Quantify issues

Recent GitHub Issues Activity

_{Like all software activity quantification, these numbers are imperfect but sometimes useful. Comments, Labels, and Milestones refer to those issues opened in the timespan in question.}

Rate pull requests

PR#703 - fix raft datasetopen

2_/5

Kai Wu (wukaixingxp)Created: 2024-10-03

The pull request addresses a minor bug fix by adjusting an index in a single line of code. While it resolves a specific issue related to token masking, the change is trivial and lacks comprehensive testing or documentation updates. The PR is still in draft status, and there's no detailed description or context provided, which diminishes its overall quality and significance.

[+] Read More

PR#731 - Zero-to-Llama-Courseopen

2_/5

Sanyam Bhutani (init27)Created: 2024-10-16

The pull request is a draft and currently lacks substantive content, with only the folder structure and empty README files added. While it outlines an ambitious course structure, the absence of actual content or code makes it incomplete and not yet valuable to the project. This PR needs significant work to be considered useful or impactful.

[+] Read More

PR#751 - Add files via uploadopen

2_/5

withloginCreated: 2024-10-28

The pull request adds a single PDF file with no explanation or context provided. It lacks any code changes, documentation updates, or significant contributions to the project. Furthermore, the contributor has not signed the required Contributor License Agreement, which is essential for the review process. This PR is incomplete and lacks significance, warranting a rating of 2.

[+] Read More

PR#698 - Multi modal rag demoopen

3_/5

Sanyam Bhutani (init27)Created: 2024-10-01

The pull request demonstrates a moderately significant change with a clear structure, including notebooks and scripts for a multi-modal RAG demo. However, it is still a work in progress, with some parts marked as WIP. The PR includes a substantial amount of code and documentation changes, but the presence of numerous spelling fixes and minor updates suggests it may lack thoroughness in initial submissions. It shows promise but requires further refinement to reach completion.

[+] Read More

PR#723 - Llama 3.2open

3_/5

mylesgooseCreated: 2024-10-11

The pull request introduces a new checkpoint converter for vision models, which is a functional addition to the project. The code appears to be well-organized and includes error handling for missing files. However, the PR lacks thorough documentation and testing, as indicated by the incomplete test section and unchecked documentation update. The change is moderately significant but not exemplary, as it misses comprehensive validation and context explanation.

[+] Read More

PR#706 - Adds Llama 3.2 example on Modal with a fun experimentopen

4_/5

Erik Dunteman (erik-dunteman)Created: 2024-10-04

This PR introduces a significant and well-documented feature by adding a comprehensive example of using Llama 3.2 on the Modal platform. The PR includes multiple new scripts, a detailed README, and an end-to-end script for running experiments. It is technically thorough and integrates well with existing tools. However, it lacks new tests and could benefit from more community discussion or approval before merging.

[+] Read More

PR#708 - add support for llama vision model conversionopen

4_/5

Lai Wei (roywei)Created: 2024-10-06

The pull request introduces a significant feature by adding support for converting the finetuned Llama 3.2 vision model to HF format, enabling multimodal inference. The changes are well-documented, and the functionality has been tested successfully, addressing conversion errors between configurations. However, it lacks new tests and a discussion or approval via a GitHub issue. Overall, it's a quite good addition but could be improved with more thorough testing and community engagement.

[+] Read More

PR#718 - Added a Gradio UI for multi-modal inferencing using Llama 3.2 Vision/open

4_/5

Himanshu Shukla (himanshushukla12)Created: 2024-10-08

This PR introduces a significant feature by adding a Gradio UI for multi-modal inference with Llama 3.2 Vision models, enhancing user interaction through a chatbox interface. It integrates important libraries like transformers and accelerate, implements GPU memory management, and supports Hugging Face tokens for model access. The author has been responsive to feedback, making requested changes promptly. However, the PR could be more exemplary with additional testing or documentation improvements. Overall, it's a well-executed and valuable contribution.

[+] Read More

PR#742 - add llama3 support for alpaca datasetopen

4_/5

Kai Wu (wukaixingxp)Created: 2024-10-22

This PR introduces significant functionality by adding support for llama3 in the alpaca dataset, enabling finetuning, model conversion, and inference. The changes are well-documented and include comprehensive testing instructions. The code modifications are substantial, with a clear focus on ensuring compatibility with different tokenizer vocab sizes. However, there are multiple warnings related to deprecated functions and parallelism issues that need addressing. Overall, it's a valuable contribution but not without minor flaws.

[+] Read More

PR#750 - add support for ingesting content from websites, audio files, YouTube, etc.open

4_/5

Evan Cosgrove (evanjcosgrove)Created: 2024-10-28

The pull request introduces significant enhancements by adding support for multiple input formats, improving documentation, and updating dependencies. The new ingestion module is well-structured with clear classes for different input types, and the documentation includes detailed usage examples. Dependency updates are necessary and well-documented. However, while the changes are quite good and improve the project's functionality, they are not groundbreaking or exceptionally innovative. The PR lacks a bit in terms of testing coverage and handling edge cases, which prevents it from being rated as excellent.

[+] Read More

Quantify commits

Quantified Commit Activity Over 14 Days

Developer	Avatar	Branches	PRs	Commits	Files	Changes
Sanyam Bhutani		3	5/5/0	89	68	23913
Kai Wu		2	4/3/0	8	11	535
Matthias Reso		1	1/1/0	11	9	438
terrchen		1	1/1/0	1	1	4
celestinoalan		1	1/2/0	2	1	4
Patrik Lambert		1	1/1/0	1	1	2
Ethan		1	0/0/0	1	1	1
Ethan Petersen (ethxnp)		0	0/1/0	0	0	0
None (withlogin)		0	1/0/0	0	0	0
Suhong Moon (SuhongMoon)		0	1/0/1	0	0	0
None (beautiful85)		0	1/0/1	0	0	0
Evan Cosgrove (evanjcosgrove)		0	1/0/0	0	0	0
Hamid Shojanazeri		0	0/0/0	0	0	0

_{PRs: created by that dev and opened/merged/closed-unmerged during the period}

Quantify risks

Project Risk Ratings

Report On: Fetch issues

GitHub Issues Analysis

Recent Activity Analysis

Recent activity in the llama-recipes repository shows a diverse range of issues, from installation problems to fine-tuning challenges. The repository is highly active, with issues being opened and closed frequently. Notably, there are recurring themes around fine-tuning configurations, model compatibility, and deployment challenges.

Anomalies and Themes

1. Installation and Compatibility: Several issues (#674, #508) highlight difficulties with installation and package compatibility, particularly with dependencies like peft and bitsandbytes. Users report errors related to version mismatches and missing modules.

2. Fine-Tuning Challenges: Many users face problems with fine-tuning Llama models (#556, #414). Common issues include CUDA out-of-memory errors and configuration difficulties when using FSDP or PEFT methods.

3. Inference and Model Loading: Issues such as #380 and #381 indicate problems with model loading and inference, often related to token limits or unexpected behavior during generation.

4. Documentation Gaps: Some users express confusion about certain features or configurations, suggesting a need for clearer documentation or examples (#242, #310).

5. Performance Optimization: There are requests for enhancements like Flash Attention 2 support (#248) and better VRAM management during training (#276).

6. Multimodal Support: The integration of multimodal capabilities is a notable feature, but users have questions about its implementation and performance (#242).

Issue Details

Most Recently Created Issues

• #752: Not able to save trained model - Created 0 days ago. This issue highlights a problem with saving models after fine-tuning without error logs.
• #749: Project license? - Created 0 days ago. A user points out the absence of a LICENSE file, which could restrict legal use.
• #747: Project summary should say what it does - Created 1 day ago. A request for clearer project documentation.

Most Recently Updated Issues

• #740: Found two forward recomputation exist in a single backward when using FSDP with activation checkpointing - Updated 7 days ago. This technical issue affects training throughput.
• #738: Learning rate scheduler - Updated 10 days ago. A feature request for learning rate scheduling options during fine-tuning.
• #735: llama3.2 fine tuning generates repeated pattern towards the end of one epoch - Updated 3 days ago. Users report repetitive output patterns during fine-tuning.

Important Issues

• #648: The EOS and BOS token setting when continue pretraining Llama3.1 - Discusses tokenization settings crucial for pretraining tasks.
• #634: FSDP finetuned model inference question - Addresses challenges in using FSDP checkpoints for inference.
• #633: Clarification on Evaluation Results for Llama Guard 3 - Highlights discrepancies in evaluation results compared to official reports.

Overall, the issues reflect active engagement from the community in improving the usability and functionality of the llama-recipes repository. The team appears responsive to feedback, addressing bugs, enhancing features, and clarifying documentation as needed.

Report On: Fetch pull requests

Analysis of Pull Requests

Open Pull Requests

1. #751: Add files via upload

   • State: Open
   • Created: 0 days ago
   • Issues:
   • The PR includes a PDF file with no clear context or relevance to the project.
   • The contributor has not signed the Contributor License Agreement (CLA), blocking further review.
   • No code changes or documentation updates are associated with this PR.

2. #750: Add support for ingesting content from websites, audio files, YouTube, etc.

   • State: Open
   • Created: 0 days ago
   • Key Features:
   • Introduces a new ingestion module supporting multiple input formats.
   • Updates documentation and dependencies.
   • Issues:
   • The CLA is unsigned, preventing review.
   • Significant enhancements are proposed, but pending CLA signature for review.

3. #742: Add llama3 support for alpaca dataset

   • State: Open
   • Created: 7 days ago
   • Key Features:
   • Adds support for llama3 with the alpaca dataset.
   • Issues:
   • Deprecation warnings in logs need addressing.
   • Labeled as "cla signed," but no reviewers assigned.

4. #731: Zero-to-Llama-Course

   • State: Open (Draft)
   • Created: 12 days ago
   • Key Features:
   • A series of notebooks for learning about the Llama model family.
   • Issues:
   • The draft status indicates it’s not ready for full review yet.

5. #718: Added a Gradio UI for multi-modal inferencing using Llama 3.2 Vision

   • State: Open
   • Created: 20 days ago
   • Key Features:
   • Implements a Gradio UI for multi-modal inference.
   • Issues:
   • Pending final checks and CI/CD validation.

6. #708: Add support for llama vision model conversion

   • State: Open
   • Created: 22 days ago
   • Key Features:
   • Updates scripts to support conversion of finetuned models to HF format.
   • Issues:
   • Awaiting tests and validation from reviewers.

Recently Closed Pull Requests

1. #748: Fix minor grammatical errors

   • Merged Quickly
   • Focused on minor documentation fixes, indicating active maintenance of documentation quality.

2. #746 & #745: Small notes and wordlist updates

   • Addressed minor improvements and updates to internal documentation and wordlist configurations.

3. #744: Append epoch rather than best val. loss to val_loss

   • Adjusted logic to append epoch loss instead of best validation loss, enhancing accuracy in tracking training progress.

4. #741 & #739: Support converting fine-tuned models and E2E workflows

   • Introduced significant enhancements in model conversion and end-to-end workflows, indicating ongoing feature development.

Notable Observations

• Many open PRs are blocked due to unsigned CLAs, which is a critical bottleneck.
• There is active development around enhancing model capabilities and integration with external tools (e.g., Gradio).
• Documentation improvements are consistently addressed, reflecting attention to usability and clarity.
• Recent merges focus on both minor fixes and substantial feature additions, showing a balanced approach to project maintenance and innovation.

Overall, the repository is actively maintained with a focus on expanding functionality while ensuring quality through detailed documentation and prompt issue resolution.

Report On: Fetch Files For Assessment

Source Code Assessment

1. recipes/quickstart/NotebookLlama/Step-1 PDF-Pre-Processing-Logic.ipynb

Structure and Quality

• Purpose: This Jupyter Notebook is designed for pre-processing PDFs to extract text, which can then be used for further processing, such as converting into a podcast script.
• Code Organization: The notebook is well-organized with clear markdown explanations and code cells. It follows a logical flow from library installation to text extraction.
• Functionality:
  • Uses PyPDF2 for PDF text extraction.
  • Validates file existence and type.
  • Extracts text with a character limit and provides metadata.
  • Implements chunking of text for processing with LLMs.
• Error Handling: Includes basic error handling for file operations and PDF reading errors.
• Documentation: Adequate markdown cells explain the steps and purpose of each section.

Improvements

• Code Efficiency: Consider optimizing the text extraction loop to handle large PDFs more efficiently.
• Error Handling: Enhance error handling to cover more edge cases, such as handling non-readable pages in PDFs.
• Modularity: Functions could be further modularized for reusability in other notebooks or scripts.

2. src/llama_recipes/utils/train_utils.py

Structure and Quality

• Purpose: Provides utility functions for training models, including setup, training loops, evaluation, and checkpointing.
• Code Organization: The file is structured into logical sections with functions handling specific tasks like training, evaluation, and environment setup.
• Functionality:
  • Supports mixed precision training and FSDP (Fully Sharded Data Parallel) configurations.
  • Implements detailed profiling and flop counting.
  • Includes comprehensive logging and metric tracking capabilities.
• Error Handling: Uses exceptions to handle configuration errors effectively.

Improvements

• Complexity Reduction: Some functions, like train, are lengthy. Consider refactoring into smaller helper functions to improve readability and maintainability.
• Comments and Documentation: Increase inline comments for complex logic sections to aid understanding.

3. src/llama_recipes/inference/checkpoint_converter_fsdp_hf.py

Structure and Quality

• Purpose: Converts FSDP sharded checkpoints to Hugging Face format for inference.
• Code Organization: Concise script with a clear main function that handles the conversion process.
• Functionality:
  • Loads model configuration from YAML files.
  • Converts model checkpoints using Hugging Face utilities.
  • Handles tokenizer saving based on model type (mllama vs llama).

Improvements

• Error Handling: Improve exception handling to provide more informative error messages during file operations or model loading failures.
• Code Comments: Add comments explaining key steps in the conversion process for clarity.

4. recipes/quickstart/inference/local_inference/multi_modal_infer.py

Structure and Quality

• Purpose: Facilitates multimodal inference using Llama models by generating text from images.
• Code Organization: Well-organized with distinct functions for loading models, processing images, and generating text.
• Functionality:
  • Utilizes MllamaForConditionalGeneration for image-to-text generation.
  • Handles image processing using PIL and model inference using Transformers library.

Improvements

• Input Validation: Enhance input validation for image paths and prompt texts to prevent runtime errors.
• Logging: Implement logging instead of print statements for better control over output verbosity.

5. src/llama_recipes/datasets/alpaca_dataset.py

Structure and Quality

• Purpose: Defines a dataset class for handling Alpaca dataset with tokenization support.
• Code Organization: Compact class-based implementation following PyTorch Dataset conventions.
• Functionality:
  • Splits dataset into training and evaluation partitions.
  • Encodes data using a tokenizer with appropriate attention masks.

Improvements

• Data Handling: Ensure robust handling of JSON loading errors or missing fields in dataset entries.
• Flexibility: Allow dynamic adjustment of evaluation split percentage through configuration.

Overall, the codebase demonstrates good practices in structuring machine learning workflows but could benefit from enhanced modularity, error handling, and documentation in certain areas.

Report On: Fetch commits

Repo Commits Analysis

Development Team and Recent Activity

Team Members and Activities

Sanyam Bhutani (init27)

• Commits: 89
• Recent Work:
  • Extensive updates to NotebookLlama including README, various notebooks, and resources.
  • Added new scripts and notebooks for Multi-Modal-RAG and zero-to-llama-course.
  • Collaborated with Hamid Shojanazeri on README updates.
  • Addressed PR comments and made numerous small fixes across the repository.

Kai Wu (wukaixingxp)

• Commits: 8
• Recent Work:
  • Added llama3 support for alpaca dataset.
  • Fixed wordlists and deadlinks.
  • Worked on fine-tuning scripts and inference modules.

Matthias Reso (mreso)

• Commits: 11
• Recent Work:
  • Made changes related to testing utilities and configurations.
  • Worked on improving test coverage and fixing issues with datasets.

Terrchen

• Commits: 1
• Recent Work:
  • Fixed minor grammatical errors in documentation.

Celestino Alan

• Commits: 2
• Recent Work:
  • Made adjustments to training utilities, specifically around loss calculations.

Patrik Lambert

• Commits: 1
• Recent Work:
  • Fixed numpy seed in finetuning to ensure consistent train/test splits.

Patterns, Themes, and Conclusions

• High Activity by Sanyam Bhutani: Dominant contributor with significant work on NotebookLlama and other branches. Frequent updates suggest ongoing development of new features or enhancements.

• Collaboration Evident: Co-authored commits indicate collaboration, particularly between Sanyam Bhutani and Hamid Shojanazeri.

• Focus on Documentation and Testing: Multiple contributors focused on updating documentation, fixing grammatical errors, and enhancing test coverage.

• Diverse Contributions: Team members are working across various aspects of the project, from dataset support to inference improvements, indicating a broad scope of development activities.

• Ongoing Development: Several branches show recent activity, suggesting ongoing feature development or experimentation.

Overall, the team is actively maintaining and expanding the project with a strong focus on improving usability through documentation and testing.