Quantify issues

Recent GitHub Issues Activity

_{Like all software activity quantification, these numbers are imperfect but sometimes useful. Comments, Labels, and Milestones refer to those issues opened in the timespan in question.}

Rate pull requests

PR#1210 - fix: Update help docs for resume CLI argopen

2_/5

Vineet (vineetjohn)Created: 2025-02-12

The pull request addresses a minor documentation issue by correcting the CLI argument reference from '--session' to '--name'. While it is a necessary fix to prevent user confusion, the change is trivial, involving only a couple of lines in the help documentation. The PR lacks complexity, significance, or broader impact on the codebase, making it a straightforward and minor update. Therefore, it warrants a rating of 2 as it is an insignificant change with no notable flaws.

[+] Read More

PR#1016 - feat: tool calling emulation (experiment/WIP)open

3_/5

Michael Neale (michaelneale)Created: 2025-02-01

The pull request introduces a moderately significant change with the addition of a new feature for tool calling emulation. However, it is still in draft status, indicating that it may not be complete or fully tested. The changes involve a large addition of code, which could introduce complexity and potential bugs. The PR lacks thorough documentation or comments explaining the new functionality, which could hinder future maintenance and understanding by other developers. Overall, it's an average contribution with room for improvement in clarity and completeness.

[+] Read More

PR#1048 - feat: add goose configure flow for adjusting amt of tool output shownopen

3_/5

marcelle (laanak08)Created: 2025-02-03

The pull request introduces a new configuration flow for adjusting tool output verbosity, which is a useful feature addition. However, it is not particularly significant or complex, involving only minor changes to existing files with a net addition of 39 lines. The change defaults to verbose logging, aligning with user preferences, but the overall impact on the project is moderate. The implementation appears straightforward without notable flaws or innovations, making it an average contribution.

[+] Read More

PR#1099 - add mcpx MCP server to servers.jsonopen

3_/5

Steve Manuel (nilslice)Created: 2025-02-05

The pull request adds a new MCP server to the servers.json file, which is a straightforward change with 12 lines added. It introduces a potentially useful feature by integrating the mcpx server, allowing dynamic tool updates via mcp.run. However, the PR lacks thorough documentation and clarity on how it fits into the existing system, as highlighted by reviewer comments. The licensing update is a positive aspect, but overall, the change is relatively minor and not without its ambiguities.

[+] Read More

PR#1175 - feat: Shared config for CLI and desktop appopen

3_/5

lily-deCreated: 2025-02-10

The pull request introduces a shared configuration feature for both CLI and desktop applications, which is a moderately significant change. It includes a substantial amount of code with new files and modifications across multiple components. However, the PR is still in draft status, indicating it might not be complete or fully tested. The repeated rebasing suggests ongoing adjustments, which may point to unresolved issues or changes in scope. While the addition of OpenAPI schema generation is a positive aspect, the overall impact and quality cannot be fully assessed until the draft is finalized.

[+] Read More

PR#1169 - feat: tutorial extensionopen

3_/5

Bradley Axen (baxen)Created: 2025-02-10

The pull request introduces a new tutorial feature to the project, which is a significant addition. However, the implementation appears to be a first pass and is acknowledged by the author as needing improvements. The feedback from reviewers is generally positive but highlights areas for enhancement, such as clarity in instructions and integration with existing SDKs. The changes are substantial, adding new files and modifying existing ones, which indicates a considerable amount of work. However, the need for further refinement and the initial nature of the implementation suggest that it is not yet exemplary or complete, warranting an average rating.

[+] Read More

PR#1201 - easter eggopen

3_/5

Max Novich (Kvadratni)Created: 2025-02-12

This pull request introduces a fun and creative easter egg feature with a battle game interface, adding several new assets and a significant amount of code. While the feature is entertaining and well-implemented, it is not a critical or highly impactful change to the core functionality of the application. The PR does not introduce any apparent security risks or major bugs, but its significance is limited to enhancing user experience rather than improving core functionality or performance. Thus, it is rated as average.

[+] Read More

PR#1199 - WIP: Add Abilities to read ignore files to Restrict access to filesopen

3_/5

ZhenLianCreated: 2025-02-12

The pull request introduces a new feature to read and apply ignore files, which is a useful addition for managing file access. However, the implementation is still in draft status and lacks comprehensive testing, as indicated by the commented-out test cases. The code changes are substantial, with over 300 lines added, but the lack of active tests raises concerns about robustness and reliability. Additionally, there are minor changes in configuration files that seem unrelated to the main feature. Overall, while the PR has potential, it requires further refinement and testing before it can be considered complete.

[+] Read More

PR#1045 - feat: Support OpenAI reasoning effort configuration for O1/O3 modelsopen

4_/5

da-moonCreated: 2025-02-03

This pull request introduces a significant feature by adding support for configuring reasoning effort in OpenAI's O1 and O3 models, which enhances the flexibility of model behavior without code modification. The changes are well-documented, with comprehensive module and function-level documentation, and include extensive test coverage to ensure robustness. The PR also improves code quality through refactoring and better organization. However, there were some initial build issues and minor formatting problems that needed addressing, preventing it from being exemplary.

[+] Read More

PR#1147 - feat: tool calling shim for models without native tool calling / structured output capabilitiesopen

4_/5

Alice Hau (ahau-square)Created: 2025-02-07

The pull request introduces a significant feature by adding a tool calling shim for models lacking native tool calling capabilities. It includes comprehensive changes across multiple files, adding substantial new code and functionality. The implementation appears thorough, with multiple commits showing iterative development and testing. However, the PR is still in draft status, which may indicate incomplete aspects or pending reviews. The changes are quite good and significant, but the draft status prevents it from being rated as exemplary.

[+] Read More

Quantify commits

Quantified Commit Activity Over 14 Days

Developer	Avatar	Branches	PRs	Commits	Files	Changes
Angie Jones		2	21/20/1	33	1404	49421
Ebony Louis		3	6/6/0	15	446	21088
Wendy Tang		6	8/7/2	21	257	20647
lily-de		7	5/5/0	25	103	10765
Max Novich		3	3/2/0	9	240	10571
Kalvin C		3	11/12/1	18	340	8877
Rizel Scarlett		2	3/3/0	8	247	8353
Bradley Axen		3	4/3/0	5	227	7604
Alex Hancock		3	3/3/0	5	43	5180
Salman Mohammed		3	15/13/2	17	220	4768
Yingjie He		4	7/8/1	12	257	4754
Michael Neale		4	14/9/6	13	205	4571
marcelle		3	4/3/0	6	194	4175
Alice Hau		4	6/5/0	11	28	1751
Adewale Abati		2	3/4/0	5	26	1427
Alice Hau		2	0/0/0	11	6	917
None (damienrj)		1	1/0/1	5	3	511
None (ZhenLian)		1	1/0/0	2	3	345
Yuku Kotani		1	1/1/0	1	10	293
Nahiyan Khan		1	2/2/0	3	7	92
Finn		1	0/0/0	1	3	64
Zaki Ali		1	2/2/0	2	4	62
evalstate		2	1/1/0	3	1	60
David Soria Parra		1	1/1/0	1	1	53
Jannik Maierhöfer		1	1/1/0	1	1	40
Yuta Hinokuma		1	1/1/0	1	1	24
Vincent H.		1	2/1/1	1	4	22
Success Kingsley		1	2/2/0	2	3	20
Nick Johnson		1	1/1/0	1	3	17
TechnoHouse		1	1/1/0	1	1	15
nick-w-nick		1	3/3/0	3	4	14
Will		1	1/1/0	1	1	4
MiladNazeri		1	0/1/0	1	1	4
Jeremy Collins		1	1/1/0	1	1	3
Yurii		1	4/1/3	1	1	2
Sorawit Suriyakarn		1	1/1/0	1	1	2
Andrew Fong		1	1/1/0	1	1	2
Alex Rosenzweig		1	1/1/0	1	1	2
Ben Levy (blevz)		0	1/0/1	0	0	0
None (thxsh)		0	1/0/1	0	0	0
None (royv18)		0	1/0/1	0	0	0
Burak Varlı (unexge)		0	2/0/2	0	0	0
None (da-moon)		0	1/0/0	0	0	0
S (sebyx07)		0	1/0/1	0	0	0
None (0xflotus)		0	1/0/1	0	0	0
Steve Manuel (nilslice)		0	1/0/0	0	0	0
Ikko Eltociear Ashimine (eltociear)		0	1/0/1	0	0	0
Austin Mackillop (amackillop)		0	1/0/0	0	0	0
Jason Kneen (jasonkneen)		0	25/0/25	0	0	0
Vineet (vineetjohn)		0	1/0/0	0	0	0
Prem Pillai (cloud-on-prem)		0	0/0/1	0	0	0
None (jacksondengky)		0	1/0/1	0	0	0
eternal-ai-org (eternal-ai-org)		0	1/0/1	0	0	0
None (techknowlogick)		0	2/0/0	0	0	0

_{PRs: created by that dev and opened/merged/closed-unmerged during the period}

Quantify risks

Project Risk Ratings

Report On: Fetch issues

Recent Activity Analysis

Recent activity in the "block/goose" repository shows a high volume of issue creation, with several issues opened and closed within the last few days. Notably, many issues are related to configuration errors, compatibility with different models, and feature requests for enhanced functionality. There is a significant focus on improving user experience, as seen in issues related to UI enhancements and error handling. Additionally, there are ongoing discussions about extending support to more platforms and models.

Notable Anomalies and Themes

1. Configuration and Compatibility Issues: Several issues (#1159, #1161, #1163) highlight problems with configuring Goose for specific models or environments, such as AWS Bedrock and Databricks. These issues often involve errors related to API requests or environment variables.

2. Platform Support: There is a recurring theme of users requesting support for additional platforms, particularly Windows (#864, #863). This indicates a demand for broader accessibility across different operating systems.

3. Error Handling and User Feedback: Issues like #856 and #902 focus on improving error messages and handling scenarios where Goose encounters unexpected states. This suggests an ongoing effort to enhance the robustness of the tool.

4. Extensibility and Customization: Requests for new features, such as support for additional LLM providers (#1155, #936) and customization options (#884), indicate a strong interest in making Goose more versatile and adaptable to various use cases.

5. User Interface Enhancements: Several issues (#1010, #1015) address UI improvements, such as better session handling and link management. This reflects a focus on improving the overall user experience.

6. Security Concerns: Issues like #189 highlight concerns about potentially dangerous commands being executed by Goose, prompting discussions about implementing safer command execution practices.

Issue Details

Most Recently Created Issues

• #1217: UI/UX considerations for navigating between conversations (Created 0 days ago)
• #1216: Bug report titled "h6" (Created 0 days ago)
• #1215: Feature request for auto-discovering existing ollama models (Created 0 days ago)

Most Recently Updated Issues

• #1161: Databricks configuration error (Updated 1 day ago)
• #1163: Orphaned processes causing rebuild issues (Updated 3 days ago)
• #1159: OpenRouter usage data error (Updated 5 days ago)

These issues reflect ongoing efforts to address both technical challenges and user experience improvements within the project. The rapid creation and updating of issues suggest active community engagement and responsiveness from the development team.

Report On: Fetch pull requests

Analysis of Pull Requests for "block/goose" Repository

Open Pull Requests

Notable Open PRs

1. PR #1210: Update help docs for resume CLI arg

   • State: Open
   • Created: 1 day ago
   • Description: This PR addresses an issue with the CLI argument help text, correcting the reference from --session to --name. This is a minor but important fix for user clarity.
   • Files Changed: crates/goose-cli/src/main.rs
   • Notable: Fixes a documentation error which could lead to user confusion.

2. PR #1201: Easter egg

   • State: Open
   • Created: 1 day ago
   • Description: Introduces an easter egg feature with several updates and animations. This PR adds new assets and modifies UI components.
   • Files Changed: Multiple files including new assets and UI components.
   • Notable: Adds a fun, non-critical feature that enhances user engagement.

3. PR #1199: Add Abilities to read ignore files

   • State: Open
   • Created: 2 days ago
   • Description: A draft PR aimed at adding functionality to read .gooseignore files, enhancing file access control.
   • Files Changed: Includes changes to Cargo.toml and new code in developer/mod.rs.
   • Notable: Enhances security by restricting file access, though still in draft.

4. PR #1175: Shared config for CLI and desktop app

   • State: Open
   • Created: 3 days ago
   • Description: Proposes shared configuration between CLI and desktop applications, indicating significant integration work.
   • Files Changed: Extensive changes across multiple files.
   • Notable: A major enhancement that could streamline configuration management across platforms.

5. PR #1169: Tutorial extension

   • State: Open
   • Created: 3 days ago
   • Description: Introduces a tutorial extension aimed at improving user onboarding with guided tutorials.
   • Files Changed: Adds new tutorial-related files and modifies existing ones.
   • Notable: Potentially improves user experience by providing structured learning paths.

Concerns with Open PRs

• Several open PRs are marked as drafts (e.g., #1199, #1147), indicating they are not ready for merging. These should be monitored for progress towards completion.
• The large number of open PRs (48) may indicate a backlog or bottleneck in the review process, which could slow down development cycles.

Closed Pull Requests

Notable Closed PRs

1. PR #1213: Revert #1138

   • State: Closed
   • Merged by: Bradley Axen
   • Description: Reverts a previous change due to build failures related to TLS dependencies.
   • Notable: Highlights an issue with dependency management that required urgent attention.

2. PR #1207: Endpoints for config management via goose-server

   • State: Closed
   • Merged by: Alex Hancock
   • Description: Adds new endpoints for configuration management, facilitating better server-side config handling.
   • Notable: Enhances server capabilities, potentially improving overall system robustness.

3. PR #1206 & #1205

   • Both involve documentation updates and workflow fixes, respectively, showing ongoing efforts to improve project documentation and CI/CD processes.

Concerns with Closed PRs

• Some closed PRs were merged very quickly (e.g., within a day), which might suggest either efficient handling or insufficient review time.
• The revert of PR #1138 indicates potential instability introduced by recent changes, suggesting the need for more rigorous testing before merging complex features.

General Observations

• The project is actively maintained with numerous contributions from various developers, indicating a healthy open-source community.
• The presence of many draft and open PRs suggests ongoing development but also highlights potential areas where process improvements could be made to handle reviews more efficiently.
• The repository's focus on extensibility and comprehensive documentation supports its popularity and usability within the AI developer community.

Overall, while the project shows strong activity and community involvement, attention should be given to managing open PRs effectively to maintain momentum and ensure quality in new features and fixes.

Report On: Fetch Files For Assessment

Analysis of Source Code Files

1. providers_and_keys.json

• Structure and Content: The file is a JSON configuration detailing various providers, their models, and required keys. It includes entries for providers like OpenAI, Anthropic, Databricks, Google, etc.
• Quality: The structure is straightforward and well-organized. Each provider has a clear set of attributes (name, description, models, required_keys).
• Observations: Some descriptions are placeholders ("Lorem ipsum"), which could be improved for clarity. The file is crucial for managing API keys and provider configurations.

2. config_management.rs

• Structure: This Rust file defines several endpoints using the Axum framework for configuration management. It includes routes for upserting, removing, reading configurations, and managing extensions.
• Quality: The code is well-structured with appropriate use of Rust's async features and error handling. The use of structured data types (UpsertConfigQuery, ConfigKeyQuery) enhances readability.
• Observations: The file uses a global configuration object which might become a bottleneck if not managed properly. Consideration for concurrent access and potential race conditions should be addressed.

3. openai.rs

• Structure: This file contains functions to format messages and tools for OpenAI's API, handle responses, and manage tool schemas.
• Quality: The code is comprehensive with detailed logic to handle different message types and tool interactions. It includes extensive test coverage.
• Observations: The file is quite large (781 lines), which might affect maintainability. Breaking down into smaller modules could improve readability and manageability.

4. configure.rs

• Structure: This Rust file handles CLI configuration commands for Goose. It includes logic for setting up providers, managing extensions, and handling errors.
• Quality: The code is user-friendly with clear prompts and error messages. It effectively uses Rust's pattern matching and error handling capabilities.
• Observations: The CLI interactions are well-designed but could benefit from additional comments explaining complex logic sections.

5. utils.tsx

• Structure: A TypeScript utility file for handling API keys in the UI component of the Goose project.
• Quality: Functions are concise and focused on specific tasks like checking if a key is secret or fetching active providers.
• Observations: Error handling in asynchronous functions is present but could be enhanced with more descriptive error messages or retry mechanisms.

6. google-drive-mcp.md

• Structure: A markdown tutorial for integrating Google Drive as a Goose extension.
• Quality: The documentation is clear with step-by-step instructions, code snippets, and visual aids (YouTube embed).
• Observations: The tutorial is comprehensive but could include troubleshooting tips or common issues users might face during setup.

7. mod.rs (Developer Module)

• Structure: This Rust module provides functionalities related to development tools within the Goose MCP framework.
• Quality: The code is extensive with detailed implementations for shell commands, text editing operations, and screen capture functionalities.
• Observations: At 1264 lines, this file is quite large and could benefit from refactoring into smaller modules or files to enhance maintainability. Additionally, concurrency considerations should be reviewed given the use of shared state (file_history).

General Observations

The project appears well-organized with a focus on extensibility and user interaction through both CLI and UI components. However, some files are quite large, which might impact maintainability over time. Consideration for breaking down these files into smaller components could improve readability and ease future modifications. Additionally, enhancing error handling across various components would improve robustness against runtime issues.

Report On: Fetch commits

Repo Commits Analysis

Development Team and Recent Activity

Team Members and Activities

1. Bradley Axen (baxen)

   • Recent work includes reverting changes, simplifying CLI sessions, and supporting system prompt extensions.
   • Collaborated with Lily Delalande on configuration management endpoints.
   • Active in multiple branches with significant contributions to the tutorial and configuration features.

2. Alex Hancock (alexhancock)

   • Added endpoints for configuration management, improved auto-scroll features, and worked on better typing for preload scripts.
   • Collaborated with Lily Delalande on shared configuration client development.

3. Michael Neale (michaelneale)

   • Worked on handling images in messages, improved JSON-RPC notification handling, and updated quarantine workflows.
   • Engaged in multiple branches focusing on deepseek tools and gosling features.

4. Rizel Scarlett (blackgirlbytes)

   • Fixed website preview actions and added clarity about resuming sessions in documentation.
   • Worked on formatting text and popover features.

5. Angie Jones (angiejones)

   • Contributed extensively to documentation, including tutorials and troubleshooting guides.
   • Deployed multiple previews for documentation updates.

6. Wendy Tang (wendytang)

   • Implemented features for removing extensions, fixed lint errors, and validated JSON schemas.
   • Collaborated with Angie Jones on documentation updates.

7. Yuku Kotani (yukukotani)

   • Supported VertexAI for Claude integration.

8. TechnoHouse (deephbz)

   • Modified Azure OpenAI API version support.

9. Will Medrano (wmedrano)

   • Improved usage of the rg tool.

10. Lily Delalande (lily-de)

    • Focused on shared configuration management and provider refactoring.
    • Worked closely with Alex Hancock on shared configuration client development.

11. Alice Hau (ahau-square)

    • Worked on structured output requests for Ollama provider.
    • Engaged in tool shim development.

12. Yingjie He (yingjiehe-xyz)

    • Consistently used LANGFUSE_URL, applied cache control correctly, and handled empty arguments in tool calls.

13. Kalvin C (kalvinnchau)

    • Updated session calculations, followed XDG specs, and re-added tests for CLI configurations.

14. Max Novich (Kvadratni)

    • Developed an Easter egg feature and worked on transcribe functionalities.

15. Nick W-Nick (nick-w-nick)

    • Added dynamic links to the homepage from the extensions site and included a favicon.

16. Salman Mohammed (salman1993)

    • Released version updates, fixed config YAML writing issues, and improved logging for Goose runs.

17. Andrew Fong (fongandrew)

    • Fixed ellipsis in loading states.

18. Evalstate

    • Fixed cached token usage count logs for Anthropic provider.

19. Ebony Louis (EbonyLouis)

    • Added Google Drive MCP Extension tutorial and addressed Mac M3 permission troubleshooting in documentation.

20. Marcelle (laanak08)

    • Fixed issues related to empty message submissions and improved configure flow for tool output verbosity.

21. Yuta Hinokuma (higumachan)

    • Addressed IME input issues in the desktop app.

22. Nahiyan Khan (nahiyankhan)

    • Made UI tweaks to tool call interfaces and fixed app reload crashes.

23. Success Kingsley (xosnrdev)

    • Used Clap's built-in version command for CLI improvements.

24. Adewale Abati (acekyd)

    • Updated docs for GitHub MCP tutorial and improved deployment workflows for docs & extensions.

25. Zaki Ali (zakiali)

    • Allowed multiple values in CLI options for adding extensions and added links to GitHub projects on extension cards.

26. David Soria Parra (dsp-ant)

    • Improved JSON-RPC notification handling to match specifications.

27. Sorawit Suriyakarn (sorawit)

    • Fixed typos in DeveloperRouter prompts.

28. Nick Johnson (nyonson)

    • Ensured terminal emulator's base colors are respected in CLI prompts.

29. Yurii Sokyran (sokyran)

    • Added fallback sans-serif font to the desktop app UI configuration.

30. Jannik Maierhöfer (jannikmaierhoefer)

    • Authored Langfuse observability guide documentation.

31. Finn Block (finn-block)

    • Added PR previews for the documentation site workflow.

32. Jeremy Collins (beetlebugorg)

    • Allowed port 443 usage with HTTPS for Ollama provider configurations.

33. Vincent H. (tiensi)

    • Updated spelling corrections across documentation files.

34. Alex Rosenzweig (shellz-n-stuff)

    • Introduced PR-level security scans into the workflow processes.

35. Milad Nazeri

    • Updated supported environments information to prevent confusion regarding macOS app compatibility on x86 systems.

Patterns, Themes, Conclusions

• The team is actively engaged in both feature development and bug fixing across multiple branches.
• Collaboration is evident among team members, particularly between Lily Delalande and Alex Hancock on shared configuration management.
• Documentation is a significant focus area, with Angie Jones leading efforts to keep it up-to-date.
• The project shows a strong emphasis on CI/CD practices with numerous workflow files indicating automated testing, building, and deployment processes.
• There is an ongoing effort to enhance user experience through UI improvements, as seen in contributions by Nahiyan Khan and Max Novich.
• The team is responsive to community feedback, as indicated by frequent updates to address issues reported by users or contributors.
• The project maintains a high level of activity with regular commits from a diverse set of contributors working across various aspects of the project including core functionalities, UI enhancements, documentation updates, and infrastructure improvements.