kuchenpirat
• Recent Work: Added summary to recipe instructions, release template updates.

hay-kot

• Commits: 12
• Changes: 58,636 across 88 files
• Recent Work: Primarily focused on localization updates via Crowdin.

renovate[bot]

• Commits: 27
• Changes: 1,525 across 2 files
• Recent Work: Dependency updates for various libraries including OpenAI, orjson, and rich.

Kuchenpirat

• Commits: 4
• Changes: 118 across 11 files
• Collaborations: Co-authored with boc-the-git and others.
• Recent Work: Group and household deletion tooltips, internal dev section in release notes.

damacus

• Commits: 1
• Changes: 4 across 1 file
• Recent Work: Fixed a minor typo in documentation.

github-actions[bot]

• Commits: 3
• Changes: 16 across 6 files
• Recent Work: Automated updates for pre-commit hooks and image tags.

michael-genson

• Commits: 11
• Changes: 3,144 across 84 files
• Collaborations: Co-authored with Kuchenpirat and others.
• Recent Work: Features like query filter builder, bug fixes related to meal plans and user data handling.

besque

• Commits: 1
• Changes: 2 across 1 file
• Recent Work: Documentation update for backend configuration.

cmintey

• Commits: 1
• Changes: 54 across 4 files
• Recent Work: Prevent login via credentials when Auth Method is Mealie.

tjb1982

• Commits: 1
• Changes: 336 across 16 files
• Recent Work: Added nutrition properties from schema.org.

dasunsrule32

• Commits: 1
• Changes: 6 across 1 file
• Recent Work: Updated OIDC documentation.

PurelyNicole

• Commits: 1
• Changes: 36 across 1 file
• Recent Work: Updated REST call documentation for Home Assistant.

Patterns and Themes

1. Localization Efforts: Significant activity around localization updates led by hay-kot, indicating a focus on expanding language support.

2. Dependency Management: Frequent updates by renovate[bot] show an emphasis on maintaining up-to-date dependencies.

3. Feature Enhancements: New features such as query filter builder and recipe instruction summaries have been added, primarily by Michael Genson and boc-the-git.

4. Bug Fixes: Various bug fixes related to meal plans, user data handling, and recipe scaling are evident, showcasing ongoing maintenance efforts.

5. Documentation Updates: Continuous improvements in documentation by contributors like damacus and PurelyNicole indicate a focus on clarity and user guidance.