Quantify issues

Recent GitHub Issues Activity

_{Like all software activity quantification, these numbers are imperfect but sometimes useful. Comments, Labels, and Milestones refer to those issues opened in the timespan in question.}

Rate pull requests

PR#162 - Fix cpu option in exampleopen

2_/5

Marco Boneberger (marcbone)Created: 2024-12-20

The pull request addresses a specific issue by adding a conditional backend initialization for CPU usage in the simulator example. While this change is necessary for users who need to run the simulation on a CPU, it is a minor modification affecting only one line of code. The PR lacks broader significance or complexity, and does not introduce new features or fix critical bugs. Its impact is limited to a specific use case, making it relatively insignificant in the context of the overall project.

[+] Read More

PR#92 - [BUG FIX] ext/pyrender/viewer: resolve macOS crashes when initialising Tk()open

3_/5

Neko Asakura (NekoAsakura)Created: 2024-12-19

This pull request addresses a specific bug related to macOS crashes when initializing Tk in the Genesis project. The changes are concise, removing unnecessary compatibility code for Python 2 and simplifying the Tkinter import process. However, the PR is relatively small in scope, affecting only a few lines of code and primarily focusing on cleanup and minor adjustments. While it resolves an issue, the impact is limited to a specific platform and does not introduce significant new functionality or improvements. Thus, it merits an average rating.

[+] Read More

PR#83 - Add support for Viewer and headless rendering on windowsopen

3_/5

Dear.Va (DearVa)Created: 2024-12-19

The pull request introduces support for Viewer and headless rendering on Windows, addressing issue #12. It includes platform-specific code for initializing OpenGL on Windows and modifies error handling related to the viewer and camera functionalities. However, the PR is marked as an initial fix, indicating that further testing is needed. Additionally, there are unresolved issues and errors reported by reviewers, such as a numba type error and blocking threads. The changes are significant but not thoroughly tested or free from issues, warranting an average rating.

[+] Read More

PR#54 - Remove torch import, keep viewer open in render_on_macos.pyopen

3_/5

Dominik Weckmüller (do-me)Created: 2024-12-19

The pull request removes an unnecessary import of 'torch' and comments out code that stops the viewer, aligning with user expectations to keep it open. While these changes are sensible and improve usability, they are minor and lack significant impact or complexity. The PR does not introduce new functionality or fix critical issues, hence it is average but unremarkable.

[+] Read More

PR#163 - fix ray-tracing for conda site-package, find the right pathopen

3_/5

YamakenElf (KafuuChikai)Created: 2024-12-20

The pull request addresses a specific issue with path resolution for LuisaRenderPy in a conda environment by allowing the path to be set via an environment variable. This is a practical solution that enhances flexibility. However, it lacks documentation updates as requested, which is crucial for user guidance. The change is functional but not significant or exemplary, hence an average rating.

[+] Read More

PR#141 - Add badges and update Chinese READMEopen

3_/5

00makeCreated: 2024-12-20

This pull request enhances the README by adding visually appealing badges and introduces a Chinese version of the README, which improves accessibility for Chinese-speaking users. While these changes are beneficial for documentation and internationalization, they are not technically complex or critical to the core functionality of the project. The addition of badges is a minor visual improvement, and while the Chinese README is a significant addition for accessibility, it does not impact the codebase or technical aspects of the project. Therefore, this PR is average in terms of significance and complexity.

[+] Read More

PR#41 - mpm_grid_op kernel optimization - coupler.pyopen

4_/5

Arda Buckun (ardabck)Created: 2024-12-19

The pull request demonstrates a significant improvement in the performance and readability of the `mpm_grid_op` kernel by precomputing frequently used variables and utilizing `ti.static` for compiler optimizations. These changes enhance the coupling efficiency between different solvers, which is a meaningful contribution to the codebase. However, while the improvements are noteworthy, they may not be groundbreaking enough to warrant an exemplary rating. The changes are well-executed but represent a moderate optimization rather than a major overhaul.

[+] Read More

PR#135 - add apply_external_force/torqueopen

4_/5

Ziyan Xiong (ziyanx02)Created: 2024-12-20

The pull request introduces a significant new feature by adding functions to apply external force and torque in the RigidSolver, along with an example script demonstrating its usage. The code is well-structured and integrates seamlessly into the existing framework, enhancing the solver's capabilities. However, while it is a valuable addition, it lacks extensive documentation or comments that could aid in understanding the implementation details for future developers. Thus, it is rated as quite good but not exemplary due to this minor shortcoming.

[+] Read More

Quantify commits

Quantified Commit Activity Over 14 Days

Developer	Avatar	Branches	PRs	Commits	Files	Changes
Zhou Xian		1	0/0/0	4	302	3553499
Pingchuan Ma		1	1/1/0	1	9	727
YilingQiao		1	2/2/0	7	19	259
Ziyan Xiong		1	3/1/1	2	3	168
Sang Min Kim		1	1/1/0	1	1	6
Zhaojing Yang		1	1/1/0	1	1	5
Genesis-Embodied-AI		1	0/0/0	2	1	5
Rob Royce		1	1/1/0	1	1	4
Zhenjia Xu		1	1/1/0	1	1	3
Abhay Deshpande		1	1/1/0	1	1	2
Ikko Eltociear Ashimine		1	1/1/0	1	1	2
Yin Jie		1	1/1/0	1	1	2
CharlesCNorton		1	1/1/0	1	1	2
Dominik Weckmüller (do-me)		0	1/0/0	0	0	0
00make (00make)		0	1/0/0	0	0	0
Dear.Va (DearVa)		0	1/0/0	0	0	0
Arda Buckun (ardabck)		0	1/0/0	0	0	0
Marco Boneberger (marcbone)		0	1/0/0	0	0	0
Johnson, Tsun Hsuan, Wang		0	0/0/0	0	0	0
Isaac (IsaacGemal)		0	1/0/1	0	0	0
YamakenElf (KafuuChikai)		0	1/0/0	0	0	0
Neko Asakura (NekoAsakura)		0	1/0/0	0	0	0

_{PRs: created by that dev and opened/merged/closed-unmerged during the period}

Quantify risks

Project Risk Ratings

Report On: Fetch issues

Recent Activity Analysis

Recent GitHub issue activity for the Genesis project has been notably high, with a significant influx of issues created in the last few days. The issues cover a wide range of topics, including installation problems, compatibility issues across different platforms, feature requests, and bug reports. This level of activity indicates a high level of engagement from the community, reflecting both interest in the project and challenges users face.

Several issues stand out due to their complexity or frequency. Notably, there are multiple reports of errors related to OpenGL and GLFW conflicts, particularly on macOS with Apple Silicon (#165, #90). These issues suggest a recurring problem with graphics compatibility on this platform. Additionally, there are several instances of users encountering AttributeError: function 'glGetUniformLocation' not found (#143, #99), indicating a potential gap in the library's support for certain OpenGL functions on Windows systems.

Another common theme is installation difficulties, especially related to dependencies like trimesh and pymeshlab, which are causing problems across different operating systems (#26, #52). Users have also reported issues with running examples on headless systems or within Docker containers, highlighting the need for better support or documentation for these environments (#33, #119).

The presence of multiple feature requests and questions about future capabilities (e.g., support for molecular dynamics or ROS integration) indicates a strong interest in expanding Genesis's functionality. However, some users have expressed confusion over missing features that were advertised but not yet available, such as the generative data engine (#30).

Issue Details

Most Recently Created Issues

1. #166: Feature request: please add an example working in Google Colab

   • Priority: High (due to user demand for accessible examples)
   • Status: Open
   • Created: 0 days ago

2. #165: OpenGL/GLFW Conflict Between Taichi and PyGEL3D on macOS (Apple Silicon)

   • Priority: High (affects usability on a popular platform)
   • Status: Open
   • Created: 0 days ago

3. #164: Issues Importing Custom Robot Model from SolidWorks into Genesis

   • Priority: Medium
   • Status: Open
   • Created: 0 days ago

4. #161: Cloth simulation

   • Priority: Medium
   • Status: Open
   • Created: 0 days ago

5. #159: Trimesh Error Report

   • Priority: High (common dependency issue)
   • Status: Open
   • Created: 0 days ago

Most Recently Updated Issues

1. #145: [Bug] run hello_genesis.py meet visualizer crash

   • Priority: High (critical bug affecting basic functionality)
   • Status: Closed
   • Updated: 0 days ago

2. #121: This project cannot run Fluid Simulations on mac, heres why, fix perhaps? :

   • Priority: High (platform-specific limitation)
   • Status: Closed
   • Updated: 1 day ago

3. #119: display not detected in docker container

   • Priority: Medium
   • Status: Closed
   • Updated: 1 day ago

4. #113: AttributeError: module 'genesis' has no attribute 'init'

   • Priority: Low (installation/configuration issue)
   • Status: Closed
   • Updated: 1 day ago

5. #107: Request to add official implementation of domain randomization for RL

   • Priority: Medium
   • Status: Closed
   • Updated: 1 day ago

Report On: Fetch pull requests

Analysis of Pull Requests for Genesis-Embodied-AI/Genesis

Open Pull Requests

#163: Fix Ray-Tracing for Conda Site-Package

• Issue: Incorrect path when installing Genesis in a conda environment.
• Solution: Introduce an environment variable LRP_PATH to specify the correct path.
• Notable: This PR is crucial for users working in conda environments, ensuring proper functionality of ray-tracing features.

#162: Fix CPU Option in Example

• Issue: The --cpu argument was not properly setting the simulator to use the CPU.
• Solution: Adjusted initialization in cloth_on_rigid.py to respect the --cpu argument.
• Notable: Important for users who need to run simulations on CPU instead of GPU.

#141: Add Badges and Update Chinese README

• Enhancement: Adds visual badges and updates the Chinese README for better accessibility.
• Notable: Improves documentation and user engagement, especially for Chinese-speaking users.

#135: Add Apply External Force/Torque

• Feature Addition: Introduces methods to apply external force and torque in RigidSolver.
• Notable: Enhances simulation capabilities by allowing dynamic interaction with rigid bodies.

#92: [BUG FIX] Resolve macOS Crashes with Tk()

• Issue: Crashes on macOS when initializing Tk().
• Solution: Ensures compatibility with Tkinter by adjusting initialization sequence.
• Notable: Critical fix for macOS users experiencing crashes, improving platform stability.

#83: Add Support for Viewer and Headless Rendering on Windows

• Enhancement: Initial support for viewer and headless rendering on Windows.
• Challenges: Encountered issues with numba type errors and thread blocking.
• Notable: Important step towards cross-platform compatibility, but requires further testing and bug fixes.

#54: Remove Torch Import, Keep Viewer Open in Render_on_macos.py

• Improvement: Removes unnecessary torch import and suggests keeping the viewer open by default.
• Notable: Simplifies code and improves user experience by keeping the viewer active.

#41: MPM Grid Op Kernel Optimization - Coupler.py

• Optimization: Enhances performance by precomputing variables and using ti.static.
• Notable: Improves efficiency and readability of the kernel, beneficial for performance-critical applications.

Closed Pull Requests

#130: Add Pre-Commit Hook for Black

• Merged: Introduces a pre-commit hook to enforce code formatting with Black.
• Significance: Ensures consistent code style across contributions, improving maintainability.

#126: Apply External Force and Torque

• Closed Without Merge: Similar functionality appears in open PR #135, possibly leading to closure without merge.

#95 & #59 & #19 & #29 & #27 & #25 & #1:

• Various documentation updates, typo fixes, and minor enhancements merged successfully. These improve clarity and correctness of project documentation.

Notable Issues

1. Closed Without Merge (#126):

   • The PR was closed without being merged, possibly due to overlapping functionality with another open PR (#135).

2. Cross-platform Challenges (#83):

   • The PR aimed at enhancing Windows support faces technical challenges that need resolution before full functionality can be achieved.

3. Critical Bug Fixes (#92):

   • Resolving macOS crashes is crucial for maintaining cross-platform stability. This fix should be prioritized for users on macOS platforms.

Conclusion

The Genesis project is actively evolving with numerous contributions addressing both functional enhancements and critical bug fixes. Notably, PRs like #163 and #92 address significant usability issues, while others like #135 introduce valuable new features. The community's engagement through these contributions is vital for the project's continued success.

Report On: Fetch Files For Assessment

Analysis of Source Code Files

1. examples/locomotion/go2_backflip.py

• Structure & Organization: The code is well-organized with clear separation of configuration, environment class, and main execution logic.
• Functionality: This script sets up a backflip environment using the Go2Env class, initializes configurations for the environment, observations, rewards, and commands, and runs a simulation loop using a pre-trained policy.
• Code Quality:
  • The use of dictionaries for configuration is straightforward and allows easy modification.
  • The BackflipEnv class extends Go2Env and overrides methods to customize behavior.
  • The main function uses argparse for command-line argument parsing, which is a good practice for flexibility.
• Potential Improvements:
  • Consider adding comments or docstrings for functions to improve readability.
  • Error handling could be improved in the main() function when loading the policy.

2. genesis/logging/time_elapser.py

• Structure & Organization: The file contains a single class TimeElapser, which is designed to log elapsed time in a separate thread.
• Functionality: The class uses threading to periodically log elapsed time with an optional emoji representation.
• Code Quality:
  • The use of threading is appropriate for non-blocking logging.
  • The class is designed to be used with a context manager (with statement), which is a clean approach for resource management.
• Issues:
  • There are duplicate __enter__ and __exit__ methods that do nothing; these should be removed or implemented correctly.
• Potential Improvements:
  • Add type hints for better clarity on expected input types.
  • Ensure that the logger's interface is well-defined and documented.

3. genesis/grad/creation_ops.py

• Structure & Organization: This file wraps PyTorch tensor creation operations with additional functionality provided by Genesis.
• Functionality: Provides wrappers around PyTorch tensor creation functions to integrate with Genesis's tensor system.
• Code Quality:
  • The use of dynamic function creation via string manipulation (exec) is clever but can be risky and hard to debug. Consider using decorators or metaprogramming techniques instead.
  • The _is_float and _is_int helper functions improve readability by encapsulating type checks.
• Potential Improvements:
  • Improve error messages in exception handling for better debugging information.
  • Consider documenting the purpose of each wrapper function.

4. examples/smoke.py

• Structure & Organization: This example script demonstrates smoke simulation using Genesis's capabilities.
• Functionality: Sets up a scene with jets that simulate smoke dynamics and saves frames as images using OpenCV.
• Code Quality:
  • Good use of Taichi for high-performance simulations.
  • The code is modular with clear separation between initialization, simulation setup, and execution phases.
• Potential Improvements:
  • Add more comments or docstrings to explain complex mathematical operations or transformations.
  • Consider parameterizing some hardcoded values (e.g., resolution, number of steps) for easier experimentation.

5. genesis/engine/entities/sf_entity.py

• Structure & Organization: Defines an entity class for stable fluid simulations extending from a particle-based entity class.
• Functionality: Provides basic methods related to particle processing within stable fluid simulations.
• Code Quality:
  • The class structure follows good OOP practices by extending functionality from a base class (ParticleEntity).
  • Some methods are placeholders (process_input, _add_to_solver_, sample) indicating incomplete implementation or future work needed.
• Potential Improvements:
  • Implement or remove placeholder methods to avoid confusion about the intended functionality.

6. .pre-commit-config.yaml

• Structure & Organization: Configures pre-commit hooks using Black for code formatting.
• Functionality: Ensures consistent code style across the project by automatically formatting Python files before commits.
• Code Quality:
  • Simple and effective configuration leveraging Black's capabilities.
• Potential Improvements:
  • Consider adding more hooks for linting (e.g., flake8) or security checks (e.g., bandit).

7. .gitmodules

• Structure & Organization: Manages Git submodules used within the project.
• Functionality: Includes documentation and external libraries as submodules, which are crucial for project dependencies and extensions.
• Code Quality:
  • Clearly specifies paths and URLs for submodules, ensuring easy updates and maintenance.

8. .github/workflows/Dockerfile

• Structure & Organization: Defines a Docker image setup for CI/CD purposes with CUDA support.
• Functionality: Sets up an environment with Python, PyTorch, and necessary dependencies for running tests on GPU-enabled machines.
• Code Quality:
  • Uses best practices like non-root user creation and virtual environments within Docker containers.
• Security Concerns:
  • Storing passwords in Dockerfiles is insecure; consider using environment variables or secrets management solutions.

9. .github/workflows/ci.yml

• Structure & Organization: Configures GitHub Actions workflow for continuous integration testing on push and pull requests to the main branch.
• Functionality: Automates testing processes including code formatting checks with Black and running unit tests in a Docker container with GPU support.
• Code Quality:
  • Well-organized steps in the CI pipeline ensure comprehensive testing before code integration into the main branch.

Overall, the files demonstrate good coding practices with room for minor improvements in documentation, error handling, and security considerations.

Report On: Fetch commits

Development Team and Recent Activity

Team Members and Activities

• YilingQiao:

  • Worked on adding pre-commit hooks and format checks in CI.
  • Merged multiple pull requests related to documentation fixes and code formatting.
  • Collaborated with Ziyan Xiong and others on various tasks.

• Ziyan Xiong (ziyanx02):

  • Added backflip evaluation documentation and fixed typos.
  • Collaborated with YilingQiao on locomotion-related files.

• Ikko Eltociear Ashimine (eltociear):

  • Updated time_elapser.py for minor corrections.

• CharlesCNorton:

  • Corrected numbering in the "What is Genesis?" feature list in the README.

• Zhenjia Xu (zhenjia-xu):

  • Fixed a bug in the from_torch method.
  • Updated README and added timeout information for PPO environments.

• Zhaojing Yang (yang-zj1026):

  • Added timeout information to environment files.

• Johnson, Tsun Hsuan, Wang (zswang666):

  • Fixed silent FFMPEG failure issues.

• Yin Jie (sjtuyinjie):

  • Made updates to the README file.

• Rob Royce (RobRoyce):

  • Fixed silent failure when FFMPEG is not installed.
  • Merged updates from the main branch into his branch.

• Sang Min Kim (sangminkim-99):

  • Fixed minor typos in the README file.

• Zhou Xian (zhouxian):

  • Made significant contributions with a large number of changes across many files, including initial setup and release preparations.

• Pingchuan Ma (PingchuanMa):

  • Added smoke simulation examples and related files.

• Abhay Deshpande (abhaybd):

  • Fixed a bug in the from_torch method.

Patterns, Themes, and Conclusions

1. Active Collaboration: There is significant collaboration among team members, particularly involving YilingQiao, Ziyan Xiong, and Zhenjia Xu. This indicates a strong team dynamic focused on improving both functionality and documentation.

2. Frequent Updates: The team is actively maintaining the project with frequent updates to both code and documentation. This includes bug fixes, feature enhancements, and formatting improvements.

3. Documentation Focus: Several commits are dedicated to updating and correcting documentation, suggesting an emphasis on clarity and user-friendliness.

4. CI/CD Enhancements: Recent activities include setting up pre-commit hooks and CI checks, reflecting a focus on maintaining code quality and consistency across the project.

5. Diverse Contributions: The contributions range from bug fixes to major feature additions, indicating a broad scope of ongoing development efforts within the team.